Editor's note: this story contains scenes of non-consensual or reluctant sex.
*****
The vibrating butt plug in my ass was buzzing away as I hopped on the tram on my way to John's flat. It was my birthday gift from him and I was on my way over for the rest of my present. I was relatively newly "out" and I was definitely a bottom, but I didn't have the nerve to go and find myself someone to fuck me - the idea of letting myself be in that vulnerable position always got in the way, no matter how much I fantasized about being fucked in the ass. I met John in a gay bar and we became good friends with some benefits. He too was a bottom, but we would suck each other off every now and then.
When I reached his building he buzzed me in and I took the lift up to his floor. On the way up I wondered what the rest of my gift would be. I was assuming the plug in my ass would be a simulated "fucking" while we sucked each other's dicks which, the more I thought about it, the more turned on I was getting. My anus was feeling full, but relaxed from the vibrations as I knocked on John's door.
"There's the birthday boy!" cried John as he hugged me and I made my way into the flat.
"So what did you have in mind?" I asked, eager to taste his cock.
"You're awfully keen aren't you?" he laughed. "Might as well get on the bed then.. I reckon we can sixty-nine with these plugs in our arses."
As he said that he turned around and dropped his pants revealing that he too had a butt plug in. We finished undressing and I flopped on my back on his bed with my feet dangling off the end and my toes just touching the carpet. I felt him take my knob in his mouth as he swung a leg over my head which placed his cock in my face. I started licking the head, working my way down the shaft. His dick was average - just like mine. A bit shy of six inches with a decent bit of thickness. I could feel my balls swelling as John sucked me off. Once his cock was sufficiently slicked up by my saliva, I started taking all of it in my throat, sticking my tongue out to make room for his knob. The combination of having his dick in my throat, my dick in John's mouth, and the fullness and vibrations in my ass from the butt plug had me seriously turned on.
I felt a chill run up my spine after hearing a noise - footsteps, and I moaned as a way of communicating my concern to John, but he quietly chuckled and continued to lick and suck my cock. Finally I was able to see whose footsteps I heard when he was beside the bed and John's thigh no longer blocked my view. The guy had medium length blonde hair, was above average in height, fairly defined muscles, but still pretty slim, and a nine inch cock that was already wet with lube. He tossed a black cloth bag toward the head of the bed and when it landed it made a quiet metallic clinking noise, which I assumed were his keys along with his clothes in the bag.
He then got on the bed, kneeling behind John and slowly pulled John's butt plug out - never breaking eye contact with me as he did so. He tossed the butt plug aside and then slowly started feeding his long dick into John's ass right before my eyes. I felt John tense up a bit and then relax as the newcomer started with shallow pumping and worked up to giving John the full length. Despite the show of his massive balls swinging back and forth in front of my eyes, I was starting to feel left out - that is until I felt someone lift my legs up off the floor to rest them on their shoulders. There was a second stranger in the room! My mind was swimming with fears and questions, but with John's dick in my mouth I had no way of letting them out. Then my butt plug stopped vibrating and it was slowly being pulled out of my anus. I was feeling nervous and uncertain, but it appeared as though I was going to get my wish of being fucked in the ass whether I liked it or not! I felt him press his knob against my well-lubed, but inexperienced asshole and he just held it there for a while. My mind rushing, I remembered to try to relax my ass and push just like when you are taking a shit. He must have picked up on what I was doing because as soon as I started pushing, I felt him slowly pushing into me. It hurt a little when his knob popped in, but he held it there for a minute as my body got used to his girth. He then slowly started shallow pumping in and out, gradually working up to full length thrusts into my thirsty asshole.
The sights, sounds, and sensations were making my head spin. "What must this look like?" I wondered. I imagined the sight of me and John in a sixty-nine, each of us having our asses fucked at the same time! I was beyond horny, but I was getting jealous feelings - it was my birthday after all - I wanted all of the cum. I pushed up gently on John's hips to pull his dick out of my throat so I could give his knob my full attention. I tightened my lips and bobbed up and down while flicking my tongue quickly over his prepuce. I felt John tense up as he started to ejaculate into my mouth. I felt John's mouth leave my cock and he said "Well aren't you greedy? I'll let it slide since it's your birthday. I'm going to get a drink - have fun with him Nathan and Steve." After he said that, the blonde guy pulled his cock slowly out of John's ass and I looked up and licked my lips.
"I'm Nathan by the way." he said as he slid his cock into my mouth. John climbed off of me and left the room. I was left with Nathan's knob in my mouth while a man called Steve who I realized I hadn't seen yet was busy fucking me in the ass.
"Looks like you can suck a mean dick," Nathan said, "let's see if you can take all of me down your throat."
