πŸ“š what the night gave bac Part 1 of 2
Part 1Next β†’
what-the-night-gave-back-pt-01
FIRST TIME SEX STORIES

What The Night Gave Back Pt 01

What The Night Gave Back Pt 01

by capncourageous
19 min read
4.53 (3700 views)
adultfiction

The bar buzzed with that particular strain of artificial energy office parties always carried--laughter just a little too loud, posture just a little too casual, everyone pretending, aware of who was watching them. She sipped her drink, a gin and tonic, well made, but more prop than pleasure. Her smile was perfect, angled just enough to seem easygoing, her posture was open, turned toward the group of men nearby. She wasn't flirting. Not exactly. But they'd noticed her. They always did.

She knew how to send the signals out: a slight lean forward when she laughed, an idle finger tracing condensation on her glass, eyes lingering an extra beat on someone's mouth when they talked. It was a practiced instinct by now Even when she wasn't consciously performing, the pattern played itself out--muscle memory by now. For control. For safety. For something unnamed, but always just out of reach. For something she hadn't named yet but kept looking for anyway.

She liked them, as far as that went. And in the brief space between small talk and suggestive touches, she felt something close to intimacy. That twinge of electricity when someone shifted closer. The heat of being seen. It was the only time in her life when her body made sense--when arousal was hers to summon, command.

Sex was fine. Occasionally good. Mostly, it was a way to discharge what built up in her skin like static. Afterwards, she'd clean up and slip into oversized sweats. And yet, it always left her a little hollow.

Tonight, had started the same. The blouse she picked was a little more daring, the skirt showing just the right amount of toned leg. She'd even picked black lace underwear, assuming... And yet--half an hour in--she already knew. These men would flirt with her and imagine her in some hotel bed, and she sometimes let that happen, enough to feel desired. But not tonight. She took another sip and let her gaze wander. Not looking for anyone in particular. Maybe just... a way out.

That's when she noticed me. My clothes were nothing flashy. Dark jeans, a shirt that seemed like it could've been worn any day of the week. I clearly wasn't trying to impress anyone, and she found that oddly attractive. Most guys in the room were all about their clothes, their image. Something about me felt unexpectedly refreshing.

She liked sharp, polished, confident men who knew how to command attention. But I wasn't trying to be seen. I looked like I was there out of politeness, maybe obligation--nursing a drink I wasn't really drinking, nodding when someone near me said something. Quiet. Still. Not hiding. Just... not loud. Not trying. It was disarming. I hadn't even glanced her way, and that--

that

--made something flutter unexpectedly in her chest. There was something about the way I held myself just outside the party, watching. She'd felt powerful with the men near her, but now, for the first time all night, she felt

curious

.

She kept watching. Not openly, not even deliberately--but her gaze drifted back to me again and again. The way I sat there, still but not stiff, made her wonder what I was thinking. I didn't seem bored--just untouched by the room. Like I could hear it all, feel the same press of bodies and noise, but none of it reached me. She didn't know what it meant. Only that it felt different. Unhurried. Unneedy. It made her heart tremble again, though she tried to ignore it.

She turned back. The man beside her was saying something about the conference, leaning in a little too close--the way some men do when they mistake proximity for charm. She smiled automatically, let her fingers trail the rim of her glass like she was still listening. But something tugged at the edge of her attention. Not loud. Just there. She glanced at me again. Still sitting the same way. Still not looking for anything but watching everything. She looked away. Then looked again. It was a pull. Quiet, steady. Like something inside her had tilted in my direction and was waiting for her to follow. So, she did.

She was walking toward me.

The way she moved--fluid, graceful--impossible to ignore. Her outfit wasn't just stylish--it placed her in another world entirely, meant for someone with effortless grace and presence, far beyond mine. The way she wore it, the way she owned it. She wore confidence and elegance like silk--draped around her, part of her.

But it wasn't just her clothes. It was her beauty. The way her eyes caught the light, a depth, a radiance. Her cheeks, soft and flushed, the dimples that appeared when she smiled. The rhythm with which she moved, the ease, her style. She wasn't just beautiful; she was class and grace rolled into one.

She'd been talking to someone--no, smiling. One of those unmistakable, practiced smiles you use when flirting. I didn't think anything of it until I realized she kept glancing over. At me. I looked away, assuming I was in the way of something. The bar. The door. A reflection, maybe. But when I looked again, she was still watching.

