An Unexpected Hoo Up

College was a time to stretch your wings, to grow and experiment and at 19 and still in great shape, I was ready to. Unfortunately, a heavy course load and a religious upbringing kept me from getting too immersed in the party life of my East Texas college. In fact, so far the only hookups I had were with an ex from high school that was attending the same college and Sarah, a sophomore girl I met at the first party I went to. Although I wasn't looking for a relationship, Sarah was proving to be a dependable fuck buddy and study partner. After the first party (where we essentially dry humped on the dance floor) we hooked up at least once a week. Soon, we fell into a regular schedule of meeting up, studying, then back to her dorm and a marathon sex session.

Tonight wasn't too unusual in our routine. It was the week before mid terms and we both had a ton of homework and exams to prepare for. We went to iHop with a pile of notes and our laptops planning to study in silence while enjoying the free coffee refills. The silence didn't last long thought, my concentration kept getting broken by the sound of Sarah's phone vibrating against the table. The screen showing a snapchat notification from a guy named Allen. I vaguely knew who Allen was, Sarah had mentioned him a few times as a guy that she met/hooked up with the year before and still occasionally hung out with. We weren't dating and I wasn't the jealous type anyway so I didn't think much of it at first.

At least not until she laughed and put her palm against her forehead. "So you know my friend Allen right? He just asked what you look like so I showed him and he called you hot!" she said in a voice of disbelief. "He's this like manly country guy but apparently he's bi? That's so weird right?" she said while still laughing.

I look up in surprise and try not to seem too interested but my body feels alert. "Wait really? I don't think any guy has ever called me that before." I say laughing. It was true, none had flirted with me at least that I knew of. I had however thought about guys before and watched more gay porn than a straight guy should but still convinced myself it didn't mean anything. Or at least, I thought that as long as I didn't actually do anything it didn't mean anything. So what if I had fingered my own ass, it wasn't a sin as long as it was just me right?

Sarah's phone lights up again with another message from Allen. "Yeah, apparently you're his type, I honestly never would have even guessed he was bi." She says while opening her phone and then laughs again. "oh my gosh! really?" she says with another burst of giggles.

I try to play it cool but she brought it up right? "What did he say now?" I ask casually while trying not to remember if she had ever shown me a picture of him. "What does he look like?'

Sarah just shakes her head before looking back up from her phone. "He says he wants your snap, should I give it to him?"

I just shrug in response. "I mean I guess, I'm not gay so I don't really care" I say while internally wondering if that was true. My cock starts to get stiff providing proof to the contrary and I'm glad that the table between us would keep Sarah from noticing.

She sends Allen my username and then puts her phone down again. "So weird, like how can a guy like that be in to guys?" An instant later my phone lights up with a friend request from Allen. I make myself wait almost a full minute before picking it up to hide my interest. Then as soon as I add him back I get a selfie of a very cute shirtless red head with curly hair and beautiful green eyes. I send him one back while Sarah gives me a questioning look.

I wink at her and say "don't worry about it" like its all a joke. Allen responds quickly with another selfie and the text "you're hot." I try to fight the grin but Sarah notices it. "Are you seriously texting him? You know what... it actually kind of makes sense you two are a lot alike. You'd probably really get along." She says in a thoughtful tone but not believing that I would actually flirt back with him. I text him back "I've never actually flirted with a guy." Before looking at her and laughing a little "what? he's nice" I say chuckling. She just smiles and shakes her head before going back to her work.

I try to focus as well but soon Allen replies. "There's a first time for everything. " I use my best poker face to keep Sarah from noticing anything more. "There sure is ;)." After that I keep my phone in my hand so she won't hear my phone vibrate and keep it hidden behind my open laptop while pretending to still work. I never thought I would actually do anything with a guy but now that the opportunity has presented itself it's like the previous mental block disappeared. Allen texts back, "Then I guess you've also never had your ass eaten out?"

I fight the impulse to groan while wondering what that might feel like. "No sir, are you going to cross off that first for me too?"

He replies, "why don't you show me that ass and I'll tell you everything I'll do to it."

I look up at Sarah and see her still immersed in her work and I quickly excuse myself to the bathroom hoping it doesn't seem suspicious. As soon as I make it to a stall I pull my pants down below my firm ass cheeks and take a few pictures before finding an angle that I like. How do girls get so good at taking those I wonder before getting another message. "Fuck that looks tasty."

"Show me what you want to put in it" I send back while stroking my now fully hard cock, thankful for the privacy of the small stall.

