He waved back to Stephanie and then drove away. He had a lot to do before the party including a shower. He had time but would have to rush to be done before the women started to arrive. Jason grabbed a fast dinner at the frat, got showered, dressed, and prepared his room with Chad for the night's activities. Kyle stopped by and pitched in too. He wanted to make sure everything was still on with Kim and Claire.
Jason wasn't sure exactly whom he wanted to see more: Claire or Caitlin. Actually he knew it was another double with Kim and Claire he really wanted, but that might not happen. He was not surprised though when Caitlin and Nina showed first just as the party was starting. Jason had managed, this time, to get out of working the party but Kyle and Chad both had to take turns serving beer and punch to the guests. The main purpose after all was to attract pledges and each brother had to do their part to add to that. Jason was just lucky to have worked the last party and therefore had time off this time.
Kyle took over the beer tap from Chad, as planned, when Caitlin and Nina arrived first. The guys had planned this out so as to maximize time with the ladies. Jason and Chad talked with Caitlin and Nina at one of the tables until the party really got going. One of the brothers was acting as a DJ and they started to dance. Nina was really into Chad after they had spent the night together. They were dancing a real bump and grind, Jason noticed.
Jason was having a good time with Caitlin when he happened to look over by the bar and saw Claire staring at him. Kim was talking with Kyle as he handed her a beer. The look that Claire gave Jason was one of disapproval of his close dancing with Caitlin. Immediately, Jason realized his plan to have them both here together was flawed. Neither one of them would want to play second fiddle to the other and keeping both happy would be a full time job. His expression must have shown the change in his mood.
"What's the matter?" Caitlin asked, but her gaze had followed his and she knew.
"Nothing," Jason said, but not with much sincerity.
"You know her?" Caitlin asked, nodding her head towards Claire and the bar.
"Yes," Jason confessed.
"Looks like she wants you over there and not with me," Caitlin claimed and she had to practically shout it over the music to the point Chad and Nina might have heard.
"I should say hello. Do you mind?" Jason asked, but immediately realized he was wrong either way.
"You want to come?" he added, thinking that might help somehow."
"Okay," was all Caitlin replied stiffly.
The dance had just ended so Caitlin followed Jason to the bar. She felt awkward trailing Jason through the crowd and didn't really want to meet her obvious competition.
"Hi, Claire," Jason said as they approached.
"Hi, Jason," Claire responded.
"Claire, this is Caitlin. Caitlin, Claire," Jason tried to say cheerfully like they should be glad to meet.
"Hi," Caitlin said and Claire nodded hi back.
"How long have you been here?" Jason asked, trying to think of something pleasant.
"Long enough ... about ten minutes," Claire answered.
This was indeed awkward and the conversation was difficult, with Jason forcing responses and peppering the women with meaningless questions to keep it going. To make matters even worse, as if that was possible, Kyle was being relieved from bar duty and hauled Kim off to dance. If Jason left to dance again with Caitlin or Claire, it would leave the other alone at the bar. And, as if that wasn't bad enough, he turned to Caitlin and she was watching Chad leave with Nina down the hall to the stairs.
'Fuck,' Jason thought. 'I'm screwed with this situation. What the hell was I thinking and now what the hell am I going to do?'
The only thing that came to him was to invite them both to his room for a stiffer drink. He could sure use one himself right then. The only problem with that plan might be Nina and Chad already being in the middle of something there.
"You guys want to go to my room for something else to drink?" Jason suggested.
Caitlin exchanged glances with Claire but agreed. Jason then turned to Claire and she nodded okay too. They walked to Jason's room through the crowd, with Claire leading and Caitlin trying to stay by his side rather than trail. As they walked he spotted a cute redhead standing talking to another brother in the hallway. He thought he remembered her name as Beth. They had struck up a conversation at the infirmary and as he recalled she was a swimmer like him, a virgin too. As he walked past, the redhead looked right at him and smiled as if she recognized him also. 'Geez, what a day,' Jason thought.
They got to his room and Claire immediately sat on the bed. It was almost like a signal to Caitlin, 'this is my domain.' Caitlin took the desk chair. Jason was relieved that apparently Chad and Nina had gone somewhere else. He asked each what they would like but they left it to him. He made them a blender of margaritas. For everyone, the first drink went down quickly, while the conversation was at best cordial. The second blender of drinks saw the women soften up and begin to talk to each other, even laughing at the awkwardness of the situation.
Jason had just made the third blender of margaritas when Chad and Nina entered the room. They looked and acted stoned. They had probably been invited to another room to smoke. Jason poured two more glasses for them. His immediate fears of Nina and Caitlin ganging up on Claire soon faded as the conversation proceeded nicely. It had become more like a little party and everyone appeared to be having a good time. He even caught Claire and Caitlin looking at each other with more than passing interest. Jason already knew that Claire was not opposed to girl on girl.
With the fourth blender of margaritas, Jason ran out of mix and also low on tequila. He had not planned for this kind of party but was pleased it was going well. Nina seemed to be getting along fine with Claire, as Caitlin was too. The two freshman girls were asking Claire her opinion on several different topics. The drinks had more than loosened everyone up and Claire seemed to show interest in Nina too.
The knock on the door was answered by Chad. Kim and Kyle came in looking a little disheveled and equally lit from the beer or other booze. They joined the party and things really became wild fun. Sexual tensions were high and the room seemed ready to bust out in an orgy. The floor and beds were basically strewn with bodies. Nina kissed Chad at one point, which soon led to Kim and Kyle making out. Even Jason found himself sandwiched between Caitlin and Claire. He alternated kisses between them. Both women had their hands in his crotch, which quickly became hard packed in his pants.
Jason's hands began working up under the shirts of each girl and had moved their bras aside to palm their breasts. Claire and Caitlin moaned as he toyed with their nipples. Their hands had freed his cock from its confines and were teasing it to rock hardness. They continued to kiss each other. At momentary pauses, Jason noticed the girls eying each other and not in a bad way.
"Whose tits you like more?" Claire asked, with a mischievous smile.
