As my birthday celebrations wrapped up, I said goodbye to my friends and got in my parents' car to drive home. I had just turned 19 and my friends had taken me out for dinner to celebrate. We had had a few laughs and a good meal, but secretly, I was desperate to get home.
I was a virgin at 19. Deep in the closet, I had been too afraid to try and meet a guy or date. I had decided that tonight, my 19th birthday, was the night I would lose my virginity. I was planning on downloading Grindr and finding the perfect guy for my first time. I was giddy with excitement and fear.
As I pulled into the laneway, I went inside. My parents were upstairs watching TV in bed. I knew they would be asleep soon, as it was already almost midnight. Heading downstairs to my basement bedroom, I pulled off my tight, light blue jeans, and got into my bed. Pulling out my phone, I opened the App Centre and found the app, clicking download.
Within a few seconds, the yellow and black icon had appeared on my home screen.
I opened it and started to fill out the profile.
Thankfully, I consider myself an attractive young guy. I'm somewhat short, at 5'7" and slender -- weighing in at just 135lbs. My brown hair is coifed into a faux hawk and I have green eyes that a few of my female friends have said are "cute". I liked to think so too...
I flipped through my phone and found a selfie that I thought showcased my face in a nice light. I also took a picture of me without my shirt on, hoping that my slender body might catch a guy's eye. I thought my ass looked pretty cute in my boxer briefs...
In the description section, I wrote out what I wanted:
"Young virgin looking for sweet, caring Daddy for first time"
I knew I wanted an older man for my first time. I had always been drawn to more mature men. I loved their masculinity and their confidence. Most of all, I really just wanted to be held by a man in his strong arms. I wanted to feel pretty and desired.
With my profile complete, I clicked on "Done" and was immediately taken to the page I wanted...
My phone was flooded with pictures of guys. Some handsome, some not, some young, some old. A little bit of everything.
I started flipping through the profiles, amazed at how many guys were close by in my suburban neighbourhood. Immediately I started getting messages. It seemed that an 19-year old virgin was a hot commodity...
I reached under my bed and pulled out a shoe box I had hidden under there. Reaching inside, I pulled out a dildo and a bottle of lube. These had been my only sexual solace for the past year as I imagined being with a man. I had bought them shortly after my 18th birthday. Wiggling out of my underwear, I squirted some lube on my finger and gently worked it into my tight hole. The dildo looked like a realistic cock -- about 6" with a reasonable girth. It was connected to a remote and had a vibrating feature. I turned it on and started rubbing it against my little bud. It felt so nice, gently pulsating against the hole. I felt my little cock getting hard at the feeling and I closed my eyes momentarily, imagining that it was a real man.
As my hole relaxed, I started to slide the dildo inside, feeling every inch slowly push inside my eager ass. My cock throbbed with pleasure. Finally, when the dildo was buried inside my tight butt, I turned up the vibration, wiped my hand with a tissue, and picked up my phone again.
There were at least 10 messages now. I flipped through them quickly. A few had no profile pictures, so I deleted their messages and moved on. A few of the guys were too young. One was an older man, but very overweight. But then, I opened one message and was delighted to see a truly handsome looking Daddy profile pic.
"Hey baby. I'd love to help you with your first time. What's your name sweetie?"
He was rugged looking, with a trim beard, crew cut brown hair, and piercing blue eyes. He was 51 but still very much in shape. In his second picture, he was shirtless at a cottage. Although he didn't have a rippling six-pack, he was well built, with a nice bit of a hair on his chest. I could imagine myself nestled up against that chest, feeling the hair brush against my smooth cheek as I nuzzled against him. I felt my cock throb at the thought...
My hands were trembling as I returned to his message and started to reply.
"Hiya :) I'm Evan. Nice to meet you! My gosh, you look super handsome lol."
I reached down and touched my cock lightly and readjusted the dildo still pulsating in my ass.
"Nice to meet you too Evan. I'm Steve. And you look very pretty! There's no way you're still a virgin looking that good?"
I blushed at the compliment.
"Aww, thanks. Ya, I've actually never been with a guy. I'm kinda still in the closet...But today is my birthday so I decided I really want to finally have my first time. Just want to find the right guy to share it with :)"
"Happy Birthday sweetie! Wow, still can't believe that you've never been with a man. But you're right to take things slow and find the right guy who will take care of you."
