This is a fictional story, purely a product of my imagination.
My first encounter with a gay couple went beyond what I had expected. I met them through an hookup site, and after some back and forth with emails, agreed to meet them at heir home. Ted was 38, 5-10, slender with a 7 inch cock. His partner Mike was 42, and a bit shorter at 5-8, also slender, with a nice fat 6 inch tool. They were both very good looking. I had ended up on hands and knees, with Ted doing me from behind, and sucking Mike's cock as he stood in front of me. It was so hot and exciting, I came with touching myself, shooting cum onto the floor while Ted was taking my ass. The only negative was that Ted didn't use a condom, and sprayed his load in me. It was my fault, I had meant to bring it up, but got carried away and let it happen. They both assured me they were clean, but it still bothered me.
A couple of weeks passed, and on a Saturday morning I woke up to find I had an email from Mike, asking if I was up for seeing them again. I was a bit hesitant, but the urge to have sex with them again overcame my misgivings. That evening I was on my way, and arrived at their house. Ted answered the door, gave me a big smile, and waved me inside. Mike was waiting in the bedroom, naked with a hard-on. Ted and I stripped, and I got in bed with the guys on either side of me, and we started making out. Like before, I got caught up in the heat and excitement of the moment, and soon I was on my stomach, with Mike between my spread legs, working lube into my hole. I couldn't see Ted. Next I felt Mike's body on mine, and his cock probing between my ass cheeks, then pressure as he tried to push it in. The puckered ring resisted, then yielded and stretched around his cock as it sunk in. He let his upper body down on me so I was taking all of his weight, wrapped his arms around me, and started to fuck me with quick strokes. I forgot about Ted, and everything else, just let myself go and enjoyed the pleasant sensations that Mike's cock was giving me.
He gave it to me for a couple of minutes, and the combination of his cock bumping against my prostate and my cock rubbing on the sheet soon had me ready to cum. I tried to hold off, but couldn't, and cum spewed out, making a sticky puddle under me. Mike soon followed, gripping me tighter, pushing it in and holding it while his cock spasmed, and emptied into my bowels. He pushed up off me and pulled out, and I heard him mutter something. I tried to turn to ask him what he said, but hands on my back pushed me back down.