Frat Daddy

Hey guys! I wrote this as a comission for one of my substack subscribers. Enjoy!

******************************

GORDON

"Son! How the hell are ya?"

My dad hopped out of his Range Rover, his boots crunching in the gravel driveway. He was grinning from ear to ear, sporting his usual flannel, jeans, and baseball cap.

"I'm good, Dad," I said sheepishly as he engulfed me in a big bear hug. I cast a glance back at the fraternity house to make sure none of my new brothers could see my humiliation.

"I missed you, kid." Dad ruffled my hair, then put his arm around me. "Now come on--I wanna see what you all have done with the place since I left."

Dad was a member of Gamma Alpha Upsilon when he was my age, although that was over 20 years ago. He'd been pushing me to rush ever since I got to college, and he was over the moon when I got initiated. To be honest, I was surprised I even got in--sure, the fraternity caters to athletes, and although I've been playing lacrosse for years, I wouldn't exactly call myself a "frat bro". I'm quiet, kind of shy, and not exactly a man's man.

"Whoa, they got rid of that old piece of shit futon," Dad said as he walked inside the den, eying the place from top to bottom. He winked at me. "Lotta fun we had on that thing."

I must have made a face because he nudged me and said, "Oh, don't be such a prude. When I was your age, young people weren't so hung up sexually. We fucked who we wanted and there wasn't anything wrong with it."

I felt my cheeks turn red. Dad was much more brash than me, always confident and never afraid to talk about things like sex or whatever. The complete opposite of me, really. True, we had the same dirty blond hair, but his was short whereas mine was kind of long. And we were both in pretty decent shape, although he'd put on a bit more muscle over the years, whereas I was still pretty lean. But our personalities couldn't be more different: Dad was the life of the party, whereas I was content to be wallpaper.

"Oh, boy... Guess I came in at the wrong time."

I felt my blood run cold when I noticed my fraternity brother Aldis standing in the doorway with a smirk on his face.

Dad let out a bark of a laugh. "Sorry, just reminiscing about the good old days." He reached out his hand. "I'm Randy. Gordon's dad."

Aldis strode over and shook my dad's hand, a glimmer of a smile in his eye. "Aldis. I'm the President of Gamma Alpha Upsilon."

"Aldis, huh?" Dad smiled at me. "Gordon's told me a lot about you."

My face turned bright red at that one. "Dad," I hissed.

"Nice to meet you," Aldis said, thankfully not seeming to take anything more from that.

I was mortified nonetheless. Did he think I'd been blabbing about him to my Dad? He'd been extremely clear that he didn't want me telling anyone about what happened between us that one night during rush. And again during bidding, when he pulled me into the bathroom and bent me over the sink. And then a handful of times when I was pledging, although we'd both been drunk and technically sucking his dick made me gay, not him.

It's not like I could help it. Aldis was the kind of guy anyone would bend over for: a tall, muscular Tight End with rippling abs, deep black skin, strong hands... and that fucking cock...

"I hate to break you two apart, but we were actually just about to have a fraternity meeting." Aldis turned to me. "Got a big party we're putting together tonight and we need all hands on deck."

I nodded. "Yeah, Dad, why don't you go check into the hotel and I'll--"

"Nonsense." Dad waved me off. "Don't need to waste money on a hotel when I can just room with my son here. And I'd be happy to sit in on your meeting, offer some words of wisdom from an old geezer."

Aldis raised an eyebrow. "Sure, man. We'd be happy to have you."

I suppressed a groan. Having my dad around was the last thing I needed tonight. I couldn't believe I'd forgotten about this party when I told him it was a good weekend to visit. Although, to be fair, we partied pretty much every weekend. I'd just have to tone down on my drinking tonight and keep him as far away from Aldis as possible...

"All right, listen up, y'all."

Aldis paced around the living room, holding a notebook like he was a football coach going through a strategy session. The rest of us sprawled across the worn-out couches and chairs, half-listening.

"Party starts at nine. We need everything ready by eight." He flipped a page. "David, you're on booze duty. Alderman's at five."

David, the burly football player, stretched his thick arms over his head, his shirt riding up to reveal thick tufts of hair under his armpits. "Got it."

"Jesus, man, put that away," Ju-wan said, wrinkling his nose. The lean Korean swimmer was perched on the armrest, absently stretching his shoulder like he was still in the pool.

David grinned. "It's my Italian heritage, bro."