"Have you been with many guys?" I asked, pulling the dildo out my ass now that it had been well stretched.
"Yes and no", he replied, "I'm actually married, so I don't get to be with men as often. But my wife and daughter are out of town this weekend."
I felt a flutter in my chest...Married and a daddy-type? Super hot. But I was nervous about the idea of being with a married man.
"So you're hoping to have some fun while they're away I guess?"
"Well...hoping to find some cute young thing to share my bed with me while they're gone, ya," he answered. "What do you really want to try with a guy, if you don't mind me asking?"
"Honestly, everything!" I replied, letting my mind wander through my various fantasies. "I want to try giving a man a blow job, getting rimmed, frotting, and ideally getting fucked for the first time. Also, I know it's silly, but I want to try making out and cuddling too..."
"That's not silly at all", came the reply, "I love holding a young man in my arms and kissing him softly, rubbing my hands over his body. And, of course, the other things are also fun! Are you sure you want to try getting fucked on your first time?"
"Yes!!!" I typed back enthusiastically. "I've actually had a dildo in my ass while we've been chatting hehe! I love the feeling of having my ass filled up. But I really want to feel a real man inside of me."
"Wow, that's hot baby. I would love to be your first. I'll take it nice and slow."
A picture popped up in the chat box and I opened it. I was looking at the nicest cock I had ever seen. 7" with a beautiful curve and nice head. I felt myself drooling as I looked at it.
I realized that he'd probably want a picture from me too. I stood up and walked over to the mirror at my closet. Twisting my body and popping my ass out, I took a shot of my naked bubble butt. Nervously, I uploaded it and sent it to Steve.
"What a gorgeous bum sweetie," he replied almost immediately, "It's making me hard just looking at it"
I smiled with pride.
"Your cock is incredible! I would love to wrap my lips around it!" I replied eagerly.
"I bet you'd worship it so well baby. So what other fantasies do you have?"
"What do you mean?" I responded.
"Oh come on, you're an 19 year-old virgin. You must have tons of unfulfilled sexual fantasies. What really turns you on?"
"Umm, well I really want to try eating cum. And I'd love to take a shower with a guy. And, you know...other things lol."
"Other things like what? You can tell me anything"
I gulped, wondering if I could tell him my real fantasy. The conversation was going so well. And Steve seemed so perfect...I didn't want to ruin it by saying something that scared him off. But I did have a fantasy...one that I had had for some time.
"It's fine, it's probably too weird lol. I just want to be with a handsome guy like you :)" I replied.
"Don't be shy baby, you can tell me. What's your real fantasy?"
I paused, my heart racing. This was the first time I was really talking with a guy about my gay dreams. Was I really ready to talk about my deepest yearnings?
What the heck...it is my birthday.
"Well...umm...my big fantasy is to be feminized by an older man. Dressed up in girly clothes and fucked like a girl...I know, super weird :S"
My cock was rock hard at this point. I was absent-mindedly rubbing the tip as I waited for his reply.
"That's not weird at all. I'd love to make you my little girl."
I felt some precum dribble out of my cock as I read his reply.
"Really, you think that would be hot?"
"Ya, so hot! You're actually probably the same size as my daughter. I bet you'd fit into some of her clothes if wanted to dress up for me. I'd treat you like a proper girl."
My heart melted. I couldn't believe it. Here was a handsome man of my dreams who was willing to not only take my cherry but also fulfill my deepest fantasy.
"That would be amazing Steve! You've got me so turned on!"
"Me too baby. So what do you think, do you want to come over?"
My heart was racing as I considered the request. Every fiber of my being wanted to say yes. I wanted to rush over there and become this man's girl for the night. But the rational part of my brain was putting up red signs.
What if he didn't take it slow?
What if he had an std?
What if he took pictures of me dressed up and blackmailed me?
I bit my lip and squeezed my cock. After a moment of not replying, he messaged me again.
"I promise I'd take it slow with you and treat you special. And if you don't enjoy it, you can head home, no problem. I'd love to share this moment with you on your birthday, Evan."