*This is a continuation of a fantasy story that is based off of a real conversation. All identities have been changed for protection*
The next few days were a blur as I contemplated everything that had happened that weekend.
I had my first gay experience with my best friend, my first threesome (with all guys at that) and a hugely erotic experience of fucking one of the most beautiful girls in our drom and my best friend while also having him fuck me. If someone had asked me what I learned in my classes that week I wouldn't have been able to answer.
My mind was all over the place trying to figure out what I wanted. I knew I wanted to continue seeing Lexi but I also enjoyed fooling around with Tyler all weekend. I tried to avoid both of them as much as I could whenever I saw them trying to avoid the inevitable. Could I just see Lexi and give up what I had with Tyler which could potentially damage our friendship? Could I continue with both Tyler and Lexi knowing that she found it so hot that he and I were also fucking each other?
I knew there were times that Tyler would try and initiate a conversation in the room but I was always scared of where it was going to go so I'd make up some excuse about needing to go to the gym or the library. I could start to see that there was that same look of rejection in his eyes as that night at the concert. Was Tyler starting to feel something for me or was it again just about sex?
It was now Friday, one week after the concert. I bumped into Lexi on my way back from the gym and I apologized about avoiding her. I explained to her my conflictions and that it wasn't that I didn't like her or didn't enjoy being with her. She understood and said that she liked me too but if we wanted to just keep it casual and pressure free that we could do that. She recognized the friendship Tyler and I had and knew that this situation was unique. She told me she didn't want to cause problems for us or make things awkward but that if I ever wanted to hang out or fool around she'd be right over.
I thanked her for understanding. We gave each other a hug and a quick peck on the lips before I headed back to my room. I walked up to my door and I could hear the faint sounds of sex coming from the other side. I couldn't tell what the source was. Was Tyler watching a movie that had a sex scene or was it porn? Was he by himself or was he with someone? If he was with someone who was it? But also why did I care?
If he was alone, there was a part of me that thought about walking in and catching him. However, if he wasn't alone I didn't want to cock block him. I decided to grab some food and head over to the dining hall. I grabbed a burger and some chips before heading off and grabbing a table by the window. I slowly ate my dinner while contemplating what I wanted. I sat there for about an hour before I decided to start heading back again.
I got back to my room and pressed my ear to the door and couldn't hear anything coming from the other side. I slowly opened the door to find the room empty. I put my gym stuff down and started to get undressed so I could go get a shower when the door opened and in walked Tyler.
"Hey man where were you?" he asked.
"I was at the gym and when I came back it sounded like someone was getting some pretty good sex so I decided to go grab some dinner. So who was the lucky person?"
"There wasn't anyone in the room" he responded with a little bit of surprise in his voice.
"Dude I know what sex sounds like are and those were sex sounds."
"Oh! I was watching Game of Thrones" he laughed as he realized that the scene was loud enough that I was able to hear it in the hallway.
We both laughed about the whole situation. I told him that I was going to go take a shower when he said "I'll join you." I was confused as it was still early, he didn't mean together did he or did he just mean that he was also going to go take a shower.
"Look, Tyler, I don't know what we're doing here."
"What do you mean?"
I started to get aggravated with him. "You know what I mean. We spent 3 days last weekend fucking each other and other people including two girls that both want us. I don't know what we're doing here!"
"Is that why you've been avoiding me?"
"Yes it is. I just told Lexi that we had to keep it casual because I couldn't choose between her and potentially ruining our friendship."
"You're the one that started all this in the first place!" he shouted back at me. "You were the one that asked me to suck your dick!"
"You were the one whining about how that chick at the concert rejected you and you were saying that you wanted to try guys. I was just trying to call your bluff so you'd shut up!"
"Then why did you beg me to fuck your ass multiple times this weekend!"
"I was fucking horny! But all week I have been trying to figure out this whole goddamn situation. Lexi wants me, you're my best friend and I don't know what I want!"
"I don't know either dude! Why can't we just have fun?"
"Because we have been friends for years! Inevitably this is going to get complicated."
I grabbed my towel and shower stuff and started to walk towards the door.
"You're just going to leave?!" Tyler yelled at me.
"Yea I am going to go take a shower, showers relax me and right now I am very stressed."
"We aren't done talking about this..." Tyler reached out and grabbed my arm.
"Dude don't fucking touch me!"
"Then don't walk away from me!"
I pushed his arm hand away which caused the two of us to get very close to each other.
"I'm done! This right here is exactly why I have been avoiding you!"
I walked out the door and went to the bathroom for my shower. I turned on the shower and stood under the running water trying to calm myself down. I grabbed my body wash and started to soap up my body. I could feel myself starting to relax when I took my soapy hand and ran it around to my back and started to wash my ass. I ran my soapy finger up and down my crack until I hit my hole. The moment my finger hit my hole a jolt went through my body. I had a lot on my mind but at the center of it was Tyler. I finished up, wrapped a towel around my waist and started to leave when I bumped into Tyler. He just looked down and climbed into the stall. I went back to my room and sat down in my chair thinking about what to do next.