Aldis ignored them and moved on. "Nate, George--you two are in charge of setting up the beer pong tables."

The two wrestlers, both short and built like tanks, nodded in unison. George scratched his ginger beard. "Where do you want them?"

"Same spot as last time."

Nate, arms crossed over his thick chest, smirked. "And who's making sure these punk-ass bitches don't spill beer everywhere?"

José, the Latino baseball player, shot him a look. "Man, just set up the damn tables." He cracked his knuckles, his muscular forearms flexing.

Aldis smirked. "José, you're on music. Make sure the playlist doesn't suck."

José gave a lazy salute. "I'll try to keep it under five Bad Bunny songs."

"Christian," Aldis continued, turning to the gymnast lounging upside down on the couch. "You're running door security."

Christian flipped upright in one fluid motion. "You want me to beat down anyone who doesn't pay cover?" He smirked, his thin brown mustache twitching like a caterpillar.

Aldis rolled his eyes. "Man, miss me with that bullshit. Just sit on the couch and take the money."

He turned to me. "New pledge, you're running the bar. Make sure the jungle juice is restocked, kegs are full, et cetera."

I gave a thumbs up. "You got it."

Aldis shut the notebook with a snap. "Alright, let's make this happen. And no one fucks this up, or you're on cleanup duty tomorrow morning."

"That's it?"

Everyone turned to look at my dad, who was sitting on the couch with his arms folded, his face unenthused. My stomach clenched in knots.

Aldis raised an eyebrow. "What do you mean? What else is there?"

Dad laughed. "What else is there? Uh, the party!" He stood, his palms spread like he was the only one talking any sense. "You're just gonna put on music, hand out booze, and expect people to show up? Back in my day, we actually threw parties people wanted to go to!"

Christian snickered. "When was that, the 80s?"

Dad turned to him, hands on his hips like a cowboy. "I've been fucking pussy since before you were born, son. I think I know a thing or two about throwing a party."

Christian went silent, his face turning red.

Aldis frowned. "So what's your idea, exactly?"

Dad grinned. "I'm glad you asked. See, we at Gamma Alpha Upsilon used to live by tradition. And the most sacred tradition was The Midnight Olympiad. Four rounds, each testing a different skill. First is the Keg Gauntlet, a relay race with kegs (and mandatory chugging stations). Then Strip Beer Pong, which is exactly how it sounds. Up next, we got Blindfolded Wrestling, then we end it all with the Midnight Swim, a skinny-dipping race in that pool you all got in the backyard."

He hooked his thumbs through his belt loops, bouncing back on his heels as his face curled in a shit-eating grin. I sat there mortified, but to my surprise, the rest of the guys seemed into it.

"It would be a great way to get chicks naked," said Nate.

"And drunk," added George.

The other guys all murmured in agreement. Dad turned to Aldis, palms upturned as if passing it over to him.

Aldis folded his arms. "All right. Change of plan. We try it your way. Boys, report to Gordon's dad, give him whatever help he needs to set things up."

"Please, call me Randy." Dad winked. "Now let's throw us a party."

The next few hours were a crazed dash of supply runs, cleaning, and setting up the space for Dad's Midnight Olympiad. I was surprised how quickly the guys took to him, asking him all about the old days of the frat and how wild things used to get.

I tried to get a moment alone with Aldis, desperate to convince him that I hadn't told my dad about our late-night rendezvous, but he was so busy I couldn't find the right time. I was hopeful that, with all the hubbub going on tonight, we might find time to slip away for some repeat action. I'd just have to shake my dad first.

By the time nine o'clock rolled around, the party was already in full swing. The backyard was packed--shirtless guys hoisting kegs like trophies, beer pong balls flying left and right, and half-drunk boys wrestling blindfolded on the lawn, laughing as they toppled onto the grass. Music blasted from the speakers, and a growing crowd gathered around the makeshift wrestling ring, cheering on Nate and José as they grappled.

Inside, the air was thick with sweat and alcohol. I crawled under the bar, grabbing a fresh keg to restock the chugging station. I caught sight of Aldis across the room, leaning against the kitchen counter, a red solo cup in his hand as he chatted with some blonde girl from Delta Pi. She was giggling at something he said, her painted nails clutching his thick forearm for support as she swayed slightly. My stomach twisted as anger rose in my chest.

