Jenny and I had just broken up and she had started seeing Jeremy. I was letting Jenny stay at my trailer until she got something else worked out. She wasn't supposed to be having Jeremy stay with her, but I knew that she was letting him stay.
Jenny was working at Subway. I would call her at work and would talk to her when she was on her break. I had called her out about letting him stay with her in my trailer and she cried, saying she was sorry, but was scared to stay by herself. I told her she was going to have to do something to make it up to me, or she'd have to move out of my trailer. Again, she was crying, but said she'd do anything.
I told her that I wanted to come over, and for me, her, and him to have a threesome together.
She said she would talk to him about it and see what he said.
A couple of days later, I called her at work to see what was up. She said he had agreed to it, and asked me to come over that night, around 8:00pm.
I showered and shaved, and was at my old trailer at about 8:15pm.
This was my place, where I had stayed with Jenny for years, up until a few weeks ago. But, man, had shit changed dramatically in those few weeks. I was nervous as hell, and I definitely felt like I was the guest who was just visiting, and not like I was the owner. In all seriousness, this was where Jeremy and Jenny were staying, and I was there only because they had invited me over.
I couldn't believe how unhinged this visit had me feeling, and I wondered if they were nervous, too. My palms were sweaty, my hands were shaking, and I paused outside thinking, maybe I shouldn't go through with this thing. I knew this was my last chance to change my mind and back out. How had I grown so distant from Jenny in such a short period of time? How had Jeremy managed to take such firm control over the girl I had dated for years? How had they taken over my trailer to the point I was having second thoughts of wanting to go inside?
I strained to regain myself and told myself this was my house and my girlfriend and only a pussy would let Jeremy intimidate him. I must say I only partially made myself feel better, and as I knocked on my own door, my knees were shaking and my mouth was so dry I could barely swallow.
After nobody came to the door, I realized my knock had been so light nobody had heard it. I tried to be more sure of myself as I knocked again, with more power behind my fist this time.
I must have done better because I heard Jeremy say, "Jenny that must be your li'l boy, let him in."
I was sort of mad and had intentions of saying something to Jenny about the 'li'l boy' shit when she let me in.
The door opened, but she never showed herself, and I heard her little footsteps trail off back towards the living room. I walked in and could see that the lights and TV were on in the living room. As I shut the back door, I looked towards my old bedroom. I could hear the shower and caught a glimpse of Jeremy as he was getting in the shower. I hadn't remembered him being such a muscled-up guy. He had stout legs and a thick ass that surely had thrusting stamina, well beyond my own. His tattoos, mixed with his ripped torso, made me aware that I hoped he wasn't mad about my visit.
What really tore into me were the deep, well-defined scratch marks that ran from his wide shoulders all the way down to the small of his back. I'd seen these before, and recognized them to be left by Jenny's tiny hands as he had brought her to a Earth-shattering orgasm. By the looks of them, Jeremy must have fucked Jenny only minutes before I had knocked on the door.
I walked into the living room, concerned about why they had so recently fucked if our plan was still in play. I remembered what I was here for when I laid eyes on Jenny. She had on a pair of daisy dukes that showed off her sexy, although, short legs and a tight-fitting, white tank-top that had all her beautiful cleavage on display.
She lit a cigarette as I took a moment to appreciate just how fine this girl truly was. Her thick dark hair was shiny, and looked like something any man would love to have his hands in. It was obvious she had been lying out in the sun by how brown her silky skin was. I found myself thinking how was I stupid enough to let this one get away.
In that instant, I wanted her worse than I ever had. I felt so moved by her beauty in that moment, I had to let her know, but made sure not to be loud enough that he could hear me from the bathroom. I whispered to Jenny, "God, you are so pretty and I want to fuck you so bad I can hardly stand to wait another second."
She didn't move from her position on the couch, but just sat there smoking her cigarette. I knew she had heard me, and I was puzzled why she hadn't even acknowledged my comment to her. I sensed that somehow something was not right, or she would have looked me in the eye. I stared at her sitting there silent, and the fear began to grow quickly. I was really starting to get scared, so I called out to her in a desperate voice, "Jenny!"
She must have heard in my voice that I was getting uneasy, as she finally turned her head to look at me.
As she did, I had a clear view of her face and my jaw dropped and I made an audible gasp.
Tears streamed down her cheeks, and she had the worst black eye I had ever seen on a woman.
"Oh my god! What happened?" I said, in a voice barely more than a whisper. "Jenny, did he do that to you?" I asked her.
Still, she said nothing, and gave me nothing in the way of an answer. We just sat there, looking at each other in silence.
"Hey, lover boy, come here a minute I want to talk to you," barked Jeremy from the bedroom.
His voice startled me somewhat, but it was Jenny's reaction that really concerned me. She had physically jumped and began to tremble from his words. I looked at her, trying to gauge what I was getting into, and she saw fear in my eyes and began crying harder.
"Hey, didn't you hear me?" Jeremy questioned.
This whole getting-to-fuck-Jenny-again scheme suddenly seemed like a dumb idea to me.
I walked to the bedroom, not sure of what to expect. I glanced at the back door and wanted to run, but told myself I was too much of a man to just leave her here helpless with this asshole. I tried to wipe any sign of fear off my face, then opened the door and walked in.
He was standing in the bathroom, wearing just a towel, still dripping wet from the shower. He said, "Don't be scared. I just wanna talk, man to man; shut the door."
I hadn't hid my fear very well, but tried once again, as I shut the door before turning back to face him. "Look, maybe this is a bad time--" I started to say.
He cut me off. "No, hell no, no time like the present."
He walked right up to me, and I thought he was gonna punch me, but instead, he dropped his towel and stood there completely naked, which made me quickly look away.
"Look at me; we need to get this out of the way," he said.
I looked at him, and again, I thought he was much more muscled up than I remembered him being. I just stared at his build and tattoos, unsure of what else to do. While trying to keep focused on his upper body, I could see out of the corner of my eye that his cock hung limp and heavy, in clear view for anyone to see.
"Go ahead, get a look at me, okay?"
I knew what he meant, but I couldn't bring myself to check him out, so I just looked down at the floor.
He stepped closer to me, bringing his cock right in front of my face. "I said for you to look, and that's what you're gonna do, one way or the other."
I was sure I was ten shades of red, and also jealous of his manly sized cock. It was totally limp, but hung at least five inches in length, with a heavy set of shaven balls up under it.
I looked up and began to check out his cock, scared of what he might do if I didn't. I felt sick as I got a better look at his cock. It was more impressive soft than mine was hard. I could only imagine what a monster it would turn into when fully erect. I was getting the closest look at another man's cock I had ever had in my entire life. Jeremy really had a nice cock on him, as much as I hated to admit it to myself. I found that I really enjoyed being allowed to study another man's cock so closely. It truly was a beautiful cock and I completely understood why Jenny would have been so impressed with it, as compared to my own.
I thought of how small and useless I would appear, if I pulled my li'l dick out and brought it beside his and let her compare the two, side by side. I was lost in the moment and caught off guard, when he said, "That's more like it, get you a good look at what Jenny has been getting lately."
Damn, I was embarrassed at how much I had been enjoying looking at Jeremy's cock. I liked getting such a good view of it that my dick had gotten hard from looking at it.
"We got to be able to be naked around each other if we are going to have a threesome, so go ahead, and take off your clothes, Chuck," Jeremy instructed.
"I really don't want to, right now," I said, rather quietly.