Becoming My Brother's Toy

Editor's note: this story contains scenes of incest or incest content.

*****

***All characters are 18 years or older. The following story is purely fictional.***

I live in a family in which all the men are tall and strong, confident and full of charisma. Except me, I am the opposite of them. I am short and weak, no confidence and lacking in charisma. On the other hand, my brother Tom, who is 21, is just like the rest of the family. I envy the relationship he has with our father and his brothers, our uncle's. They are always going out on trips and talking about women and I'm always nowhere to be found.

My father doesn't despise me neither does he hate me, but he hates that I turned out to be as I am. Did I have any choice to stay short? The only thing that he ever encourages me to do is to try find myself a girlfriend. He always gives me an example with my brother. Tom is always around girls and having sex. But little does my father know that I am different from him in that area too.

See, because of the way he thinks, I can't even enjoy the things I like. First, I'm gay. I fantasize about bottoming for a hot guy but because of my current situation, sex is nowhere to be seen. Secondly, I also fantasy about wearing women clothing, mostly lingerie. But, yet again, I can't. I can't do any of this. At school there are some gay boys that I talk to but as soon as I see or think I see my brother coming I flee the scene.

Today is my 18th birthday; happy birthday to me. This is that day that comes once in a year where my father gets a bit drunk and gives me the same speech over and over again about how I don't do and act like him and my brother. I wake up and go take a shower. I decided to shave my whole body today so that I am extra smooth for my not so special day. I step out of the shower and admire myself in the mirror.

I look at my short, lean, smooth body and below average dick. I turn around to admire the rest of my body, especially my ass. As I grab my round smooth bubble butt, I ask my butt the same question that I always do: "When are you going to take your first dick?"

As I got downstairs for breakfast, I found my brother and father talking. Tom was telling him about this new girl that he's dating and how wild she is. Obviously, my father invites me to listen to my brother so that maybe I get tempted. My brother isn't like my father, personality wise. He immediately stopped talking about this new girl that he's now dating.

Later that day, my brother asked me if he could talk to me about something a bit sensitive. What did I think it may be? Absolutely no idea.

"Hey what's up?" I asked my brother.

"Yeah, uh, I don't even know where and how to begin on this," he said, scratching his head.

"Well, what is it on?" I said.

"It's about my girlfriend," he said, "I kind of have a problem of sorts."

"What about?" I replied, afraid of any advice I might end up saying to him.

"Yesterday as I was over at her house, we had sex," he said.

"So? You say you have had sex plenty of times before," I said instantaneously.

"But this is different," he said.

"Different how dude, you aren't making much sense right now," I told him.

"Let me continue," he said, "as we were having sex, she told me that she wanted anal, but I didn't want to."

"Why didn't you? Most guys would beg to get some anal going on and you refused?" I said, thinking to myself that I am the one begging for some.

"Sure, it's all good when you think about it but when you are on the spot, about to put your dick in her ass," he said as he paused, "I don't know, I froze. I never did anal before."

"Well next time just lube up plenty and push it in slowly," I said.

"Could you give me advice on it?" he asked.

"Tom, I guess you know that you came to the wrong guy about sex advice," I replied.

"I think I came to the right guy; you are gay and all," he said with a cool tone.

I froze, how did he know?

"Oh, come on, don't play dumb with me," he said, "whenever I see you talking to somebody at school, it's always a gay guy. Every time."

"Please don't tell dad. He'll kill me," I begged him.

"Don't worry. My intention wasn't to blackmail you or anything. Your secret is safe with me," he assured me, "I just thought that you might have any useful tips since you only have to put it in an ass."

"Well, I actually don't," I replied.

"What do you m-, are you saying that you bottom for guys," he said, shocked.

"yes, I am a bottom, but I never had sex before with someone else so technically I never bottomed for nobody. Except for a dildo," I replied confidently.

"Oh, so you are experienced, see?" he said, "and what do you to prepare for the dildo?"

