the-straight-date-experience
FIRST TIME SEX STORIES

The Straight Date Experience

The Straight Date Experience

by freyagersemi
19 min read
4.74 (17800 views)
adultfiction

Welcome! This is the tenth story in the second "Freya and Friends" series. I try to write stand-alone stories so this can be enjoyed as-is, but if you'd like to start at the beginning of this series, check out:

I Will Love You Forever

If you'd like to begin with the first series, click here:

The First Blowjob

Enjoy!

Love, Frey

My Stories

💖 💖 💖 💖 💖

"I might be getting my surprise sooner than expected?" Katie asked with excitement in her voice. "Like today?"

Cynthia held up her index finger to quiet her and listened. They both heard footsteps running up the staircase, then the door to their apartment opening and someone running towards the bedroom.

Freya burst through the doorway gasping for breath.

"Alex came..." gasp, "Home early..." Freya leaned against the door jamb. "He's taking a shower." She stumbled to the bed and sat heavily down at the foot of it facing the two girls.

When she caught most of her breath, she told Cynthia that they had about ten minutes.

"Plenty of time," Cynthia agreed.

Katie sat up. "Plenty of time for what?"

"Let's get you cleaned up for your surprise, Katie-bear," Cynthia said.

Both Cynthia and Freya helped Katie clean the makeup smudged all over her face, combed her hair, and gave her a fast shower. They dressed her in a T-shirt and sexy panties and told her that she was ready.

"No pants?" She asked.

"Won't need 'em," Cynthia told her as she pulled on a shirt and a long peasant skirt.

"Okay," Katie said, starting to get suspicious. "I know that we aren't going out, because you would

never

go anywhere without a bra on, Cynthia."

"Nope." Cynthia smiled at her girlfriend. "Just downstairs to visit Alex." Then Cynthia innocently asked, "Katie, the 'no safe word equals consent' rule is still in effect, right?"

"Yes..." Katie answered warily. She wasn't sure where this was going. "If anyone says 'nitrogen' then everyone immediately stops..."

"And you like role playing, huh?" Cynthia sat up.

Katie's eyes shined. "I do!"

"And you like it a little rough?"

"Um-hmm..."

Suddenly, Cynthia forcefully twisted Katie's arms behind her back. "Great! You're now a kidnap victim!"

Freya lunged for her feet and was able to grab them both before Katie realized what was happening. She struggled, but not too much. She figured that they were just playing anyway.

Cynthia wrapped her strong arms around Katie's upper body and Freya carried her legs and they brought her to the top of the stairs.

"Can we carry her down the stairs?" Freya asked.

"I'll walk," Katie offered, fearing for all of their lives -- or at least for all of the bones in their arms and necks.

With Freya on the stairs in front of her and Cynthia behind her, she felt like a prisoner on death row being transported to her execution.

When they reached the bottom landing, Cynthia grabbed Katie again while Freya opened the door.

"Oh, no!" Katie yelled trying her best to sound sincere. "I've been kidnapped! What do you plan to do with little ol' me?"

Carrying her by her legs, Freya told her, "You'll see!"

They carried her into Alex and Freya's bedroom and tossed her onto the bed. Cynthia pulled Katie's T-shirt off while Freya grabbed some long scarves and tied both of her arms to the heavy, wooden bed posts.

Katie was now lying on the bed, both arms spread apart and bound, her hair washed and combed, freshly scrubbed face, naked save for her two nipple piercings and a pair of skimpy lace panties. She looked as enchanting and as sexy as she ever had.

"What are you going to do to me?" Katie wondered as her mind raced through various scenarios. She imagined the two girls doing to her what she and Freya had just done to Cynthia. She could see them both eating her out and kissing each other, reveling in the copious amounts of vaginal fluids that she usually produced. She imagined the two girls taking turns sitting on her face while the other played with her pussy. Katie's thoughts were awash with all manner of lesbian antics.

And then Alex came into the room.

'Maybe he's going to watch?' Katie thought. 'Or have another go at Cynthia while Freya and I have some more time together?' Either way, it was all good fun as far as Katie was concerned.

She smiled and wiggled her hips as Cynthia and Freya each curled a finger into the waistband of her panties and started to slowly drag them down her slender legs. Alex stood at the foot of the bed eyeing Katie's shaved crotch as it came into view.

With the panties fully off her, she crossed her ankles, gave a demure smile, and asked, "So, now what, ladies?"

