"Take of your clothes Phil. You can leave on your underwear for now." Jason commanded.
Phil complied, hastily removing his shirt when Jason stopped him.
"What's the rush man? Relax. Little slower." Jason chuckled. Phil was perplexed by his casual friendly attitude. The brothers at the head table said nothing while the lights shone on him. Phil revealed his well-defined chest and abs. The cool room caused his small pink nipples to stiffen a little. He removed his shoes and socks then his pants showing his thick legs. They had ample hair, but he trimmed ahead of a date earlier that week making them less hairy than usual. He stood before the committee and his buddy in his tight white briefs. His large glutes filled out the briefs well and the outline of his penis was clearly visible. The situation felt mildly embarrassing but certainly not humiliating. Phil thought it was going pretty well so far.
"Have a seat in the chair bro. I'll secure you in."
Phil did as instructed. Jason walked behind him and picked up the rope which he used to secure his arms and feet to the sides of the chair leaving Phil sitting with his legs open and his arms wresting on the arm rests. Jason sat in the stool next to him and put his elbow on Phil's leg.
"We're going to have a little bro talk okay Phil. You know- one buddy to another. Don't mind those guys." Jason chuckled. He talked to him like he usually would if they were alone. This made it even more unsettling. Phil was beginning to wish Jason would go back to calling him "Brother" and he could go back to calling Jason "Brother Alves". Maybe this was all part of the punishment. He had no clue where it was heading but knew it wasn't anywhere good.
"How was your little date with Jess last night? You told me it went well but I want all the deets," Jason prompted.
Phil was mortified. Jessica was girl from the sister sorority with whom many of the freshman brothers were trying to score. Phil genuinely liked her and tried to keep it secret precisely to avoid conversations like this. Now his best friend was not only letting the other frat brothers know but also forcing him to talk about it.
"What? I.." SLAP. Jason slapped him across his face so hard that his eyes began to water. Phil looked at him in disbelief.
"The next time you start an answer with a question, it'll be harder," said Jason coldly. "Now, back to Jess. Tell be about what happened after the date. I'm your best buddy so I know if you're lying. Remember that."
"We did stuff," replied Phil meekly. The guys at the head table jeered and cheered. "Deets!" one shouted.
"You dirty dog," Jason laughed tousling Phil's hair, "What did you do bro?"
No use in trying to avoid the question. "We had sex." The guys at the front cheered and laughed again.
"Just sex? Nothing else? Did she suck your cock Philly boy?" Jason probed. This seemed like the kind of conversation they'd usually have over beers and video games- not while Phil was tied down to a chair in his underwear.
"Damn Phil. We've fucked chicks together bro so I know you're not small. She fit that whole fat cock of yours in her mouth?" Jason started to gently run his hand on Phil's chest. It lingered at his right nipple. Phil couldn't believe what was going on when Jason squeezed his nipple hard and prompted him back to reality.
"Yes. She put it all in her mouth," Phil answered with a little shiver in his voice.
Jason gently teased the nipple as he pushed Phil to reveal more.
"How did she suck it? Close your eyes and tell me."
Phil had an idea of what was expected of him now. "She started at the tip, using her hands and licking right under the head. Then she licked my precum and went all the way to the base." Jason teased his other nipple while he recounted.
"Nice bro! See that wasn't too hard to talk about. Although something is hard." The guys at the front table laughed. Jason snickered. Phil looked down to see the front of his briefs clearly outlining his erect cock. To make matters worse. A wet spot had formed on the fabric. "Jessica took all that? She must be a fucking champ huh Brother?" shouted a brother at the head table.
"Did she suck those big balls of yours too, bro?"
"Yes," Phil conceded. There was no hiding anything now.
"Didn't realize she was such a freak Phil. I bet you made her eat out your ass didn't you?"
"No! I didn't," Phil was really beginning to feel the embarrassment. A guy liking to have his ass eaten was something he might admit to his best buddy but certainly not to a raucous group of frat bros.
"C'mmon buddy. Don't deny it. You know you like to have that big cyclist booty of yours eaten don't you?" Jason looked him in the eye. Phil had already admitted this to Jason in private so he couldn't lie.
"Yes."
"Yes what?" Jason responded intently.
"Yes. I like to have my big cyclist booty eaten by a girl". More snickers and laughter were heard from the crowd. Phil's erection was still clearly visible and twitching. This did not go unnoticed.
"Damn Philly boy! Our little convo really got you going didn't it? You're fucking leaking and twitching bro! And right in front of your brothers too. Thing about choosing your best buddy to carry out your punishment is that he knows all the right buttons to press." Jason joked as he playfully flicked Phil's nipple. "How long did you last while fucking her bro?"
"Fifteen minutes," responded Phil stoically.
"Tisk tisk. That just won't do Philly boy. You got the Sigma-Phi reputation to uphold every time your fuck a chick. What do you say fellas? Should we help our fellow brother here get up to standard?" The guys responded with cheers.
"I agree! Let's get this underwear off bro. That looks a little uncomfortable anyhow." Jason took a scissors and snipped the sides of briefs. At the second snip, the elastic snapped back to reveal his fully erect 8 inch cock. It was the first time his brothers, except for Jason, had seem him in this state. His pink head peaked through the foreskin and his large balls hung loosely in their sack. The base of his hairy crack was also slightly visible under his gooch. "Nice one Phil!" shouted a brother. He was deeply ashamed to be in this state.
