So far in this series, all the girls have shown the initiative; the one in this chapter also will. When I realized that, I recognized that almost all "my" girls are like that. Is it my chivalrous streak, or am I the more bashful type? Certainly, I don't like the idea of a father seducing his daughter, but then he may be very willing, when she makes the first move. Do women writers here prefer to have the man take the initiative? All rhetorical questions; maybe there is a discussion of this on the forum.
The girl in chapter 3 told a quite plausible story. The eighteen year old one in this chapter tells a rather fanciful one, after her friend tells all the background. "Fanciful" is related to "fantasy" and that's what everything on Literotica is about, even the possibly autobiographically true stories, fantasies for the readers. This story dates back, of course, to before youngsters could learn all about sex from the media and internet.
This story is not for readers who quickly scroll down to see if there is hot sex on the first page. I hope that readers who enjoy a long, sympathetic description of an idealized first time will like it.
I wish mine had been that good.
Now that I have completed the story, I have to apologize for Mark's having wanted to tell in much more detail than I had anticipated. I enjoyed it and hope that readers also do, but only in chapter 5 will he be able to ask the question and hear Peggy's answer. That isn't quite true; he never really asks the question -- the title of this series. He and readers do hear from Peggy all he could want for an answer.
* * *
My name is Mark. Peggy and I had our eighteenth birthdays a week apart in February. We've known each other since grammar school, never anything special between us, except that we both weren't part of the "better" crowd: both our parents working, no dancing school, no team sports, not outstanding in school.
After Easter, kids started talking about our graduation prom. Of course, some were going steady, their date for the prom. Others were pairing up, a couple of them making up with their old friend so that they had a date. Peggy and I weren't the only ones to agree to go with each other for lack of someone better. That doesn't sound nice; we were quite pleased that we had agreed to go to the prom together. At the prom, we saw some very unexpected couples: she taller than him, pairs we had never seen together before -- desperate last minute choices.
After we had agreed to go to the prom together, I invited her to a movie, nothing special, just our first date. Her parents wanted to meet me. That was a little sticky for both of us, but mostly in anticipation. I was invited to dinner, and it was all right. So we went out again, and I began to look at her a little different, not just seeing the Peggy I had always known. Maybe she wasn't good looking, but I had known her so long that her face was just her face. I suddenly recognized that she had a nice figure, wondering why I hadn't notice before.
Eighteen: recognizing that my date for the prom had a nice figure, that was going to be in my arms when I tried to dance with her, and didn't everyone make out after dates? One girl in our class junior year had even gotten pregnant, at least, that was the rumor. If Peggy and I were going to date till June ...?
Then next time in the movie, she had her hand where I could hold it, and she didn't take it away when I did. Just holding hands with a girl in the dark made my cock stir? Eighteen. When the movie ended, I let go of her hand, but outside, walking her home -- small town, just a couple of blocks from where I lived -- she took my hand and murmured:
"Last time we held hands was crossing streets on a grammar school outing to the fire station."
I had forgotten that, but if she had remembered? I squeezed her hand and nodded, and she squeezed mine. Eighteen, my cock stirred again. At her house, she turned to me, still holding my hand, and looked at me, tilting her head up a little and to the side. The girl in the movie had done that, and they had kissed. Nerd! She had to murmur: "Everyone does." We did, just a first kiss, really my first kiss. Had she kissed a boy before? I couldn't remember seeing her with anyone she might have kissed.
After that, we always kissed, of course, and better -- French kissing! -- and embracing. I was embarrassed about my cock, but she just hugged our hips tighter together. Then the next time, I wasn't embarrassed, and she hummed, when it twitched between us.
The following week, she suggested that we sit on the isle. Before the movie ended, she whispered that we leave. We hurried out of the theater and hurried to the darkest spot on the way to her house, in the shadow of a hedge. Then it was embarrassing again; my cock was stiff between us, and she wanted me to hold her breast. I can't remember how I knew that, but she did, and I did, just through her sweater and bra. She moaned, and her hips rocked against my cock, and I came -- all up in my jockey shorts, more than when I beat-off. I must have also moaned. Did she know what had happened?
