The next time they saw each other, they did not have sex. Barnaby didn't even know he'd be seeing Gil.
It hadn't been a very good day, so he wasn't particularly In The Mood to start with. Hadn't so much as texted his 'friend' (
Were they friends?
). Gil didn't need to hear about the potted plants he dropped in front of his entire class because he didn't stop to think to balance them in his arms first - or about his classmates watching him scramble to pick up the pieces before the professor came over with a broom. He didn't need to see the way Barnaby hunched at the counter, nearly doubled over under the weight of customer complaints. He'd gotten two drinks wrong from already lingering shame and so he hesitated on several orders after that. People weren't happy with him.
If nothing else, Barnaby was sure wet, red eyes from crying weren't exactly Attractive.
But at just about midnight, Gil came in anyway. Barnaby caught a glimpse as he approached, grin fading quickly from the man's face. "You alright?"
"Yeah- I'm-" Barnaby wiped his face, got off his stool and forced an awkward smile. "I'm fine. Just-
midterms, y'know?
And capitalismβ"
Gil huffed, maybe trying to laugh. It was still too much effort, as far as Barnaby was concerned. He rushed to make up for it, "Can I get you anything?"
Gloomy eyes lingered on him a moment longer before an answer was given - "Black coffee. Thank you." Gil handed over the money for it but strayed away from the counter to look around while Barnaby poured his drink. Paper bats dangled from the ceiling, zombies climbed out of posters on the walls, cartoonish wild eyes peered through every window.
When he turned back to the boy handing him a mug, he asked, "Got any plans for this weekend?"
Already anticipating an invitation back to his dorm, Barnaby hesitated to tell Gil. Even if it wasn't for that night, he wasn't in the mood to make those kinds of plans either. So he wiped down the coffee machine and told him about the Halloween party he and Jensen were supposed to go to, about how he didn't know if he was going to go or not at that point. That seemed to put a light back in Gil's eyes.
"Well, if you don't go," he started, a bit of a lift in his voice, "There's gonna be a haunted house thing right outside of campus. It'll probably be lame, but-" He shrugged over a sip of coffee. "It's something to do."
Barnaby's brows knitted together, and he paused. "You want me to go with you..?"
Gil shrugged again, somehow more exaggerated. "Everyone else I know just wants to get hammered, and that's not really my scene. I figured since you don't drinkβ" He nodded thoughtfully. "
Yeah."
Suddenly, it didn't matter what happened the next day because Barnaby had something to look forward to other than sex that night. He had a reason to wear his deer onesie with little plush antlers on the hood. As silly as he felt wearing it, he did think Jensen looked sillier in his costume when he left for the party. But rather than give his opinion on how he was pretty sure his roommate's X-rated Star Wars outfit qualified more as lingerie than a costume, he just told him to have fun. They had already been through it: "Halloween costumes at our age are either stupid, scary, or sexy,
Barney
".
Well, Jensen, you certainly marked all the boxes this year.
'I'm here.'
The message popped up on his phone, and Barnaby hurried out the dorm, down to the building entrance. Gil had said he'd drive them to the haunted house, and sure enough, there he was, leaning against a shiny black Range Rover with black tinted windows. "
Hi
."
"Hi yourself." Gil scanned him up and down and laughed, "You look
really
cute, oh my god."
Barnaby shrugged and folded his arms, feeling his face get warm in spite of the autumn chill. His gaze swept Gil's body, and he raised a brow. "Where's your costume..?"
Grey eyes widened, seemingly caught off guard.
"I'm wearing it."
Barnaby grimaced, considering the man's camouflage-print sweatclothes. "You're...a soldier?"
Gil's jaw dropped, and he flailed his arms, exasperated. "I'm
invisible.
Like the
Invisible Man
. Get it, 'cause I'm-"
"Because of-!
Okay, yeah
! The camo!" Barnaby exclaimed, remembering that the joke was very much A Thing, "Sorry, I'm -
it's clever.
I'm dumb."
"You're not dumb." Gil grabbed him by the shoulders, pulling him closer. Before Barnaby could try to convince him of the contrary, he was having his onesie pulled away from his neck - revealing the leather collar underneath. Gil said, sounding a tad surprised, "You're wearing it."
All nerve left him, and Barnaby hid his face away into Gil's chest. Really, he wasn't sure
what
he was thinking when he put it on. Except, maybe - "I'm a...
pet-
deer?"
"Hm?" Fingers carded through his hair and an arm draped around him. It certainly made him feel coddled like one. "Is that so?"
Barnaby nodded because it was easier than trying to explain why he likely would have worn it without the costume. No, that was something he'd need to figure out with himself on any other Over-Analytical Night - not the one time he was meant to go out and be normal (at least as normal as being Barnaby Hirsch would allow).
His fingers curled into Gil's sweater. It was a particularly soft fabric, and he couldn't exactly picture the man wearing them on a normal day.
"Are these," he asked, trying to change the topic, "Your
pajamas
?"
The hood of his onesie was promptly pulled over his eyes, and before Barnaby could shake free to fix it, Gil had pulled away. "Get in the car."
Probably, the most alluring of Gil's features was his voice. It was his rich, husky way of speaking that drew Barnaby to follow his commands, but still, somehow, sounding so young that Barnaby could recognize him as equal. And maybe even relatable. Especially if Gil would trail off or pause, as if he were uncertain of himself.
It became obvious in the car, while Barnaby listened to him talk about the spirit of Halloween and how it seemed to be fading in recent years. He sounded - average. Not like a man who existed solely to pleasure people from his dorm. And that stuck to Barnaby more than he realized, apparently. Because that was what he remembered of Gil inviting him out.
Not
that Gil was inviting him to a haunted house.
Because, clearly, what Barnaby
didn't
remember from that encounter was that he was
terrified
of haunted houses.
He'd only ever gone through one once, years prior when Jensen dragged him through (