I do not mean to say that the penises in this story are the largest or smallest ever. I simply mean they are the extremes of the few that I have actually experienced. All of the people in the story are at least 18 years of age.
The first penis I ever saw was when I lost my virginity. That was on Prom night. Though it may sound like a cliche, that was when it happened. It was not a great experience. Actually there was nothing even good about it.
After our Prom, my date Kyle and his friend Tom took us to a motel across town. Mindy and I (my name is Hannah) and our dates were in separate cars, but for a moment I was afraid all four of us were going to share a room. That would never do, but thankfully we weren't asked to do that. That was about the only thing that went right. I sat in the car while Kyle and Tom went into the office to get our rooms. They had taken off the coats and ties of their tuxes and replaced them with normal jackets. This way they thought they would not stand out. I thought they looked silly, like someone trying to hide the fact that they were bringing their Prom dates to a cheap motel.
All the while I sat by myself in the car, dressed up and made up, feeling very embarrassed to be there. I tried not to look at Mindy in the next car, who looked as out of place as I felt. After what seemed like hours of waiting, it got only worse as Kyle opened the door for me and led me to the room. I nearly cried as I stepped in to the low rated motel room in my beautiful Prom gown where I was to lose my virginity to a boy I didn't like that much.
I suppose at this point the reader may wonder why I was doing this. The short answer is that it felt like it was time to give up my virginity, before high school was over. And why Kyle? Well, because he was there.
It wasn't always like that. I used to be a very popular girl. I think I peaked in my Sophomore year. I was a cheerleader, and that seemed to make me the object of desire for most of the jocks in school. It worked out well because that was who I wanted to date. I didn't seem to care too much about what they were like. Just what their status in high school was. That meant basically how good at sports they were and how good looking they were.
As for me, I was your stereotypical cheerleader. Tall, thin, athletic, cute, long legs, perky breasts, and a flirty personality. In my Sophomore year I attracted mostly Junior boys, and a few Seniors as well. I suppose I attracted a lot of Sophomores, too, but I didn't bother much with them. I liked the older guys, and they liked me. Well, I suppose they like nailing a cheerleader most of all.
But that was the problem. I wasn't ready to have sex yet. I was young, wanted to be popular, and wanted to get some experience with boys, but I didn't want to "go all the way." Most of the guys didn't seem to mind too much. Probably because my body was pretty much open to them in most other ways. Usually by the second date they were free to feel me up as much as they wanted. And I mean completely. My clothes would disappear and their hands would freely roam.
I even learned how to masturbate from a couple of those Junior boys. I didn't masturbate much before this, but their hands made me feel so good rubbing my clit, that I found I needed that same feeling more often, so I would do the same things that they did to myself. Most of the boys were just clumsy, though. Too rough on my breasts and little clue even as to how to undress me. We all have funny stories about the mysteries of unhooking bras, right?
But for some reason I drew the line when it came to the guys' bodies. Of course I could feel their erections in their pants, but I did not touch them. If they started to unzip while we were making out I put a stop to it immediately. No stroking, no blow jobs, nothing from me. I suppose some thought I was a real cock tease, but I let them feel my body so much that most of them forgave me. And I never had a steady boy friend. Two dates in a row was the most that I got. Or wanted. More than two dates was okay, but not in a row. That might send the wrong message.
Clumsy guys were especially common when I was a Junior and Senior. You see, I gave up cheerleading then - it just seemed like so much time and work - but then the best athletes seemed to have much less interest in me. So the boys asking me out were generally less experienced, and I kind of missed that. By the time I was ready to give up my cherry I was still looking for a special guy, which I never seemed to find.
That brings us back to the Prom. I went with Kyle because he asked me. He asked me early, but he was the first and I said yes. We had never even really dated. We were friends, and had gone out many times in a group of friends. The first time we kissed was the time he asked me to the Prom, and we didn't even have a real date after that. The Prom was our first, real, alone date. And I had decided that I did not want to leave high school a virgin, so when he said that Tom and Mindy were going to a motel afterwards and asked if I wanted to go also, I said yes. I knew what I was getting into.
After my fast start as a Sophomore, I felt that I was inexperienced now as a Senior. I still had never even seen a penis, except for pictures and on the internet. That made me pretty nervous as I walked through that motel room door. A little like the sacrificial virgin.
"What should we do?" asked Kyle after he shut the door to the room.
I think that sounded more naive than he meant it to. At least I hoped so. I really didn't know how experienced Kyle was. I never asked if he was a virgin, though he didn't talk as if he was. But what guy did? As i said, we had never been on a real date before. Plus I did not know of any girls claiming to have slept with him. So I was figuring he was pretty inexperienced, and he sounded like it at the moment. At least he could have kissed me!
"Why don't you get - in bed - and I will go into the bathroom and get ready," I suggested.
Once in the bathroom I looked in the mirror at my makeup and my gown, and very nearly burst into tears again. This is not how I wanted to do this, and not who I wanted to do it with. Not that it was bad - Kyle was a nice guy and had an attractive body. It just seemed like I had painted myself into a corner without choosing a guy I really wanted.
Putting all that aside, I gingerly removed my gown and tried to place it where it wouldn't get soiled. I removed most of my underwear also, leaving only my bra and panties on. I peed and dabbed at my eyes. I couldn't wash my face like I wanted because I didn't want to ruin my makeup. When I was ready I took a deep breath and opened the door.
I was hoping for some complimentary words from Kyle when he saw me, looking my sexiest, but all I heard was a sound more like a giggle from him. He was indeed in bed, naked at least from the waist up with a sheet pulled over his lower half.