The two girls each grabbed an ankle and pulled her legs apart. "Okay, Alex. She's all yours," Freya said, her voice full of excitement. She then looked down at Katie and asked her, "Ready?"

Alex looked at Katie lying on the bed like a sacrificial virgin. She was everything that he had imagined and, literally, dreamed about. Of course, with everything that had happened over the last couple of weeks, he had already seen her naked, but they were no more than stolen glances. He felt that he could look at Cyn more openly because his attraction to her was no more than any man's attraction to a pretty woman -- and, of course, they had not already had sex -- but with Katie, it was a world of difference. Looking at her in a purely sexual way seemed almost disrespectful to Freya.

But now, his wife was offering this gorgeous woman to him with seemingly no strings attached.

As he openly stared at the tiny, glistening slit between Katie's legs, her inner lips peeking out at him -- calling to him -- he felt his dick stiffen even more and thought to himself, 'I'm literally living every man's dream.'

Suddenly terrified, Katie looked from Freya to Cynthia and then to Alex. She could see the lust all over his face as he started to unbutton the jeans he had on. His eyes never left her gaping pussy. Her racing mind suddenly froze, she watched as he stepped out of his pants, pulled his underwear down, and his full erection sprang forth pointing at her like an arrow.

She looked back at Freya, her best friend, and Cynthia, her lover, both smiling down at her, and burst into tears.

Trying to pull her knees together, she blubbered, "I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Nitrogen. Nitrogen..." before violent sobs racked her body making her unable to speak.

Both girls were completely dumbfounded, but immediately let go of her ankles and sat in the bed next to her frantically untying the scarves and trying to console her.

Alex, equally confused, pulled his underwear back up over his quickly shrinking cock and reached for his pants that were lying on the floor by his feet. Having no idea what to do, he just put his pants back on and stood where he was feeling a little foolish and more than a little bit concerned for their friend.

When she could finally speak, Katie whispered, "I'm sorry. I'm sorry that I ruined your plan. I really am."

Freya had pulled a blanket over her curled up and naked body and was rubbing her back. "You didn't ruin anything, honey."

"I just... I don't want my first time to be like this." Katie burst into sobs again.

Freya motioned for Alex to leave the room. He walked out, closing the door behind him, still wondering what he had done wrong.

"Tell me what you want, Katie-bear," Cynthia tenderly asked her.

"I'm so sorry that I ruined everything," she cried. She looked up at them, her face scrunched and wet with tears. "You must be so disappointed in me."

"No, honey. No." Freya laid down next to Katie, spooning her, and put an arm around her shoulder. "That's not what this is about, sweetie. There's no shame here. We're trying to navigate totally uncharted waters and we all respect each other much too much to ever be disappointed in one another."

Freya looked at Cynthia, then continued, "We thought you would like this, but it's fine that you don't. It's okay."

Suddenly, Katie turned her head in a panic to look around the room. "Where's Alex?"

📖 Related First Time Sex Stories Magazines

Explore premium magazines in this category

View All →

"I told him to give us a little space," Freya told her.

"Oh, no!" Katie cried miserably. "Go get him! He must think this is about him! Oh! He must be mortified!"

Cynthia stood up. "Don't worry. I'll go get him."

This calmed Katie down a little.

"You don't have to do anything that you don't want to do," Freya assured Katie.

Katie turned to face Freya. "But that's just it. I actually

do

want to try it." Through her tears, Katie genuinely smiled. "And your idea sounds like a lot of fun. Me all tied up and taken advantage of against my will." Katie sniffled and wiped her nose with the back of her hand, "I just don't want that to be the first time."

"I understand," Freya said as she hugged one of her very best friends in the world.

"It looks like he took Rio out for a walk," Cynthia announced as she walked back into the bedroom. She took one look at Katie's face, made a U-turn, and said, "I will go out and I will find him."

"Thank you," Katie called out after her. "And tell him I still want to do this."

Cynthia popped her head back into the doorway. "You do?"

Katie smiled. "Yes. Just not this way. But you did make it sound so interesting."

"That's a great reason to have sex with someone," Cynthia noted. "It sounds like it may be 'interesting.'"

"You know what I mean, jerk!"

"I know what you mean, Katie," Cynthia said, blew her a tiny kiss, then went out to find Alex.

After a few minutes, Freya asked Katie, "So, what do you want?"

Katie blushed. "I know it sounds super silly, especially for tom-boy lesbian me, but I'd really like him to take me out on a date, do something fun, and give me the real 'boyfriend experience.'" Then she added, "That sounds stupid when I say it out loud. I'm sorry."

