Author's Note: I'm introducing quite a few new characters here with plans for more types to come into the story from this leather club. Would love to hear feedback and/or suggestions for where or who to take the story to next. Enjoy!
_________________________________
"I'll have the beef filet and a manhattan to drink. And he'll have the salmon with, let's see...is a Tito's and soda, okay with you?" President May peered at me over his menu waiting for my response.
"Err...yes Sir. That sounds great. Thank you." President May smiled, took both our menus and handed them to the waiter.
That was different, I thought. Intentionally, I had waited to allow President May to order first. I knew that was only right, but I had not expected him to order for me. His question about my preference for tilapia or salmon a few minutes earlier made more sense in light of what just happened. I shifted tentatively in my seat and looked around the restaurant once more.
Crispino's was an elegant family steakhouse on the edge of Southlake. Southlake was a wealthy suburb filled with gated neighborhoods, fine dining, and high achieving schools. I had never been to a restaurant in this part of town before. When I looked at the menu I saw why. The prices were much too fat for my skinny wallet.
We sat at a two person table in a more secluded part of the restaurant. I was thankful we had the advantage of privacy with it being my first ever public date with another man―not that anyone would have guessed the two of us were on a date given our age difference. I wore a green checkered button up shirt and my nicest and tightest pair of blue jeans at President May's request. He was always the most handsy with me when I wore this pair to his house or to work for casual Fridays. President May wore the shirt I had helped him choose earlier that day― dark blue shirt with a tiny white diamond speck pattern throughout. He also wore a dark pair of jeans of a much higher quality fabric and clear signs of a personal tailored touch. A black belt and dress shoes completed this handsome look.
When our drinks arrived, President May raised his glass and offered a toast. "To the most intelligent and most handsome young man I know. You've been a breath of fresh air when I needed it most. You've made me feel young again. Thank you for being such a," he paused a moment and then lowered his voice, "good boy!"
I blushed. I did most times when I heard those two magical words (and many times my pants would tighten). I could tell his words were sincere. It was now my turn to say something. "And to the man I have learned so much from and look up to more than anyone in the world. You've helped me accept myself for who I am. I don't know what I would do without you. I am glad I can call you..." I checked around to make sure no one was listening, "Daddy."
President May's smile stretched wider at the utterance of that last word. Even the corners of his eyes curled upward in delight. Our glasses clinked, and we each took a drink.
"Now Johnny, tonight is a special night. Or, so I hope. I have a gift for you. More of an offering, really."
I straightened up a little. My heart beat with anticipation.
"I've thoroughly enjoyed our time together over this past month," President May continued, "I love having you over to my home, having dinner with you, watching films, getting to know you in mind —and in body." Both of us feigned a smile. "When I say you're a good boy, I think you understand there is nuance in that term. It is not meant to be demeaning. It simply speaks to relationships, to hierarchy."
He took a moment to read my reaction and see if I followed his words. I nodded my understanding.
"You play that role very well. You've made me a proud father, which is why," he reached into his shirt pocket and pulled out a small silver object, "I want you to dive deeper into that role."
He placed the object between us and snapped it onto the table. It was a key.
"What is that?" I asked.
President May chuckled, "It's a key, obviously."
"Yes, I know. But what's it to?"
"Think. You're a smart boy." At that moment our salads arrived. This gave me a few seconds to think.
"Your house?" I said, going with the most obvious answer.
"Correct. John, I am offering you a key to my house. I want you to move in with me."
My eyes widened. I took a deep breath. I reached to pick up the key. I I wanted to feel the brass in my fingers.
"Hold on," President May said, placing his hand over the key, "It's not yours yet. This key comes with a set of rules and expectations."
With a disappointed look I pondered what he was getting at. I could tell by the tone of his voice it was more to this daddy/boy hierarchy we had been operating in. There was something I didn't know yet.
"What kind of rules? Expectations?"
President May looked around to see if anyone was listening. He leaned forward and rested his elbows on the table. His voice was direct and in the volume of a whisper.
"You may think you know what it means to be a good boy, but truthfully, you barely know the half of it. Tonight, I intend to teach you it's full meaning." He sat back in its seat and his voice returned to a normal volume. "But, this is hardly the place for that conversation. Plus, it would be more fun to show you." He smiled with only one side of his face. His eyes were now aflame with a seductive light. He knew he was teasing me, torturing my curiosity. And he loved every minute of it.
"What do you mean? Show me?"
"If you want to find out, you'll have to come with me after dinner." He took a sip of his drink, but his eyes never broke our gaze.
"Where are we going?"
"Don't you trust me?" He said, raising his eyebrows at me. His words were as much an accusation as they were a question. I looked down at my salad. I did not respond. "Perhaps, you don't. Maybe this is too soon." He reached across the table to take back the key.
"No! Don't!" My hand slammed on top of the key before he could take it. The collision of my hand hitting the table combined with my sudden outburst made a large enough ruckus for the nearby tables to notice. I looked away embarrassed and President May waved at the tables and flashed an apologetic smile to them before looking back at me. His smile grew as he looked at my desperate face. He knew he had me―hook, line, and sinker.
"Sorry," I said, "It's not too soon. I do want to move in with you. I do trust you."
"Good. Then you will come with me after dinner. Until then, however," he reached across the table and lifted my hand off the key, "this will remain with me." He snatched the key up and slid it back into his shirt pocket. I stared at that shirt pocket as if I had x-ray vision and could see the key through it's cloth. I felt like a kid on Christmas morning that just had his present from Santa taken away.
"Eat your salad." President May's words snapped me back into reality.
"Yes Sir." I said. I picked up my fork and began eating.
The key and our after dinner destination were not mentioned for the remainder of dinner, though the two were constantly in the forefront of my mind. My salmon was delicious, but I couldn't help be envious of President May's plate. My mouth watered every time he cut into the bloody filet. I felt guilty for having these thoughts. I should be more grateful. This fancy dinner was on his dime after all. There would be ways to thank President May for his generosity later, I told myself.
President May signed the check and downed the last of his drink (his second of the night). "Alright, my boy. Time to go." We stood up to leave.
"Where are we going?" I asked, trying to tread lightly.
President May answered without bothering to look at me. "Hush boy. Trust Daddy." Without another word, I followed him out of the restaurant.
The car ride over was uncomfortably silent. President May was intent on keeping an aura of mystery. We passed many bars and restaurants as he navigated his BMW through the city streets. I noticed we had left Southlake and entered into a part of town I had never been before. After another couple of miles, he made a right turn and soon all I could see was bar after bar with various patrons spilling out on the sidewalks. It took me a couple seconds, but I realized there was a common demographic among all these people. They were all men.
We were in "the gayborhood," or so it was called on campus. I had never been to a gay bar before. I was not out, and while the thought intrigued me, I never had gathered enough courage to venture to one. I turned and looked at President May. He gave me a couple seconds of side eye. His face was expressionless, but he knew I had figured out the relative location of our next adventure. Still, he said nothing. His hands turned over one after the other as he pulled his car over to the side of the road in front of a valet booth. I looked up and saw a large red neon sign that read "The Phoenix." The valet, a young athletic guy not much older than me, rushed to the driver's side and opened the door for President May.
"Sir May, welcome back! How are you tonight?" the valet greeted.
"I'm good. Thank you, Mitchell." President May said as he got out of the car. "Is Master Martin here yet?"
"Yes Sir. He wanted me to tell you he has reserved a private table for you upstairs."