A few seconds later I get reply with a cock that looks slightly bigger than my own 6" and girthy with a bush of red hair visible at the base. I bite my lip and respond with a dick pic of my own. "I feel like I might have to suck my first cock." I tell him. I know I cant stay much longer without Sarah getting suspicious so I tuck my cock into the band of my shorts to hide the bulge and go back to the table. I set my phone down just as Allen responds and Sarah notices the name before I can hide it. She shakes her head, "He's still texting you?"

I play it off again, "he's cool, we're just talking about games and stuff" I say nonchalantly. I wait a few more minutes before picking my phone up again. This time he just sent his dorm room and the words "whenever you want."

"Give me like an hour" I send back, both not wanting to make Sarah suspicious and also not wanting to completely ditch her.

I put my phone down and time out another ten minutes, ignoring the next message from him. "I think I'm just going to finish this works cited page and then call it an early night." I say out loud. Sarah doesn't look up from her notes before answering. "Yeah, honestly I was planning on getting a good nights sleep before the test tomorrow."

I nod in response and keep working until the page I'm working on is presentable. Then I close my laptop and sigh. "I feel like I still have a lot to do but I'm beat." I say. Sarah closes her computer too "honestly midterms next week might kill me but yeah, I'm done. Sleep tonight and play tomorrow?" she asks with a grin.

I nod back, "yeah definitely." I say while getting up from the table. We make the walk back to campus without talking about anything important and I try not to think about meeting Allen. As soon as Sarah splits off to go to her dorm building, I pull my phone out to check the room number for his. "I'm on my way." I type quickly with trembling fingers.

My heart beats a little faster in my chest and I try not to think over think what I'm about to do. It's a line that I've never crossed before, and I hadn't really thought that I would cross. I make my way to Allen's building which is the next street over from mine. Before I know it I'm face to face with his door. I consider turning away and going to bed or texting Sarah and asking to go to her room. I consider everything but then I knock.

The door opens and I'm frozen. Allen grins at me with eyes that are just as beautiful in person. He stands an inch shorter than my 6'2 frame, my eyes roam to his muscular chest and biceps, his sweatpants already showing an obvious bulge. Before I can say or do anything he takes my hand and pulls me in from the hallway and closes the door.

With a girl I would know what to do from here. But with him it feels like the mental block returns. I stand awkwardly in front of him with his hand still gripping mine. "You're hotter in person" he says still grinning. I swallow dryly but manage to say "you too." Allen steps closer and puts his free hand in the small of my back and I feel my chest flip tightly. "Can I kiss you?" he asks.

I just nod, my mouth feeling suddenly dry. "I really haven't ever done this before." I tell him while he leans towards me. He whispers back "It's ok, we'll go slow" before his lips touch mine. My eyes close. His lips feel fuller than I would've expected. The kiss is firm but sweet, distinctly different from kissing a girl in a way that I can't fully explain. Our lips part further and he wraps both arms around me. My hands shake slightly but slide around his back, feeling the muscles there. As the kiss deepens I feel the unfamiliar scratch of stubble against my cheek.

My tongue tentatively slides into his mouth, exploring it while his hands explore my body. One of his hands slides lower to grasp my butt cheek while the other moves around to slide up my shirt and rests on my abdomen making the skin feel sensitive in a way that no girl ever really has. My heart is still beating out of my chest but I revel in how overwhelmingly natural it all feels. I feel frozen and lost in his embrace and our kiss but I manage to move one hand up and my fingers get lost in his red curls.

We stay like that for what feels like an eternity but then he pulls away. His eyes look into mine, "lets go to bed" he says with his lips just a breath away from mine. I nod and he pulls away then grabs my hand and leads me back to his room.

I feel light headed as I'm pulled through the apartment sized dorm until suddenly I'm in his room. He just grins at me and I can't help but smile back before laughing when he pushes down on to the bed. The laughter is quickly stifled by his mouth on mine. The kisses grow more urgent and I feel his weight on top of me. My hands resting in the small of his back while his push up under my shirt lifting it up. Then his lips move to my ear and nibble on it ever so gently. His mouth moves lower on my jawline, then my neck. My fingers claw at his back and my legs wrap over his while his bulge rubs over mine. Then his mouth moves lower and I feel his teeth scrap against my nipple I let out a low moan. He looks up and grins again while pinching my other nipple.

"Fuck why does that feel so good" I say in a low voice. He just grins and then continues lower with one hand still teasing my nipples. His mouth travels across my abdomen stopping just above my waist line. He stops and looks up at me. "Is this ok?" he asks while rubbing his hand across my rock hard bulge. I just nod down urgently.

He continues teasing the skin above my waist line while unbuttoning and then unzipping my shorts. My hands reach down to play with his hair while he pushes my shorts and boxers down. His lips traveling with the garments teasing the sensitive skin around my extremely hard cock. "you have such a beautiful dick." He whispers before dragging his tongue up my shaft and forcing another moan from my throat. Then with an expertise I'd never experienced before he takes my entire cock in his mouth. His eyes still watching my reaction while his tongue slides around my shaft.