Then she started walking. Not toward the bar. Not toward the door. Toward me.

My hand tightened on my glass. I set it down--too carefully--and wiped my palm against my jeans. Casual. Like I wasn't thinking about it. Like my heart wasn't suddenly louder than the music.

A small, unreadable smile. And then, just like that, she was there.

She sat in the chair across from me. "You don't look like you're having fun," she said.

I glanced over, caught off guard but trying not to show it. "Is it that obvious?" I asked.

"A little," she said. Then added, "Not in a bad way."

"It looked like you were having fun over there. Something go wrong?" I said.

"I didn't think you were watching," she said, sipping from her glass, eyes on me over the rim. "I don't really know... Maybe I'm tired of the usual noise," she continued. "And... you weren't trying to get me to come over."

She gave a half-shrug, like even she wasn't sure what she meant. "I just thought... you looked like someone I could talk to."

"So, you come here often?" I blurted before I could stop myself.

She raised an eyebrow. "Is that your best line?"

I shrugged and smiled--and waited.

πŸ“– Related First Time Sex Stories Magazines

Explore premium magazines in this category

View All β†’

She leaned in slightly, voice soft and conspiratorial.

"I may or may not have had one too many. You're not gonna let me get lost in a hallway somewhere, are you?"

I smiled. "Now, why do I get the feeling you'd be just fine finding your way anywhere... but I like the idea of you needing a rescue."

She tilted her head, the corners of her mouth lifting. "Maybe I do too."

I gave her a dramatic little bow in my seat. "Well then, m'lady, if I am to be your Knight in Shining Armor tonight, I shall bravely protect you from all rogue hallways and treacherous carpeting."

She giggled and sipped her drink, eyes dancing. "Careful. Keep that up and I might start thinking you're actually charming."

I tried not to blush. Failed. "That sounds dangerously close to a compliment."

"A rare one. Use it wisely." She paused, her eyes glinting.

Then, with a knowing tilt of her head: "So... you come here often?"

I laughed softly. "TouchΓ©. Not really. Mostly work events."

She looked at me like she expected more, then just smiled. "Yeah. Me too."

Her expression softened as she studied me for a moment. "You're better at this than you might think."

The conversation unfolded gently, the clatter of the party fading into a soft hum. Neither of us rushed to fill the spaces between words--we let them breathe.

We ended up at a quieter table near the back, tucked just enough out of the way that the laughter and music softened to a dull rhythm. She slid into the seat across from me, her knee brushing mine beneath the table. She didn't pull away.

Her drink sat mostly untouched, but she twirled the glass, watching the way the light caught the bubbles as they rose. "I like this part," she said softly. "When things feel a little looser... but you're still mostly yourself."

I nodded, watching her fingers trace slow circles on the base of her glass.

"There's a sweetness to it," she added. "I get to pretend it's my drink talking--but it's really just me, with fewer brakes."

That made me smile. "You don't strike me as someone who has to hit the brakes too often."

She tilted her head, half amused, half... something else. "Oh, you'd be surprised."

She shifted in her seat, and the neckline of her blouse dipped just slightly. A glimpse of skin--small, unintentional, maybe. I caught it. Felt the tug, the heat of it. But I didn't stare. Didn't say a word.

Her gaze lifted, searching for mine.

When she found it steady--still on her, but not where she might've expected--something in her eyes flickered. Surprise, maybe. Or relief. She held it for a beat longer than she needed to.

She tilted her head, curious now. Testing something. "You're hard to read," she said. "I thought I was broadcasting my pure terror pretty clearly." I chuckled.

"No. You're..." She frowned, brow creasing as she tilted her head slightly, her eyes narrowing. "You're calm. It's kind of unnerving."

I didn't know what to say to that, so I just smiled and sipped my drink.

As we talked the space between us continued to shrink. She leaned in more with each exchange, her fingers brushing my sleeve as she made a point, then staying there a moment longer on the next. Her businesslike tone softened, her words slower, warmer. As our conversation deepened, she found herself relaxing even more, laughing at my dry humor or the unexpected warmth in my words. She hadn't expected it to feel so easy, so... real. She edged closer, brushing my arm with a gesture--more out of habit than intent. But as she shifted slightly, her hand moved instinctively toward my face, fingers hovering just inches away, before she paused, a fleeting hesitation crossing her expression. Then she caught herself and pulled back. The unexpected closeness had surprised her. She laughed it off--light, a little too quick, but the faint edge of surprise betrayed how much the gesture had startled her--how natural the impulse to touch me had felt. "Guess I'm getting too comfortable with you," she said, but the words didn't feel as casual as she intended. "Careful. I might start thinking you're being charming on purpose."

