=== Friendly warning: Parts of this series include incest between a man and his father ===
*****
The guilt washed over me like a bucket of icy water right as I opened my eyes in the morning. I still felt Mr. Cooper's hands on my hips. He was sound asleep and his grip on me loosened up over the night. The sunlight coming through the window suggested it was pretty late already. We must have overslept!
Careful not to wake him up, I started getting off the bed. I managed to do it silently and I was also able to put on my shorts and get out of the room, leaving Hunter's naked dad snoring on the bed. I closed the door behind me carefully and leaned against it, whining softly to myself about the events of last night.
What the fuck was I thinking?! I fooled around with my boyfriend's dad, behind his back! This was bad, really bad! I was thinking with my dick and now I'll have to pay the price! There is no way I'll be able to keep this secret away from Hunter. I'm gonna have to tell him, ruin our relationship and presumably the relationship between him and his father as well. Dear god... I almost teared up on the spot.
I composed myself and started walking down the hallway. No sense in delaying the inevitable. I would have to find Hunter and tell him everything. I wondered if he was up already-
"SURPRISE!" somebody shouted at me, jumping onto my unprotected back. I yelled and lost my balance, falling to the floor. Shocked, I turned around and saw the grinning face of my boyfriend, holding me in a headlock. He looked like he was in a great mood. And I was about to ruin it...
"Guess who's feeling better!" he cheered, as he let me go and helped me up, "Dad was totally right, it was just an overnight thing as always. I'm absolutely ready for the fishing trip we were planning for today, isn't that great?"
"Yeah," I said, unable to look into his eyes, straightening my underwear, "Yeah, I'm really glad for you, that's... great."
He noticed immediately that something is wrong. Of course. He knew me too well.
"What's going on, Gary?" he asked, concerned, "Did something happen?"
I forced myself to meet his gaze, unable to believe that I was able to hold back the tears.
"I... There's no easy way to say this, Hunter, but... Last night, your dad and I were talking, and... things got weird, and... inappropriate. Physically. I am so, SO sorry."
His face looked absolutely perplexed. I can't say I was surprised...
"Wait, what? What do you mean by 'inappropriate'?"
"I mean... sexually inappropriate. Your dad and me. I... can't imagine how it feels to hear this. I'm really, really sorry. I blame myself entirely."
He chuckled - he was probably not really grasping what I was telling him yet?
"Are you saying you had sex with my dad?"
"No! I mean... not full-on sex, but we did... stuff. We did enough. I can only imagine how horrible that makes you feel."
Hunter scratched his head, probably figuring out himself how to process these feelings before he looked back at me. To my surprise, he didn't seem neither angry nor sad.
"Well... it's kinda weird. For starters, I had no idea that my dad was into dudes!"
"He... what?"
Hunter shrugged with an amused grin on his face.
"He didn't have a girlfriend in years, that's true. And he was married to mom for a pretty long time. But I have never heard him say a word about another man. That is... interesting..."
It was my time to be confused. I gently grabbed his wrist and looked him deep into his eyes.
"Hunter, sorry but I think you're missing the point," I said gently, "I'm saying I had something with another man. With your dad. Doesn't that bother you at all?"
Hunter gave me a smirk and his hand went to pinch my cheek.
"What? Were you hoping I would throw a jealous fit?"
"I..."
"Yeah, I definitely wasn't expecting it. But for some reason, it doesn't bother me at all. If it was any other man, yeah. But this way... it kinda feels like things are staying in the family, you know? No harm done."
Well, I certainly wasn't expecting this kind of outcome! At first, I was suspicious that he really still wasn't grasping what just happened, but his expression looked one-hundred percent sure. Was he really okay with this?!
"Well..." I started, still puzzled, "No matter how you feel about it, I feel really guilty. I can promise you that it will never, EVER happen aga-"
"How was he?" he interrupted me.
"I'm sorry?"
"How was he?" Hunter repeated the question. His eyes were... burning with curiosity for some reason.
"Umm..." I said, wondering how much detail should I go into. I mean, what was the appropriate level of describing the amount of sex you've had with your boyfriend's dad to your boyfriend?! "He didn't hurt me, you don't need to worry about that. And he was very... passionate. And also very... um... "
"He initiated it, didn't he? Of course, he did..." Hunter said, coming closer to me. His voice sounded different, but he wasn't angry... No, he was intrigued! "How big is he? I've never seen his dick fully hard before..."
"I... actually didn't see. He was... behind me."
"Did you make him cum?"
"Yeah... yeah, I did."
"Inside of you?"
"No, he didn't fuck me. But he nutted all over my back."
"Fuck..." Hunter whispered, now close enough for me for our bodies to be touching. Confused, I looked down and saw a huge tent in his grey sweatpants! Was the thought of his dad and me actually turning him on? Again, I thought about that scene yesterday, with the hunting gear...
"If I didn't know any better, I'd say that this is actually making you horny," I noted. Hunter looked down and went a little red in the face when he saw his own tenting crotch.
"Yeah..." he said, "I guess I've always felt... strange about my dad. He was the man of the house, my role model. I looked up to him a lot, I always wanted to be like him. I adored him. At first, I thought it's just being proud of your dad, you know. But then the thoughts started taking a turn... Started being more explicit."
He grabbed his dick over the cloth of his pants and tugged on it a little bit. Our eyes met once again.
"Hunter, do you have a crush on your dad?"
It took him a while before he answered.
"I suppose..." he answered softly, "I guess I always did, it's just something that feels really uncommon to put into words..."
Wow. This trip has certainly taken a turn. I could not believe the conversation I was having. Or the ideas that started popping into my head... The images of Hunter and his dad, together... Maybe me as a part of it?
No. No, that was too far. This was an actual family. No matter how Hunter felt about his dad, it wasn't my job to intervene in it.
"Well, I guess this is a good day for confessions," I said, with a slight smile. Hunter smiled back and stroked my hair. He grabbed my hand and we both left the hallway, so we wouldn't wake up Mr. Cooper. Against all odds, the discussion ended there, much more successful than I could ever have hoped.
"Isn't that beautiful, boys?" Mr. Cooper sighed, turning his head to gaze at the mountains in the distance. He was wearing a colorful shirt and a pair of shorts today, together with a fisherman's hat and a pair of sunglasses. He looked absolutely relaxed, despite the events of last night. Apparently, he was going to pretend as nothing happened at all.