I looked down to where John was laying, snoring lightly, his lean naked body half-covered by the sheet that had pulled down over the edge of the bed. He looked so peaceful lying there like a little kitten - no one would have thought he had just thrown a fuck so hard my ass was still singing praises.
It was difficult for me to control the sounds coming from my mouth as my nipples were rubbed and licked to distraction. Added to the fingers currently ransacking their way into my creamy prostate, and the sinful mouth latching now onto my nipple, now onto my own ruby-streaked lips, all made a perfect picture of sexual debauchery. The fact that the one giving me so much throbbing joy and ecstasy was the one who was blackmailing me - blackmailing us, John and me - was the cherry on top of this scrumptious sundae.
No one would have thought that the very married-with-two-children, gruff manly next-door neighbor would have an inkling of how sex between two men work, but there he was now, between my tired thighs, making easy work of pushing me into another orgasm. And there I was, letting out a reedy little cry into the night air as the fingers in my asshole prodded just one too many times onto my cum-lined prostate and made me took that final leap into a delicious climax. I clutched my thighs together, closing on his hunky dad-body, riding my orgasm as I released my semen onto his hairy chest.
Clark let out a guffaw and smiled, which looked somewhat charming on his rugged face. "Heh fuck, there I made you cum."
"That's not fair, I was already hot from John's fucking."
"A deal's a deal, now let me fuck you."
Truth be told I wasn't entirely displeased with his proposition. Although framed in the circumstances, the idea was really very attractive to me, having to pop the inaugural man-sex cherry of this masculine hunk of a man, with his erstwhile wife unaware back in their home and with John laying beside us. "Okay," I murmured against his collarbone, producing a shudder that ran in his frame. "But let's fuck in the master bedroom. Let John sleep here."
"You're a kinky little shit aren't ya."
"I am, I am."
We marched into the master bedroom, nary a thread between us, all his six-feet-four enormity with broad shoulders and huge arms, and me, fresh cum still streaking across my thighs and dripping from my hole, ready for further abuse. I asked him to lay on the bed as I went into the en-suite for a wash. As I cleaned myself between my thighs the ring that John gave me, my pussy boy ring, glinted in the light. I took a deep sigh, kissed the ring and put it on the counter for later.