I let the silence stretch between us. She glanced at her nearly full glass and gave a faint shrug.

"It's funny--if this were any other night, I probably wouldn't still be here," she said, not quite looking at me. "So many nights end up disappointing when you wait around hoping to see if they'll turn into something."

I just watched her quietly.

πŸ›οΈ Featured Products

Premium apparel and accessories

Shop All β†’

She set the glass down, untouched. "But tonight feels... I don't know. Different. Like something's...still unfolding, if that makes sense. Like if I leave too soon, I'll miss it."

She smiled, a little embarrassed by her own words, and looked away like she was brushing them off. Then, trying to steer the mood back toward solid ground, "Listen to me," she added lightly, "Must be the gin." Her fingers toyed with the edge of the table. She laughed softly, more to herself than to me, then--with a little sigh--she rose and slid into the seat beside me. Her thigh brushed mine as she settled in beside me, smiling up as she set her drink down.

A flicker passed through her--something electric, unexpected. She didn't move away. Instead, her breath caught--just slightly--like her body had noticed before she had. Then, almost imperceptibly, she stilled--her brows drawing together, surprised by the warmth blooming low in her belly. Uninvited. Quietly insistent.

For a moment, neither of us said anything. Then she spoke again, her voice distant--like she was only half-aware she was sharing. "I had this professor once," she said, her fingers idly tracing a ring of condensation on the table. "He said something I never forgot-- 'Some people move fast because they're chasing. Others move fast because they're afraid of being caught.'"

She gave a small laugh, but it came out uneven. "Took me way too long to realize I was both."

She blinked, realizing what she'd said. A little too revealing, too soon. She turned toward me, ready to cover it with a joke, ready to pivot. But I didn't say anything. Didn't joke. Just met her gaze. Soft. Steady. "So, tell me, Sir Galahad, what's your story?" Her tone was light, teasing.

"My story? Hmm..." I gave a small laugh and looked down. I felt myself blush again. "I guess I'm just a shy guy pretending to be confident enough to survive talking with a woman..." I looked up into her eyes, then down at the table. "Who's completely disarming me."

That made her eyes sparkle. "Aww," she said softly. "You don't have to pretend. I think it's kind of sweet, how flustered I'm making you."

She reached across the small table and touched my hand. It was light, almost casual. But her fingers lingered. I couldn't move. The warmth of her skin against mine--an instant thrum in my chest that made everything else quiet. Her thumb grazed the side of my hand, and I had to remind myself to breathe. "I think it's refreshing," she added. "Most guys try too hard to impress me."

"What makes you think I'm not?" I managed, flashing her a crooked grin that I hoped looked charming. "Okay... something real." I glanced at her hand still resting over mine and swallowed. "I like to think I'm bold, sometimes even witty, but mostly I just overthink things." Then after a pause, "I play piano. It's the only time I don't feel like I'm overthinking."

She tilted her head slightly, a soft smile tugging at her lips. "Piano, huh?" she said, intrigued. "That's interesting. I wouldn't have pegged you for a pianist." She let her hand rest a little more firmly on mine, her gaze softening. "It's nice, having something that lets you breathe--even for a moment," she said quietly. "I'm still searching for mine."

I couldn't quite believe she was still here. Still leaning in. Still laughing. She was beautiful in the kind of way that usually made me disappear--but now she kept leaning closer, again and again. Choosing me. There was something real in it. Her laughter curled around my ribs. Her touch, impossible. She took another sip, eyes still on me. Then she shifted in her seat, crossing one leg over the other. Her skirt rode higher, revealing more of her thigh--and for just a moment, I saw her notice the way my eyes dropped. She tilted her head, lips parting in a smile that tried for playful--but something behind her eyes flickered. The air between us thickened, warm and close. She leaned in again, and this time our thighs touched.

"I think I might be a little tipsy," she said, her voice soft and sing-song. Her giggle came quick and light, like a reflex--practiced and perfect.