"Don't be sorry for how you feel. Especially with me, Katie. Or Cyn. Or even Alex. He's part of this, too."

"Okay..." Katie mumbled.

"And besides," Freya told her, "I think it sounds very sweet and I

know

that Alex will be totally into it. He's a true romantic underneath all that boring silence."

Katie giggled and it warmed Freya's heart to hear it. "Let's get you dressed again. You can borrow something from me."

When Cynthia came back with Alex and Rio in tow, Katie was sitting at the kitchen table with a cup of hot tea. She jumped up and gave Alex a hug. "I'm sorry."

Alex hugged her back.

"She would like you to take her out on a date first, Alex," Freya explained.

Alex held Katie at arm's length and looked at her. "A date, huh?"

Katie blushed a deep scarlet and nodded.

"It would be my pleasure," Alex told her. "I have to go in to work tomorrow to check Sully's inventory numbers -- he's a good guy and a great employee, but not exactly the brightest bulb and he sometimes misses things -- but I should be home by 3:00, if that works for you?"

"Okay. You can pick me up at 5:00 and take me out to dinner," Katie said, enormously relieved that no one seemed upset with her.

"Don't worry, she's a cheap date." Cynthia said, patting her tummy. "Good thing I put out so easily, Alex. It would have cost you an arm and a leg to feed

me

on a dinner date!"

Cynthia looked around at everyone, "Speaking of dinner... Who's hungry?" Then she added, "I'll cook."

"No! No! I'll cook!" Katie yelled.

Cyn ran to the supermarket to grab a couple of steaks while Alex started the grill and Freya and Katie made a salad.

During dinner, they talked about Alex and Katie's upcoming date.

"So, where would you like to go tomorrow, Katie?" Alex asked.

Katie shrugged. "I don't know. You decide."

"Oohh, nooo!" Freya said, shaking her head emphatically. "We can't let Alex pick. It'll be that damn burrito place."

"As the resident gourmand, I'll pick the place," Cyn announced.

"And I'll make sure that Alex is dressed up nicely for his date," Freya added.

"I can dress myself," Alex informed her.

Condescendingly, Freya patted his hand. "Of course you can, Alex, of course you can. I'll just give you a little assistance."

"Ooo! Can I help you get Katie ready for her date?" Freya asked Cyn. "We can do her makeup and her hair!"

Katie looked at them. "What am I? A dress-up doll?"

"Yes!" Both girls replied.

Katie pouted as she started gathering the empty plates and bowls. "Again, I'm sorry I spoiled everyone's plan tonight."

Freya stood up to help her clear the table. "You didn't. We're all entitled to our feelings and preferences and likes and dislikes. We only have two rules and being honest with each other is one of them. It's huge. And you were just being honest and we all respect that."

Placing the dishes in the sink, Katie sat back down at the table. "I just didn't want my first time to be like that."

Now it was Alex's turn to speak up. "That's fine, Katie. You deserve whatever you want. If anyone deserves that, it's

you

."

Katie sighed and Alex watched her face cloud over. "I want it to be sweet and simple and like I was a girl in a love story. A straight girl in a love story."

Cynthia took one of her hands.

"I spent so many years wishing that I was... Not who I was." Katie continued. "Denying who I was..."

"That's the past," Cynthia said. "It's over now."

Katie looked at her. "If anyone knows that that's a lie, it's you.

You

know that whatever happens in your childhood... It's never over."

Cynthia smiled sadly and squeezed Katie's hand.

🛍️ Featured Products

Premium apparel and accessories

Shop All →

"All of those years wishing that I could be 'normal.' I think it would be fun to give it a shot just for an evening." Katie looked at Cynthia and grinned. "I mean, Cynthia has given Alex a blow job

and

had sex with him and she's still gay, so I think I'll be safe."

"You turning straight?" Cynthia cried. "You are definitely safe from that!"

They ate some leftover cookies that Freya had, chatted for a while, then said their goodnights. When Cynthia and Katie got back upstairs, Cynthia said, "I think tomorrow's going to be fun."

"I hope so," Katie said, hugging her lover. "It will definitely be interesting."

Cynthia wrapped her arms around Katie. "And there's that word again!"

Katie just held her and after a few moments, Cynthia whispered, "Come on. Let's go to bed. You have a big day tomorrow."

"Yeah," Katie whispered back.

The next day, Alex rushed home from work to find a note on the kitchen table.

Alex,

Shave, take a shower, brush your teeth, and get dressed.

I put clothes out for you on our bed.