A burst of laughter from the stairs caught my attention. I turned just in time to see my dad, his flannel shirt opened to show his ripped, hairy torso, upside down and chugging from a keg. The crowd was cheering him on, clapping as the foamy beer sprayed out of his mouth and onto his body. David held my dad's legs, whooping as my dad chugged. Suddenly, my dad's legs started to wobble, then he came crashing down onto David in a big pile on the floor.

For a moment, I thought he might be hurt, but then I saw his fist punch through the air, causing the crowd to let out a big cheer. He helped David to his feet, his arm around the burly football player.

"Lucky I had a nice thick landing pad," Dad called out to the crowd, who roared in laughter.

My father leaned in and whispered something in David's ear. David smiled slowly, then looked at my father and nodded. The next thing I knew, my father had David's hand and was leading him toward the staircase.

"Ey-yo, let me get another keg!" José stood shirtless and sweaty in front of the bar, arms outstretched.

I picked up one of the kegs and handed it over to him. By the time I turned back to the stairs, Dad was gone.

That was weird. Where would they have gone? Maybe David was showing him to the bathroom? I knew my duty was to stay by the bar, but my curiosity got the better of me. I slipped out and weaved my way through the crowd, walking over to the staircase. I grabbed onto the banister and started to ascend, the noise of the party beginning to die down as I reached the second floor.

I walked through the hallway, peeking into open doors to see if I could find them. Maybe he went to my room to grab something?

I opened the door to my room and was greeted with the sight of Ju-wan's bare ass pumping away. A small Asian woman lay underneath him, her arms wrapped around his back as he thrust into her. Our eyes met, and she let out a scream.

Ju-wan turned and glared at me. "Dude, I'm a little fucking busy!"

"S-sorry!" I stuttered awkwardly.

I slammed the door shut, silently chastising myself. When we started rooming together, Ju-wan made it clear that I should always knock in case he had a girl in there with him, but I'd forgotten in my haste to find my dad.

I looked down the hallway, but none of the other doors were open. I had just turned to head back downstairs when I heard a loud grunting sound. I turned back to see where it had come from. Was that David's room?

I put my ear against the closed door, trying to see if I could hear anything. More muffled groans, and then something that sounded like a smack.

My heart was pounding. What the fuck was going on in there? I reached for the doorknob, hand shaking as I slowly opened the door.

Whatever I was expecting to see when I opened the door, it wasn't my father's naked body, sweaty and muscular, his boxers around his ankles as he slammed his cock up David's ass.

"Oh, FUCK!" David grunted, his hands gripping the bed sheets like he was holding on for dear life. He was bent over the bed, his hairy, naked ass rippling every time my dad thrust into him.

Dad held David by the waist, his fingers squeezing into the football player's thick flesh as he plowed him. It was a shocking sight, seeing my naked father fucking another man. I knew he'd been into some wild sexual stuff back in college, but fucking dudes? Jesus...

"God, that jock pussy is tight," Dad said with a chuckle. "Arch your back for me." He pulled David's ass up off the bed, bringing it back onto his cock and making the boy moan.

"Dude... your cock is so fucking big..." David buried his head into the sheets, letting out a loud moan as my father assaulted his prostate.

Dad smirked. "If I had a nickel... oh fuck, squeeze it again... damn boy, you learn fast."

I watched in awe as Dad continued to rail my fraternity brother. I'd never seen him like this before. He looked like a Greek God, his back muscles rippling with every movement, his ass cheeks muscular and dimpled, his thigh muscles straining so hard it looked like he was carved out of stone. From my angle, I couldn't see his cock, but if the noises David was making were any indication, my dad was fucking hung.

The sound of laughter from behind me made me snap back to attention. I looked down the hallway to see Aldis coming up the stairs, that blonde girl from before draped across his arm.

I watched, enraged as he opened the door to his room and ushered her inside.

"Oh fuck, right there... Jesus, what is that?"

"That's your little button, son."

"Oh, fuck... it feels so good, sir... don't stop!"

I couldn't bring myself to watch any more of this. As quietly as possible, I slid the door closed and headed back down the hallway. I passed the door to Aldis's room, my neck flushing with anger as I heard the sounds of giggling and kissing coming from within. First, my dad and David, and now Aldis?

I needed a fucking drink.

____________________

RANDY

I woke up with my head pounding. The light streaming through the curtains hit me in the eyes, making my head pound even worse. God, was I hungover? I hadn't drunk this much in ages.

I sat up, rubbing my eyes as I tried to make out where I was exactly. Messy sheets, dirty clothes everywhere, the smell of man musk and cum in the air... yeah, I was in a fraternity alright.