But then she paused. Her smile lingered, but her breathing shifted. She tucked a strand of hair behind her ear, and when she spoke again, her voice had shifted--lower.

"You're messing with my usual rhythm a little." She gave a small shrug, finger rubbing the rim of her glass. "Also... either this drink's stronger than I thought, or the room's doing something to me."

The conversation kept drifting--light, then deep again, then light once more. We circled something neither of us touched too directly. She found herself drawn to touch me more often, without really knowing why. Her hand returned to my forearm, fingertips tracing slow, absent-minded circles. A laugh brought her closer. A pause made her lean in. There was a pull inside her--low, warm, steady--that made each new touch feel like a quiet relief. She wanted more of it. More of whatever this was. It felt good. Electric and calming all at once.

She exhaled through her nose and gave a tiny laugh, almost embarrassed. "God, I was about to tell you some story about the time I accidentally hit on a guy at my cousin's wedding who turned out to be the groom's brother or something--total disaster. That's usually my role: distract with chaos." She smiled again, smaller this time. "But now I just... I don't know. You're making me forget my lines."

She laughed again, but softer this time, the sound curling in her throat. Her eyes drifted lower, to where her fingers still rested on my arm. She traced one slow arc with her thumb, then another, slower still. Her skin felt overly aware of this touch, her body had tuned its ear to the quiet space between us, listening for something unspoken. It was hard to tell where the conversation ended, and these sensations began. She liked the way I looked at her--steadily, openly, without expectation, but these touches were unnerving. Something in her had shifted. Her thighs pressed together, a small motion barely noticed, more reflex than anything else. That soft pull she'd been feeling was becoming thick, insistent, a hum beneath her skin. Heat had bloomed low in her belly and was spreading, slow and liquid. Beneath her skirt, the lace of her underwear clung a little more than it had a moment ago, soft and damp at the edges, though she hadn't quite noticed it yet. It was just another sensation swirling through her--unfamiliar, distracting, confusing.

The way she touched me, her hand settled on my arm--lingering. A warm pressure answered low in her hips, making her shift in her seat--her body adjusting. Her thigh against mine, the contact kept the feeling building--wet, low, steady, present, her body had been seeking this kind of closeness, and now it couldn't let go. Each touch felt like an answer. Closer. She kept reaching for me--just to be near, just to keep asking the questions.

She shifted again, crossing her legs the other way. Her knee brushed mine this time, and didn't move. Her skin flushed just slightly at the neck. I became aware of her scent--soft and clean, with a warmth beneath it, something faint and... familiar... that stirred something low in my chest. I tilted my head slightly. "I think

I'm

a little intoxicated, too," I murmured. She glanced at my drink, the ice melting untouched. This brought another wave of warmth deep in her lower belly. She felt a thrill run through her at the warmth that was pressing in deep inside her responding physically and primally to this new emotional connection. She blushed. Real, visible. That beautiful involuntary bloom across her cheeks that. I had said something dangerous and exactly right. She looked down, inhaled softly, then lifted her eyes to mine with a tension she didn't try to hide. Her voice, when she spoke again, was hushed.

"I don't usually..." She trailed off, then shook her head, almost laughing at herself. "Never mind."

But I saw the blush, not just the flicker in her breath. I saw the restraint. The way her knees stayed pressed together even though her body was leaning closer. The way her fingers kept coming back to touch me. She could feel it--low, insistent heat blooming between her legs. She shifted slightly, as if that would help, but the warmth didn't go away. If anything, it deepened. A subtle dampness. A slow, traitorous ache. Her hand was still on my arm. She realized her thumb had started tracing again--small, unconscious circles. She told herself to pull away, to laugh it off, but didn't. Couldn't.

This isn't supposed to happen just sitting next to someone.

She looked at me--really looked--and her body betrayed her again. That flutter in her stomach, the sudden tightness in her chest. I was watching her. Just... reading her. Seeing her. She swallowed. And still, her voice came--barely audible, barely steady.

"Do you... are you feeling this too?"

"I really like this. I'm glad you came over." I glanced down where our thighs were touching and blushed again.

She followed my glance, caught the blush. Another flutter rose in her belly. After a beat, she let her thigh settle more snugly against mine. A subtle promise.

"I like this too," she murmured, her voice soft, low. "It's nice to just... be here with you. Like this. And for what it's worth, I'm glad I came over too."

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like