This is the second in a series. To really know what the story is about read "Emmy and the Top Ten List" first.
Three weeks ago my wife and I entered a new stage in our relationship where Em dominates me sexually and makes me submit and do whatever she wants in the bedroom. On that first day another couple initiated us into the lifestyle. But otherwise this was private between us.
Then once Saturday, Emmy was out shopping when the doorbell rang. It was the neighbor's 19 year old son, Colin. He said he wanted to borrow my hedge trimmer. I invited him in, chatting as we walked through the house on the way to the garage.
He asked if he could have a drink as he was thirsty from yard work. I could tell he had been working as he looked hot. Incidentally, Emmy had recently mentioned that he looked hot the other way too, ever since coming home from college.
In the kitchen, with a glass in his hand he questioned if Emmy was home. I thought nothing of what seemed like idle talk and answered that she was out shopping. Checking the clock I added that she would be home soon. Then motioned for him to follow me to the garage.
In the garage he seemed jittery like he wanted to say something, but he never did. I handed him the trimmer then we started making our way back to the front door. Just before I was to let him out he turned to me, nervous and speaking fast, he spit out, "I saw you. There on the carpet." He pointed to the spot on the carpet where the cum stain was. "Three weeks ago. I stepped outside to smoke so my parents wouldn't smell it. Looking through the gap in the curtains, I saw what you did."
My face suddenly felt hot. I was greatly embarrassed. I know he knew I was mortified, because my flushed face would be unmistakable. He, of course, was talking about the night I gave Nick a blowjob right there on that spot.
I raised my hand to gesture my objection while countering, opened my mouth, but I had nothing to say. He had caught me dead to rights.
Accusingly, he added, "I also saw, how you cheated, what you did with that woman who wasn't Emmy." I looked around the room, at the spot where I sucked my first cock, the place on the floor where that crazy woman had sat on my face, the gap in the curtains, and the place where Emmy had been. It dawned on me that he didn't know Emmy had been there too. I didn't want her to be as embarrassed as I was, so to protect her I decided to leave her out if it.
Colin's tone changed, "I think the missus would find it all veeery interesting." He let that hang in the air for a minute. He smirked, "I'm going to keep this trimmer. And then we're gonna talk more when your wife's not due home." I realized that this kid thought he was blackmailing me. With that said, he turned and walked out.
Naturally, when Em came home I related the amusing story. At first she was appalled that someone had witnessed what I had done, then she was angry at the little dick for trying to blackmail me, then she asked me If maybe we should have some fun and teach him a lesson. I approved.
We gave it a couple days thought, then sprang our trap. Friday, as planned, she went next door to talk to Colin's mom as a pretext. While she was there she let it drop that she was going to be out all day Saturday.
Next we moved the computer and wifi camera, as well as the security camera, so we could get him on tape trying to extort me. We parked her car in the parking lot at her workplace. Then came home to wait for the rat to show up.
Saturday morning around 11:30 the doorbell rang. Emmy hid and I answered the door. I needed to get him in front of the cameras so I acted like a guilty man who was trying to act normal. In other words, I just acted normal.
I invited him in, poured a scotch for each of us, setting his on the end table to control where he would sit. He was on the recliner and I was on the couch across from him.
"So, Collin, how's college, how's your girlfriend?"
He really didn't have any idea how to blackmail someone. "Good Mr. Blake. I'm getting good grades, she's smart and funny. Everything's good."
"I'm glad to hear life's good for you." I had earlier thought I would take some time to lead the conversation. But in the moment I decided that now was as good a time as any to get his confession. "Now, why would a young man with so much going for him want to blackmail someone?" When I said that I caught Emmy's eyes peeking out from a crack in the living room doorway. She gave me a silent thumbs up.
Colin looked at me cooly, he answered, "Because I can Mr. Blake. And I want something."
Colin were all friends here, "Call me Scotty"
This wasn't going well for him. He just didn't know it yet. Less than a minute in and he'd already given it up. He was also kind of a jerk which made me agree more strongly with Emmy's idea to really let him dangle on a line.
I decided to fidget a little. Make it look like he had me over a barrel. Then I gave him some rope, "Young man, Just what is it that you want for your silence, you know, to not tell my wife?" I called him 'young man' but he was only five years younger than us.
I poured him another drink. "Well, Scotty, I figure it's worth a lot. I bet that pretty wife of yours would be super mad if she found out that you had an affair. First with that woman who's hotter than her," at this point Em was gesturing to me, glaring angrily, and making the 'slit your throat' sign at Colin from her hiding place. He continued, "And then the gay affair with her husband. She might even divorce you."
"So, Colin, what's it to be?
At this point his nerves flared up. As a long time poker player I recognized that he was about to place a bet but was afraid he would overplay or underplay his hand. He hesitated, "I want two hundred dollars." Here he hesitated for even longer. "And... and I want...a blowjob."
So here it was, his big play and it was a couple bucks and a Bj. I was surprised at how little he asked for. If I were really afraid for my marriage I would pay a heck of a lot more. I almost spit out the sip I was taking when he said that. It was all I could do to not laugh. I'm sure he thought he had me on the ropes.
Sympathetically I asked, "Doesn't that little girlfriend of yours blow you?"
"No man, nothing fun at all. I haven't had a blowjob since my last girlfriend three years ago."
"Whew! That's a long time. But you've been steady for three years now, Wouldn't she be upset if I told her that you got a BJ from a guy?"