We both got dressed and went out into the living room and he put on a movie called Trainspotting which is actually a cool flick. I relaxed on one of the chairs and we both started to watch it. About halfway through the movie, he just blurted out, "So do you want to fuck each other in the ass tonight or are we done?"
I scooted my ass around on the chair as if I was sizing up the pain I was going to be in.
I said, "Ummm...yeah, sure! But I don't know how gentle I can be. Once I get going I'm going to fuck you pretty hard. And when you grabbed my cheeks and pile drove me, it felt good at the time, but wow did it hurt later! This time I want to ride you backwards with my back to you. And call me some names, will ya!"
We both kind of laughed and in a relaxed manner we rubbered up and lubed up and in no time my asshole had a death grip on his thick tool. Now that I knew what to expect it was much more fun! We moved around on the couch and floor until I had a easy time balancing myself as I let him nearly bottom out deep within my body. The extra-thick base of his rod stretched me out something fierce, although he usually kept about an inch of his penis out of my body. Because I was still an anal novice, I was just sort of bobbing an inch or so above the root to keep my anus from being stretched too hard. It felt great to have his cock deep in my body but I knew when he started to come it was going to hurt like hell! He was going to shred my ass for a few seconds, but I knew I could take it. I knew full well I was going to get stretched like a rubber band when the thick base of his dick straining my delicate and inexperienced opening.
"Oh, you are getting so good at taking my cock up your ass", he said softly. "Your ass is so tight."
"I have only had one cock in my ass", I replied glancing back with a sultry and deferential look.
"Yep, my cock", he said as he pulled all the way out and challenged my anus with the head. "One cock in your ass" he repeated as he popped it back inside me.
"It's so fucking thick. I love it. I am becoming your anal whore" I said quietly, facing downward.
"Well, let's figure out if you really are an anal whore", he said, panting, as he continued to slide his tool inside my body. "I'll ask you some questions and you answer them as honestly as you can."
He withdrew his stiff cock all the way out of my ass and pushed the fat, bulbous head against my asshole. "Question number one...Do you want my cock back in your ass?"
"Yes", I said, looking backwards. He re-lubed and slid his cock past my anus and it popped inside, stretching my hole nice and wide, warm and tight. After he penetrated my body with the head, he slid his penis deep inside me and began to move faster. It started to burn, but despite that it felt pretty good. I had the unmistakable sense that the first time we hooked up, he had anal sex with me. This time, I suspected I was about to get fucked in the ass. There is a big difference!
"Question number two...Do you like thick cocks up your ass?"
"Yes, I love your thick cock up my ass", I said facing away from him. He was picking up the pace.
"Question number three...Do you like to hear a guy grunt and groan as he comes deep in your asshole?"
"Yes I love it", I muttered. "I love to hear you scream as you come in my ass."
He lubed up again and began sliding much faster inside me. He was avoiding going that final, extra deep, ass-stretching inch, waiting instead to yawn me open at that final moment of ecstasy. As he put his hands on my hips I knew that special moment was about to arrive.
"Based on your answers, assuming you answered truthfully", he practicaly gasped, "you are an anal, cock loving, ass fucking whore! You're an anal whore!" He began to scream again and again.
"Yes, I am a cock loving anal whore!" I screamed, looking back at him. "Pound my ass with your thick cock! Stretch me with your dick! Work me over with that big dick fast and hard! I want to feel those nuts banging mine!"
"Oh, god I'm close!" he screamed. "I'm going to lose it!"
I glanced over my shoulder and hissed, "Come in my ass! I want to feel you swell up and dump that come in your rubber. Fuck my asshole! Fuck me deep and hard, dammit, fuck my tight virgin ass."
It took all I could do but I eased down until the base of his rod puffed out my hole wide as can be. It felt like someone took four fingers and plunged them deep in my asshole, stretching me wide open. Combined with the earlier anal I'd endured, I was raw, raw, raw! I felt so cheap! I could definitely feel the burn and I knew that the red, chafed feeling the next day was going to be terrible and I screamed in agony.
This orgasm was virtually a carbon copy of his first, replete with him grabbing my waist, skewering me for a few seconds as he wrenched another orgasm into the safety of his condom.
"I'm coming! I'm coming! I'm fucking your ass you fucking anal whore!"
"Yeah that's right!", I said as I dropped down hard on his cock. This time it was me that drove his penis deep beyond those tight, unwilling rectal muscles. I felt his prick fill and spread my bung hole wide and screamed "Fuck my asshole! You're the only one that's ever fucked me deep in my ass!!" I yelled at the top of my lungs, not caring if his neighbors were within earshot.
I can only imagine what he was seeing, and how my distended asshole must have looked with his thick cock rammed up my butt. From his perspective it must have been very exciting because based on his grunts and screams it was quite pleasurable.
As he came he bucked in and out just a fraction of an inch stretching me tight as a drum. This time, painful as it was, I powered my body downward against him and repeatedly pile drove his cock into my body. Pain was just another sensation, adding to the insanity, pleasure, excitement, and confusion of what I was doing.
However, because I was riding him with my back to him the angle was different than the other direction and I liked it a little more. It went in deeper but was more comfortable because of the slight outward arc of his penis.
He finished with me and his thick clock slipped out of my ass and we separated. I was stinging a little but surprisingly not as much as the first time despite the fact that I got fucked much harder this time than last.
"Wow, your asshole's tight!", he said loudly amid heavy breathing. "Look at my condom, there's a double shot of come in there. If you had that much hosed up inside you, you'd be dripping for an hour."
"No chance of that", I smiled. "I'm loving the safe sex thing. It's fun to get fucked in the ass but it's great to know that it's being done safely. I am super-fucking-paranoid about AIDS."