I was going to have to wash my shorts before I put them in the laundry, but I wasn't going to have beat-off, like I did after our other dates -- but I did. We walked to her place and kissed again.
The next week, when I picked her up, she murmured that we didn't have to go to the movie. It was a warm spring night. She suggested that we go somewhere else, where I knew there were no street lights. As we walked there, I already anticipated having to wash my shorts again; my cock was already stiff. I hoped that she didn't notice that I helped it move around in my shorts.
We kind of started where we had left off. When my hands on her back discovered that she wasn't wearing a bra, she nodded. Oh, the previous week, she had chuckled and murmured that it was good that she hadn't been wearing a blouse that would have been wrinkled. She wasn't again. My hands slid down and then up under her sweater -- on her bare skin!
She hummed with a nod, and her hips pressed harder against mine -- and my cock -- when she leaned back. She could only want my hands to find her naked breasts! They did, and I moaned with her; it was so arousing to be holding her firm breasts, and feel her stiff nipples between my fingers.
Of course I came again, this time letting my hips rock with hers, only afraid that it might soak through to my chinos. Her hands had been down holding our hips together. Then it was very embarrassing; she murmured: "Did you? Wish I could have."
I could just nod; she had understood what was happening down there, and she had admitted that she had also wanted to come. What was that like for girls -- for a girl, for Peggy? What were we going to do now, only minutes into the start of the movie, where our parents thought we were?
"I want to hold it," she murmured, and I felt her hand slid around my hip. Did she want to open my fly, pull down my jockey shorts, want to find out how wet they were, and touch my bare cock?! I was holding her bare breasts, but that wasn't sliding my hand down between us, like hers was doing.
Her hand only held it through my chinos and shorts. It wasn't now so stiff, but when her fingers grasped it through the cloth, it was again. She moaned, and I did, feeling her fingers trying to creep in closer around it, having to pull the front of my chinos together to grasp around it.
"I just had to hold it," she murmured. I hoped so, hoping that the wet part of my shorts was above her hand, and squeezed her breasts. She purred and murmured:
"I've been wanting you to hold them, to feel your hands on them, on my skin."
Was she suggesting that she wanted to hold my bare cock?! She squeezed and purred again, murmuring: "It's so big and stiff."
It sure was, and twitching! Peggy, talking like that, squeezing my cock, and we were only closer because we didn't have anyone else to go to the prom with?! Was that how other couples were?! Did she know more about this than I did? She had an older sister, so maybe. I was an only child.
"Where's the park bench?" she murmured: "I want to sit on your lap."
We both knew where, and I was relieved that she let go of my cock. We went to it. If she sat on my lap, she couldn't hold my cock. I sat down, wondering how she would in her skirt. Darn! She pulled it up around her hips and straddled my legs, and then told me to move my hips forward!
I did. Did I understand that she wanted to straddle my hips so that her pussy was near my still erect cock? I didn't, but then it was obvious that she did. I knew that I and classmates were always horny, but were girls too, especially my Peggy? "My" Peggy? Till the prom.
She leaned forward and started another kiss. That was fine, and my hands slid back up under the front of her sweater. Were her nipples always so stiff, just inviting my fingers to squeeze them, and making her moan. How did that feel for her? Had that made her hips twitch?
Oooh! She wanted her crotch right up against my cock, wanted her pussy right against it! Could she feel it twitch -- right against her pussy?! What did a pussy look like? It wanted to rub my cock? Did that arouse it, just rubbing there -- not in it?! Shit! Her crotch was rubbing my cock through all that cloth; I was going to come again! More yellow stains, and she had never moaned like that before!
I came. I could come that good again, so soon?! Her hips were still rocking, but then she gave a disappointed sounding moan, and they stilled. She sighed with another disappointed sounding moan and murmured:
"Your lucky; I wanted to, but couldn't."
She had recognized that my twitching cock had come again and hoped that she could, that her pussy could? She had thought that rubbing it on me that way might have given her an orgasm? She sighed and kissed me again. We had lost lip-contact. Then she murmured:
"Anyway, it was good for you, and better for me than before, but just frustrating."