My eyes landed on the boy in my bed. That's when it started coming back to me. Burly guy, hairy as a motherfucker. Currently passed out and naked as the day he was born. Was that my cum leaking out of his hole? Damn, we must have had a real good time.

I scratched my stomach, then yawned. Fuck, I needed to piss bad. My cock was hard as a diamond. Where the hell was the bathroom again? Probably should have gotten the lay of the land before I took one of my son's fraternity brothers upstairs and fucked him silly. But it's not like I'd planned it. One minute, we were chugging beer, having fun like the good old days. Next thing I know I gotta piss and I'm asking him if he wants to cross streams. Then one thing led to another, and...

Of course! The bathroom was at the end of the hall. That was where we'd started getting freaky. I threw the sheets off, realized I too was naked as the day I was born, and got to my feet. I couldn't find my clothes in the mess on the ground, so I picked up an old pair of the kid's briefs and pulled them on. Quiet as a churchmouse, I slipped outside and tiptoed down the hall.

The hallway was empty. Most of the brothers were still asleep, I assumed. I headed for the bathroom, needing to piss like a motherfucker. The second I was in front of the toilet I pulled my cock out and sighed, letting the piss stream freely.

Damn, it felt good to get some ass again. It's not like it was my intention when visiting my son, but what can I say? The glory days just ran away with me. Plus I'd always been a magnet for jock pussy. The more straight-acting and masculine the guy, the louder he'd beg for my cock. It's like they couldn't help themselves.

The sound of the door opening caused me to jump, sending piss flying.

"Oh, sorry..."

One of my son's fraternity brothers stood in front of the door, wearing nothing but a pair of boxer shorts. He had a big, throbbing hard-on like I did, and his hair was all in a mess. His eyes widened when he noticed my dick hanging out of my underwear.

I grinned. "Don't be shy. There's room for two."

He stared at my cock for a moment, not saying anything. He was a cute kid, a little shorter than my son. He was pretty smooth, with a few sparse chest hairs and a thin, wispy mustache.

"Christian, right?"

He tore his eyes off my cock, looked up at me and nodded. "Uh, yeah."

"Well, come on over. I can tell from that tool you gotta piss real bad."

He grinned sheepishly, then approached. I was still holding my cock, trying to get out the last few drops after being interrupted.

"Go on, then. Let's see what you've got."

He swallowed, then reached for his cock with trembling hands. He slipped it through the hole in his boxers, trying his best to aim it down. But with how hard it was, and the fact that he had one of those dicks that curved upwards, it was kind of a fool's errand.

I shook the last drops of piss out of my cock. "Last night was a hell of a party. You get up to any fun?"

Christian stared at the wall, trying not to look at my cock. "A little."

I tugged on my foreskin. "Yeah? What was her name?"

His face turned red. "We... we didn't end up hooking up."

"That's a shame," I said. "She left you with blue balls, huh?"

This time he looked right at my cock. His jaw dropped slightly as I got hard again.

"Like the way it looks?"

He blinked. "It's... so big..."

I put my hand on his shoulder, then gave him a gentle push in the right direction. "You should see how it tastes."

His eyes went wide with fear, but he got on his knees anyway. My cock dangled in front of his nose.

"Breathe it in," I said.

Christian closed his eyes and took a deep sniff, and from that moment on, he was hooked. His mouth was wet and eager, his eyes wide with the need for an older man's approval that every young man has. He cleaned his jock brother's juices off my cock, swallowing me so deep I could have sworn it wasn't his first time sucking cock.

God, nothing gets your day started like an early-morning blowie after fucking some jock pussy all night.

I grabbed his head and held his nose against my pubes, feeling my cock pulse in the back of his throat. "That's it," I moaned, feeling my balls ache with my impending orgasm. "Open your throat and take me in."

He swallowed me down to the root, choking as he tried to ignore his need for oxygen. At the last second, I pulled my dick out of him and pointed it straight between his eyes. "Fuck, gonna paint you so good, baby," I groaned, then showered him with my seed.

He closed his eyes, staying put as ropes of my cum sprayed across his face. My jizz leaked through that messy brown hair, down his forehead and nose until it pooled in that puny little mustache. I smiled when I saw his tongue flicking out to catch some of it in his mouth.

I squeezed out the last of my cum onto his forehead then patted him on the cheek. "Don't let it go to waste, huh?"