During my freshman year at Brigham Young University I lost my virginity to a gorgeous young woman from Salt Lake City, Sandra Olsen. We established a regular practice of spending Thursday evenings having sex at an apartment that belonged to her sister-in-law, Lauren Olsen. My relationship with Sandra was erotic, but hardly what one could call romantic. She had made it clear to me that she was committed, at her Mormon family's direction, to marry a young man from another upper crust Mormon family from Salt Lake who was away serving his mission. But in the meanwhile so long as we could be discreet she was happy to spend Thursday nights fucking with me and pretty much ignoring me the rest of the time aside from a bit of help with calculus. I suppose I should have been offended by the arrangement, but the sex was too good to pass up for a 19-year-old freshman in college and I found her description of the double standards she and her family shared at best strange.
Things moved along smoothly until just before Christmas when I got a call from my older sister, Karen inviting me to spend Christmas with her and her family in Idaho Falls. That call was the beginning of my next lesson that people are not what they seem.
"I'd love to visit you over the holiday," I responded. "When did you have in mind."
"I meant the whole three weeks. I'm assuming you will be needing a place to stay since neither Mom nor Dad will be home over the holidays."
"They what? Why not?"
"Oh you haven't heard have you? I knew they wanted it kept confidential, but I assumed they had told you. They've split up. Well sort of. It's complicated."
"What? Why? How?"
"Like I said, it's complicated, but for Christmas at least, neither one of them will be at home so you better come here little brother. I guess they are still technically married but they sure don't live together anymore. I'll explain the details when you get here."
I tried calling home and no one answered. I called the feed and grain/hardware store in the little rural Idaho town I had grown up in but all I could get was that my parents were out of town. I tried my Uncle Lou, who owned a ranch near where I had grown up but no one answered the phone. Then I left to take my Calculus final.
Two days later I arrived in Idaho Falls after a long Greyhound ride from Provo. My sister greeted me and took me to her house. Her children were in the car so I couldn't ask her what was going on with our parents on the ride home or during dinner which was waiting for us when we arrived. After dinner her husband put the kids to bed and she sat me down in the kitchen to explain what had happened to my parents' marriage. It was yet another lesson in people not being what they appear to be. I had always assumed my parents were a happily married couple, at least they seemed to be that way to me.
"No Richard," she said. "They have been unhappy for years. They just hid it well." She went on to explain that at some point after she and I were born our parents had for reasons no one could explain simply lost interest in sex with each other. "That's not to say they lost interest in sex. Dad found himself a lover in Idaho Falls and Mom had an affair with our Uncle, Lou."
"Uncle Lou?"
"And his wife, Sherry," my sister added as I sat with my mouth open in shock.
"Aunt Sherry?"
"Don't be so shocked," Jane chided me. "Women do have sex with other women you know, although they don't teach that at BYU yet do they. For all I know the relationship started with Sherry and then Lou joined them."
I shook my head. "So how long as all this been going on?"
"For years. Each of our parents knew about the other's dalliance and agreed to permit it so long as everyone kept it discreet. They didn't want us to know and they couldn't let the town know. You know how a small Mormon town is. Appearances matter."
That's true even in a big Mormon town like Salt Lake, I thought. My time with Sandra had been a crash course in the importance of appearances. But I wasn't going to explain my relationship with Sandra to my sister given I wasn't sure I understood it myself. I simply said, "Yes I understand that. You can't run a small business if the Church has excommunicated you and/or your spouse for philandering."
"But it happens Rich," she said. "People are people, regardless of what their church teaches."
"True," I agreed.
"What you need to do while you are home from school is talk to both Mom and Dad. Mom is at Uncle Lou's place spending time with him and Sherry. Dad is here in Idaho Falls spending time with Christine and her two kids."
I did exactly as she suggested--a long phone call with Mom at Uncle Lou's place and a face-to-face meeting with Dad in a Denny's Restaurant where I had my first ever cup of coffee. Each of my parents more or less confirmed the story my sister had told me. They each apologized for keeping it a secret from me for so long but showed no sign of embarrassment or apology for their adulterous relationships. Neither expressed any animosity against the other.
I also learned that although they considered themselves living separately they weren't planning on a divorce. Their plan was to continue to represent themselves as married but Dad was going to spend most of his time in Idaho Falls managing a feed and grain store his new lover (wife, roommate, friend, slut; I really didn't know what to call her) had inherited from her deceased husband while Lou and Sherry were going to move in with Mom on the theory that they were tired of living out on the ranch and my family home had plenty of room with the kids gone. Lou had leased out his alfalfa land to a big Ag company from Boise and hired a manger for his cattle business so he didn't have to be there full time. He would run the feed and grain store as a resident manager for Dad. Dad's theory was that he was just traveling on business to Idaho Falls to look after the new store he had acquired (never mind who actually owned it). Meanwhile they would all maintain their apparent marriages. It sounded crazy to me but they both told me it was essential to maintaining their standing in the community and the value of the feed and grain store. Their marriage hadn't worked out and this was as good a solution as they could come up with.
I hung around at my sister's place through Christmas day but then got on a bus to head back to Provo early. It was a long dreary ride while I considered how I should feel about the hidden implosion of my family. Somewhere north of Ogden it occurred to me that my family was doing much the same as Sandra's family. Presenting themselves to the community according to one set of standards and living their private lives in accordance with a different set of standards.
And what were my standards? I chewed on that question from Ogden down past Salt Lake City and on down to Provo without reaching a clear conclusion, but I had to admit that I certainly wasn't presenting my relationship with Sandra to the world I lived in for what it was. To my friends and to hers, she was just an acquaintance that I helped with her Calculus. Nothing more. In reality she was my fuck toy or I hers. I wasn't quite clear on that either. Each of us strongly denied that we had any stronger feeling for the other than convenient sex partner. The only person who knew our real relationship was her sister-in-law Lauren.
When my bus pulled into Provo and I walked up to the campus I was distressed to learn that my dormitory had closed for the Christmas holiday and I had no place to stay. I tried calling a couple of friends who lived in Provo without luck. Then it occurred to me that I had a key to Lauren's apartment. I figured Lauren and Sandra would be in Salt Lake for the holidays and would have no objection if I spent the time until my dorm opened at their apartment. As soon as I turned the key in the lock I heard approaching footsteps. When the door opened before me I was more than a little surprised to find Lauren.
As I perhaps explained earlier, Lauren was married to Sandra's brother, Ben. They lived in Salt Lake, but she was doing post-doc research a couple of days a week at BYU, spending a couple of nights a week in the apartment in Provo. I thought that of a bit of an unusual arrangement for a Mormon family. Normally a mom's role when children still live at home is to be a full-time-stay-at-home mom, so leaving the two children in Ben's care from Tuesday morning until Thursday evening while she went to Provo to teach was not at all normal, especially for a family like Sandra's which strived to meet the Church's appearance standards.
Lauren was very different in appearance from Sandra, tall and lean, nearly six feet, compared with Sandra's five and a half feet. Her skin was olive and her hair a shinning black, but her Latino look was offset by intense blue eyes, all in all an unusual and striking combination. When I had met her in her office she was wearing the pretty much standard University faculty garb--skirt breaking below the knees, and a loosely fitting white blouse buttoned to the throat that tried but failed to hide an ample bosom. Makeup was simple. Her long hair was done in a knot atop her head. But the Lauren who answered the door had a very different appearance.
"Richard. You're home early. Can't get into your dorm?"
"Oh yeah. I'm sorry. I didn't think anyone would be here now and I need a place to stay for a few days. Looks like it's going to snow tonight."