I'm upstairs helping Cynthia.

I'll be down to check on you before your big date.

Love, Frey

"What does she think I'm twelve?" Alex muttered as he crumpled the note up and tossed it into the trash barrel.

Rio looked up at him and barked in agreement.

"Let's go out for a quick walk before I shower, buddy," Alex told him. Rio barked more urgently.

"Okay. Okay." Alex hooked the leash onto Rio's collar and they took a walk around the block. Alex had a lot to think about and also nothing at all to think about. He was finally going to fuck Katie. It's not that often a guy gets an absolute sure thing on a first date. He just had to show up. And they already knew that they enjoyed each others' company, so the date part of the evening would be easy. Alex had a definite spring in his step as he walked Rio around the neighborhood that afternoon.

As Katie stepped out of the shower, both girls were standing by with towels.

"I can handle this," Katie told them.

"Do you want the full boyfriend experience?" Freya asked her.

"Yes..."

"Then trust me. I know what will get Alex's motor running," Freya said as she started to dry Katie's back. "Let us take care of everything."

Cynthia, carefully patting Katie's breasts with another towel, added, "I'm pretty sure his motor has been running for this little thing for quite some time."

"Oh, it has!" Freya exclaimed. "Believe me!"

Cynthia crouched down and started drying off Katie's legs. "We're gonna make you so unbelievably fuckable!"

Katie put one hand on her hip. "And I'm not, now?"

"Oh, you totally are now. But we can still up the ante," Cynthia said, then planted a quick kiss on Katie's bare pussy. "The next time we meet, darling, you won't be a virgin anymore."

"Are you talking

to my vagina

?"

"Yeah," Cynthia looked up at Katie. "We're pals."

Exasperated, Katie said, "Alex already knows me. He's seen me sick, he's seen me ugly cry -- he's already seen me naked and having sex! I really don't think we need to do all of this. I just want to go out on a date like a normal girl!"

"Normal girls are boring," Freya scoffed. "And besides, best friends would help you get ready for a first date. This

is

the straight date experience."

Katie sighed in resignation.

"Cyn, how are the legs?" Freya asked. "Do they need a quick shave?"

"They look good."

"Anything else need a quick shave?"

Cynthia slid her fingertips across Katie's smooth pussy lips. "Nope. We're good over here."

"Okay. Let's get her into some cute panties and a bra, then we'll do her hair and makeup."

"I really am just a dress-up doll to you, two," Katie mumbled.

"Tonight, you are," Freya explained. "We need to think like a guy and you know nothing about guys. Sure, you're a person -- a woman -- with thoughts and feelings and hopes and dreams and all of that great stuff, but on a first date, a guy doesn't care about that. You're just a piece of meat to him meant to be fucked."

"What?" Katie cried.

"Sorry, but you are." Freya wrapped a towel around Katie's wet hair. "And it's not just Alex who knows that he's going to screw you tonight. It's all guys. Alex is great and loving and so wonderful, but tonight he just wants to fuck you. And like any guy, he'll say and do pretty much anything at all so that at the end of the night, he's cumming inside you. And he probably won't even care where -- pussy, mouth, ass. He'd even settle for a hand job and cumming all over his own lap rather than go home with nothing."

Katie just stared at Freya, astonished and speechless.

"It's the sad truth, honey."

Katie slowly shook her head. "Men are gross."

"They can be," Freya told her as she guided her friend to the bedroom. "But men can be incredibly wonderful, too. They're just different from us. They think differently. They act differently. But men can be just as loving and caring as any woman. They're just different."

Cynthia came over with a pair of dark purple panties and bra. "Katie, I told you how amazing it was having sex with Alex.

Totally

different. And

totally

amazing. I can't even explain it. But I know that no woman could ever do what he did. There was just a different..." Cynthia trailed off searching for a word that she didn't have. "A different... Connection. A different

thing

between us. I guess it's just a boy-girl thing." She gave up trying to explain it. "You'll see," She told her. "Here, put these on."

Katie pulled the panties that Cynthia had chosen for her up her legs and Freya helped her hook the matching bra on. Cynthia stepped back, gave her a quick once-over, adjusted the panties on her slender hips, then stepped back again.

"Good grief!" Katie muttered to herself.

"Hey! I want this to be perfect for you," Cynthia explained.

Katie shook her head in resignation. "Fine."

Freya and Cynthia did her makeup, hair, and dressed her in a very cute blouse, pleated skirt, and a pair of Mary Jane shoes that Katie had had for years and rarely wore.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like