Before these events, I had successfully met with 2 other people from Craigslist for safe play at different times. I am bi and like women more, but when I need some quick relief, I turn to Craigslist, usually guys because the w4m posts are typically scams of some sort. Anyway, onto the story...
I was extremely horny one day, as usual. I posted an ad searching for another guy who was interested in mutual masturbation. I got several responses, but I picked the guy who had a similar body type to mine (heavier and stocky, just more comfortable). He said he had a 7 inch cock and lived alone so I could head over, watch porn, maybe give eachother a hand. So I got ready and started driving that way. He lived about 35-40 minutes from me. I finally arrived after having slight troubles finding the place since I had to take some small back roads. He lived in a nice little duplex. I got out of my car and walked up to the door and knocked. He peeked out the window to check who was at the door, saw that it was me, unlocked the door and let me in.
He had nothing on besides some boxer briefs and a tank-top. We both sat down, him in a computer chair and me in a recliner. We started watching a little bit of TV and had a good conversation just to get to know eachother a little. He was rubbing himself the whole time, which started turning me on. Eventually we both moved over to the computer so we could watch some porn. I pulled up the recliner and took a seat. He pulled his briefs down and took off his tank-top. I didn't take anything off yet, just wanted to make sure things felt right at first. He had a pretty big cock, the biggest I had ever seen in person, for sure. I'd say it was about 7 1/2 inches and very thick. He searched through some videos and ended up clicking on a cumshot compilation. I started rubbing my dick through my shorts as he slowly stroked his semi-erect cock. Eventually I had to pull my dick out as well. So I stood up and dropped my shorts and boxer briefs. He reached down next to the computer and grabbed a bottle of lube from a drawer. He put a good amount on the tip of his dick and handed it to me. I did the same. I hadn't used lube to jack off too many times before this. Then I remembered how fantastic it feels! I slowly worked the lube all over my dick and slowly stroked myself. We both kept watching the porn while taking glances at eachother's erect dicks.