"As I already told you, just lube up plenty," I replied.

"Well, I still am not convinced," he said, "tomorrow we are seeing each other again and I told her that I would be ready."

After that, Tom left, and the conversation stopped there. The day went on and eventually came the famous speech from my dad. This year was a bit more special being my 18th birthday. He was more drunk than usual, and he told me that although I am 18 now, I still am not a real man. The only thing that I wanted to say to him in reply to that was that I am such a man that I just gave his favorite son sex tips. But I didn't want to drag Tom into this and kept my mouth shut.

After the speech I pretty much locked myself in the room. I kept hearing my dad blabbering downstairs for what seemed like an eternity. And finally, there was some quite in the house, I could hear myself think again.

Nighttime fell and the house was still conquered by serenity and peacefulness. Suddenly, I heard a knock on the door. I thought that it was my father, maybe he left something out in his speech and wanted to say it to me, but it was Tom.

"Door's open," I told him, "What's up?"

"Hey," he said as he entered the room, "how are you feeling?"

"Oh, I am fine don't worry. I got used to this now," I replied.

"I wish I could have said something to stop him, but you know that it would just make it worse for you," he said.

"Yeah, I know, I know." I replied.

"Listen, uh, I couldn't stop thinking about the advice that you gave me about my little problem," he said, "I am so nervous about tomorrow and a lot of crazy ideas have gone through my mind and here's one of them: can I practice anal on you?"

"What?" I exclaimed.

"Forget it. It's just the nerves and the fear taking a hold of me," he said.

"Well, wait a moment," I told him, "you want to take your dick and try to put it in my ass. Right?"

"Uh yeah. I know that it's crazy, especially now that I said it out loud," he replied.

"Well, it isn't crazy. I guess it's just desperate measures, that's all," I said, "perfectly normal situation."

"I don't think that incest is normal," he said, "God, what did I even think?"

"It's only incest if you penetrate me," I replied.

"Is it?" he said, as he raised his head up in surprise.

"Yeah man. Just stretching me isn't incest," I said.

"But what if we get caught? We would get in trouble," he said worryingly.

"Who is going to catch us? Dad is drunk asleep somewhere and mom is probably in bed," I reassured him, "besides, it's not illegal here and since no one will know or see, it's as if nothing ever happened."

I tried my best to try and make him go along with his own idea, but I knew that I could have tried to convince him in a better way. To this moment I never dreamt or even had the slightest thought of having sex with my brother. But I just couldn't say no to the first and only chance to feel a real cock pressing down on my ass. Besides, he is the one that suggested it and it would be like brothers helping each other, which is a good thing, sort of.

"Ok, let's do it," he said.

"Ok," I said, trying to contain my excitement, "so how do you want to do this?"

"I don't know. I didn't think that we would actually go through with it," he replied.

"Alright. So, do we both get naked?" I asked.

"No," he replied, "I'll just take my dick out and you just take out your ass."

"Sure. And do get into doggy?" I asked.

"Yeah. That will work," he replied.

I went over on the bed as I watched him unzip his flyer. I couldn't believe what a beautiful cock my brother had. Now, it felt weird thinking that, but damn, I couldn't lie to myself about it. It's bigger than my dick that's for sure, and it was veiny but not too veiny, just the right amount.

"I can't believe where are doing this. I am pretty excited about it," said my brother.

"Yeah, I can see that," I told myself as I saw his dick getting bigger.

I wasted no further time. I got on the bed, went into doggy and lowered my pants just below my ass. I tried to do it slowly, for dramatic purposes obviously.

"It's all up to you now," I told him.

As I finished my sentence, I felt his hand on my ass. I could hear him speaking under his breath how smooth my ass felt. This made my dick go from soft to hard and made me hornier than I already was. I eagerly waited to feel his cock against my ass, but all I felt was his other hand on my other ass cheek. Holy shit, he was spreading my ass and looking at my asshole almost at eye level. I wondered what was going on in his head in this moment.