His mouth begins to bob and saliva drips down on my hairy balls. His hand gathers some of it and rubs it down closer to my virgin hole. I moan again and shift my hips up to give him better access. Then with my cock still in his mouth he pushes a finger deep inside. "mhmm fuck" I moan while his finger slides up to the knuckle inside me. My hands gripping his thick curls and his mouth never loses his rhythm. Soon his finger is pumping in and out of me and pressing against my prostate in time with the motions of his mouth.

"Shit fuck! I'm going to cum soon!" I moan but he doesn't slow down. He gathers more saliva and presses a second finger into me. At first the additional girth makes my teeth grit with the sting but my ass soon relaxes around his digits. I let out another moan knowing that I'm about to release into another man's mouth for the first time. He speeds up and I feel my ass constrict around his fingers and the familiar tension in my balls before I shoot a huge load of cum into his mouth. He continues at the same pace as I cum and I feel my legs spasm with the force of it but he doesn't spill a drop.

He finally pulls away while I gasp from the strongest orgasm of my life. "Holy shit" I say between breaths. He just grins at me and pulls up to lay on top again and kisses me before asking. "Wanna keep going?" I blush a little and hope the post nut clarity doesn't set in and make me leave but I nod and he bites my lip before telling me to take my shirt off and roll over. I feel nervous again but obey. I try not to overthink what might come next.

Allen is sweet and slow and I soon find myself relaxed again. He strips off his shirt too before again kissing my neck and working his way down my back. I relax into the bed when I feel his lips on my ass cheek. Then his hands spread my cheeks and I feel his tongue dragging my balls up to my tight hole. I let out another moan and feel my toes curl when his tongue slides around the opening and pushes in. I press my face into the soft sheets and let out another moan while he eats my hole. My ass pressing up against his face and I grip the sheets. The feeling is intoxicating and indescribable.

His hands grip my ass while his tongue attacks my ass with the same ferocity that he used to suck my cock. Then his tongue disappears and I look back over my shoulder. I drink in the view of Allen now completely naked, His muscular but slim body looks like a dream and the sight of his fully erect cock makes me bite my lip. He walks to the dresser and pulls out a bottle of lube and says "are you ready baby?"

For just a moment I feel myself freeze again, the nerves return and my mind flashes through all the reasons why I haven't done this before. It only lasts a second and my eyes go slowly from his cock to his eyes. "I'm ready" I say while pushing my ass up and spreading my legs further.

"good boy" He says while moving forward to kiss my bussy again then dropping lube on the outside and pushing some in with a finger. I feel the mattress shift while he lines up behind me. His hands spread on my back and in a soft voice he tells me to just relax and let myself enjoy it.

My eyes squeeze shut and I feel his thick bulbous tip pressing against my opening. I let out a breath and try to relax but then grip the sheets and gasp with pain as he pushes into me. "it's ok, just relax I promise" He whispers while rubbing my back. He pushes slowly deeper into me, then I feel a small pop as he makes it past the head. It still stings but i breathe out again and let go of the sheets. He slides further in and I hold my breath until he makes it about halfway in. He pulls back slightly and I let out another gasp when he pushes back in deeper than before.

He does this a few times, moving slowly in and out careful to not back out too far and then pushing deeper inside me all while caressing my back. "You're so tight baby, you're doing so good." he tells me until I feel him bottom out inside me. The sting has subsided now and when he pulls back out pushes in I gasp with pleasure more than pain. I let out another low moan and he tells me that he's going to speed up. I nod and press my face into the sheets again then let out a grunt when he pulls out half way and thrusts back deep into me. His cock makes me feel full in the best way.

His pace starts to pick up more and I start to push back against his thrusts. "fuck you feel so good' I moan. "Baby you're so tight" He says back while thrusting harder and faster into my tight ass.

"I could do this every night" I say while pushing back against the hard thrusts of his cock. "maybe you should" he grunts while fucking my ass with increased force.

Soon his balls are slapping against mine and I'm pushed deeper into the mattress. My moans growing louder as he fucks me, the room is filled with the wet slapping noise of our bodies coming together in primal ecstasy. "Baby I'm going to cum!" He moans. I know I should tell him to pull out but I can only moan in response. I feel his cock pulse inside me as his thick heavy load shoots into my rectum. His thrusts continuing through the orgasm and cum leaks out around his shaft and drips down onto the sheets.

Finally he starts to slow and collapses on top of me with his cock still deep in me. His arms around me while we lay still and recover. I look over my shoulder at him and smile. He leans in to kiss me, "so... every night huh?"