I would like to thank everyone for the great feedback and encouragement to keep writing. I had made half of this story already in my head so I would probably not change much in the beginning and just incorporate ideas further into the story.
Reminder: Ty is not a minor, he is 18.
Disclaimer: The humiliation of Ty will go on so if you are not into non-con scenarios this story probably won't be for you. I appreciated the feedback anyways.
----------------------------
The next day I had a hard time forgetting what happened and was feeling down for most of the day. I should've been relieved my secret was safe but I didn't trust my coach and now I had two secrets instead of one: the buttplug and the blowjob.
I couldn't really concentrate for most of the day. I felt like I was on auto-pilot. My mind often drifting to the humiliation I was subjected or the disgust of the things I had done. I thought I would go through life without sucking a dick, and now I had done it and for an unattractive middle-aged sweaty guy, it was a lot to burden.
After classes I went to Cory's house before practice and since we were alone he took time to ask me about the buttplug experience and make fun of me a little bit.
"How was it? Are you ready to take my dick now?" He said mockingly.
"Fuck off. Your dick is smaller than that tiny buttplug" I answered. Talking about the buttplug just brought me back to what happened and was no fun for me. But since I wasn't planning on letting my best friend know I suck the coach's dick, I just played along for a bit and tried to change the subject.
I was getting nervous of going to practice and how the coach was going to behave after what happened. When we arrive at the lockerroom, my locker was gone; the coach wasn't playing around, he really moved my locker to his office. I got a knot in my throat. I went to his office and there he was, sitting in his chair, with a small grin that got me worried and unsettled. The office was simple, basically just some shelves, a desk, an old rusty office chair, and now my full size locker was in one of the corners.
"Hi, coach. I came for my locker." I said.
"Come on in Thomas, of course." He said as if nothing had happened. Guess that's part of keeping a secret; but I couldn't see him the same way. "Close the door." He said calmly. I did. I was a little scared but also found myself following his orders immediately as consequence of this fear, I knew he had shit over me.
I went directly to my locker and tried to avoid eye contact. I heard his chair squeak and I spotted from my side eye he twisted his chair to watch me directly. He looked hungry, kind of pleased sitting with his legs wide open waiting for me to undress.
I didn't know what I could've said so I just started undressing shyly. Then he said: "You like putting in the buttplug, do it. That's the whole point of this arrangement, for you to have a safe space to do it." I didn't wanted to and I definitely wasn't feeling safe there but I didn't wanted to get in a discussion with him, so I took it out of the locker. I just threw it in the night before, without washing it or anything so it was dirty and smelled like ass and shit. I tried to get out of it by saying, "Oh coach, I don't have any lube, it won't go in like this. Maybe some other time."
"Don't be ridiculous Thomas, I have some lube right here. Come, I'll help you out." The old pervert said while opening the first drawer from his desk.
Reluctantly, I walked to him in my jockstrap and a t-shirt, with the black buttplug in my hand and no idea on how to get out of this. He asked for the buttplug and told me to turn around. I heard as he squeezed the lube onto the buttplug. He told me to grab my ankles which made me feel really vulnerable, showing my asshole to the coach who raped my mouth a day before. I heard another squeeze of the bottle and then I felt his pervert finger lubing my asshole, I wanted him to stop, to get the toy inside me already and let me get out of that damn office.
He played a bit with my asshole before inserting the buttplug, quite roughly. "Done. What do we say?" He asked adding to the humiliation.
"Thank you, coach" I said defeated.
I put on my shorts and got out of there as fast as I could while trying to keep a poker face to the guys just outside the office.
I couldn't believe I was subjected to another hour-long practice with that thing up my butt; and was getting paranoid this might become a daily thing.
I was uncomfortable and afraid that any guy on the field would notice anything weird on my shorts; but most of all I didn't wanted to go back to the lockerroom and change in front of the coach again.
The practice was close to be over when the coach yelled at me in front of the team and belittled me saying I wasn't doing much and that I've been doing the exercises halfway. This was true since I was still uneasy about the buttplug in my ass and struggling to keep it in, specially when making efforts; but still, it didn't felt good to be scolded in front of the whole team.
So I was asked to stay longer on the field just with the coach to make up for lost time. The team left to shower while I was there again to obey the coach.
He made me do some laps and some jumping jacks which were slightly painful. Then he made me do some yoga poses that should 'help me loosen up'. Being the pervert coach he was, he started saying I wasn't doing the positions correctly and he would get closer, touch me and handle me. The worst was when he had me raise my butt and he came from the back and push himself against my ass and buttplug, pushing it even deeper and making me moan in an uncomfortable pain.
You could see he was enjoying having me do whatever he said even if it was only tiring or distressful and not sexy at all. Finally, after a long 45 minutes of physically demanding torture he expressed, "That's enough, let's go shower". Which quickly unsettle me. 'Let's go'? Meaning he was gonna shower with me?
Then it hit me: that was his whole strategy, keep me entertained until the showers emptied and he'll have me alone again. This time the rage and warning gave me time to wake up and tried to defy or avoid him.