"Um, in case you didn't know, that's where you need to put it," I said jokingly.

"Yeah, I know," he said, "I was actually seeing the difference between my girls' hole and yours. Her's looks a bit more open than yours if I saw yesterday."

"Everyone's different, you know," I said, realizing that his girl definitely had dicks up her ass before.

As he got more comfortable with his hands on my ass, he moved both of his thumbs closer to my hole, further spreading my cheeks apart. Then the magical moment happened, his cock making contact with my cock-craving hole. At first, I felt him pushing in, but that feeling immediately stopped. All I felt was his cock resting on my ass.

"Well, here I am," he said, relieved.

"Are you going to stop there?" I asked him.

"Uhh..." he muttered.

"Aren't you going too at least almost put your dick in me? Because you could have just did this with her," I told him.

"Yeah, you're right," he said.

I slowly started feeling him push his dick, trying to get inside of me. However, he wasn't using any lube and the more he pushed, the softer I felt his dick becoming.

"Oh damn. This was a waste of time. I can't even get hard now," he said.

"You didn't even put lube on!" I told him, "listen, go and get the lube, I have an idea."

As he went back to his room to get the lube he had, I got completely naked and laid down on the side of the bed. As he got back, he seemed almost shocked.

"Uh, why did you get naked?" he asked me.

"Oh, they were in my way and I wasn't comfortable either way," I told him, "listen, we have come so far so this shouldn't matter. Take off your clothes and come lay down here too."

He took off his clothes revealing his toned body. I never realised how hot my brother looked; no wonder women want him. As he went and lied on the bed, I grabbed the lube that he got and went and turned off the lights of the room.

"What are you doing?" asked my brother.

"Just stay there, close your eyes and relax. Imagine that I am your girlfriend," I told him.

"Having seen you naked with your dick out and your ass that looks l-," he suddenly gasped, "holy shit that feels strangely good."

"A blowjob is a blowjob," I said, as I was now between his legs feeling his dick around in my mouth and with my tongue.

I gotta say, this was turning out way better than I could have ever imagined. My only thought was that the first dick in my mouth and hopefully to soon be in my ass was a big dick. I slurrped his dick and jerked him off, I felt him inside my mouth getting hard again. In the heat of the moment, I even sucked his balls off.

At this point, I felt him that he was rock hard and that he was now moaning more, and I didn't want him to cum. So, I decided to continue with my plan. I grabbed the lube and applied some on my asshole and more on his dick. Then I got up in the bed and got on my knees on top of him.

"What are you doing?" he asked again.

"Just relax and let me guide you in," I told him.

I felt as if I had complete control all of a sudden. I turned around to get my back facing him. I grabbed his hard dick from behind and I gently sat down on it, aligning his dick on top of my ass. I felt the coldness of the lube from his dick on my ass and that's when I sat further down on it. I felt my hole opening up and his dick getting inside of me. Both of us where now moaning, him more than me. He grabbed me by my hips and at that moment I slammed down, filling up my ass with his hole dick.

"I shit look what you did, I am in you!" he said panicking.

"The lube made everything slippery and just kept sliding in," I told him, "but admit, it does feel great."

"Oh yeah, it does. But now this is incest, is it not?" he asked.

"Well, you told me that you wanted to practice anal on me, yes?" I asked him.

"Well yeah, but..." he said as I interrupted him.

"So why don't you see how far you can go before cumming?" I asked him.

"What? I don't want to fuck my brother," he said.

"You are already balls deep inside me and nothing bad has happened. As far as I know, we are both having fun," I stated.

"Well yeah but...", he said as I interrupted him again.

While saying all this, I was still sitting down on him with his dick buried deep inside me. So, I got a bit up until his cock was almost out of me and I immediately crashed back down. He moaned but didn't say a thing. I kept doing this until eventually, I was riding him.

