Scott walked over to the door, the butt plug inserted, wearing only his white stockings and opened it wide to let our guest in.
"Wow!" He exclaimed, "You look great!"
Scott replied, "Thanks, come on in."
The guy we had met on CL walked into the room then saw me, sitting on the bed naked, my cock was about half hard. He introduced himself as Jim. He was wearing a dress shirt, slacks, nice dress shoes. He was about six feet, same as Scott and I. He had said he was 45, but he looked closer to 50 with salt and pepper hair, he was clean shaven and all in all a nice looking guy.
"Welcome Jim, feel free to get undressed," I said, walking over and shaking his hand. I introduced myself and Scott, adding, "Scott here will be sucking and fucking and doing anything else we want."
Jim was unbuttoning his shirt as he replied, "That is so hot. I didn't know what to expect," he continued, while now slipping off his slacks, "I'm really glad I made it over."
He was naked in a few seconds, his cock steadily growing harder and thicker, again about like a coke can, only about 5 or so inches long.
"Scott, why don't you suck our friend's cock," I said.
Scott got on his knees and started licking and sucking Jim's cock. Naturally he moaned and put one hand on Scott's head. His other hand reached out and wrapped around my cock! I wasn't expecting this, as Jim had described himself as all top and not interested in anything but getting blown and fucking, but he had a strong grip on my cock and was certainly enjoying it.
"Let's move to the bed," I said. We all moved the bed, Scott getting on his hands and knees, spreading his butt cheeks apart to show his butt plug.
"OH! WOW!" Jim yelled, "THAT IS FUCKING HOT!" He reached up and tugged on the butt plug slightly, then pushed it back in. Scott moaned.
I handed Jim a condom and said, "slip this on, then pull the plug out and let's see how well you can fuck my friend."
He smiled, grabbed the condom, tore it open and stretched it around his thick cock. It rolled almost all the way to the base, but was stretched tightly around him.
"I have a problem with some condoms, thank goodness my wife is fixed now!" He laughed, adding, "I've only fucked two dudes ever, so this is extra hot for me, I hope I can last longer than five minutes!"
"You'll do fine, it might take you five minutes to get that thick cock in him," I said.
He smiled and then looked at me and asked, "what are you going to do while I fuck your friend?"
I grinned, "well, probably watch and then move around to his hot mouth so he can suck me off."
"Well, um, uh, could I suck you off instead?" He asked, blushing a bit.
"Sure, but I didn't think you wanted to do that," I replied.
"Honestly, I usually have no interest in that at all, but your cock is amazing," he said, "and could you put the butt plug in me?"
"Sure," I replied, grinning.
He eased the butt plug out of Scott's ass with a 'plop'. He handed it to me as he slid up behind Scott and lined up the thick head of his cock with Scott's slightly gaping hole. He then started to push forward and Scott, being the excellent fuck that he is, slid backwards, forcing the thick cock into him.
"OH FUCK!" Scott exclaimed then moaned deeply as the cock slowly spread his cheeks wider and wider as it slid in deeper and deeper. He continued to moan as Jim pushed in.
"Geez! His ass is so fucking tight!" Jim said.
I cleaned off the butt plug, then smeared anal lube on it and got onto the bed behind Jim. I smeared some of the lube onto Jim's asshole and then slowly inserted the plug.
"Oh man, oh man!" He exclaimed, "that feels amazing."