It was feeling so good, definitely better than the small dildo I had. Hearing Tom moaning and knowing that I am pleasing another man with my ass, plus the damn good sensation I was getting of his dick thrusting in and out of me, it was almost divine.

A few minutes later as I was still riding him, in reverse cowgirl basically, still doing all the work, Tom started fucking me. As in he started making the effort to thrust his dick in me. I stopped riding him to let him fuck my ass. As I was enjoying just feeling his dick in me, I saw a shadow approaching my bedrooms door.

"Shit, someone's coming. Get under the sheets," I told Tom.

We got under the sheets, with his dick still in my ass. We were both lying on the bed under the sheets sideways. Tom still kept fucking me slowly even as the door opened. It was my dad and now I was terrified.

"Son, I just-," he said, clearly, he was still drunk.

"What do you want dad?" I asked him, with a calm tone trying to hide the pleasure of the dick in my ass.

"I just wanted to apol, apologise," he said.

"Yeah sure. Now can you leave so I can sleep?" I replied.

"Thank you, son," he said as he left the room, leaving the door wide open.

As he left, I let out a moan in relief of the one's I kept inside as Tom kept fucking me. I was going to get up to close the door, but Tom just grabbed me from my shoulders and pinned me down. Suddenly I felt as if I lost complete control of the situation. Tom was now fucking me hard and harder; we were still on our sides. Tom didn't say anything, he was only grunting.

Then very unexpectedly, he grabbed my leg and lifted it up. I do say unexpectedly, but at this point having my brother fucking me this hard compared to lifting my leg up is really nothing. He kept fucking me in this position.

"Damn big bro," I said as I was moaning, "if you fuck your girl like this, she will definitely like it."

He didn't say anything, and he kept fucking me. I started jerking myself off as I felt my brother's big dick making his way through my ass. This moment made me feel I was in ecstasy, and then I came. I must have blacked out as soon as I cummed because the next thing I know is waking up the next morning.

As I woke up, I felt that I was still naked and that the bedsheets were off of me. I woke up in a hurry to check the room and saw that the door was left open. My brother was nowhere to be seen and as I hurried to close the door, I heard my mom shouting that breakfast was ready.

I closed the door and put some clothes on and went straight downstairs. I found my brother and father around the table talking.

"Where the hell did you go last night?" said my dad to my brother, "I came into your room and you weren't there."

"Yeah, I... Well...", my brother murmured.

"Don't tell me; you snuck off for a good time with your girl?" my dad said with a large smile on his face.

"Uh, yeah. I did. Have a good time," my brother said.

"Good good. At least one of my sons is having fun," said my dad as he looked at me, "unlike someone who likes to sleep naked and leaves his door open for everyone to see."

I buried my head in my plate and tried my best not to look at him. All of a sudden, I felt something in my ass. I mean, I was feeling my hard used hole all morning, but I was feeling almost something coming out of me? My first thought was that I lost the feeling in my ass with the hard fucking my brother did and was now shitting myself.

"so, did you fill her up full?" my dad asked my brother quietly.

"Oh yeah, the tank was completely empty at the end," my brother replied.

"Make sure that both of you are taking precautions. You don't want to be a father just yet," my dad told my brother.

"Don't worry dad. There definitely won't be any babies around. Especially considering where the tank was emptied," said my brother as he looked at me.

"Oh nice. That's the best stuff. Looks like it was your first time," stated my dad.

"Yeah. And it definitely won't be the last time," said my brother, again as he looked at me.

All of a sudden, I felt my face turning red as I realised after hearing my brother and dad talk that what I was feeling coming out of my ass could possibly be my brother's cum. I immediately went to the bathroom to confirm my suspicion and indeed it was. I took a picture with my phone to serve as a memento. I was about to push the cum out of my ass but decided to leave it in, just so that I enjoy the sensation of being bred for the first time, by my brother.