In the darkness, a figure standing by the bed had tapped me on the shoulder, and a very familiar voice greeted me.
"Well, well, isn't this interesting," my wife Caroline's voice said calmly.
I jerked awake, hoping it was a dream, but no. Jayne stirred next to me, and I gave her a tap to wake her up, she just about bolted upright as Caroline's voice continued.
"Now, I don't want any pitiful explanations of this is not what it looks like, or any silly nonsense like that. Tell me what happened, and what you did, I want to hear everything that happened," her voice finished calmly.
Knowing we were so busted, I told her everything that happened, starting with coming home the night before, sliding into bed, and into Jayne, before I knew she wasn't my wife. I could feel Jayne shaking next to me. And even though the situation was dire, I could feel my cock tenting up again as I told her everything, I couldn't stop it, the remembered heat of passion and fucking just brought me right back up. A flashlight came on, and the beam was directed straight at my crotch, displaying my arousal at the remembered fucking and sucking.
In that same calm voice, she said, "Well, it certainly looks like you enjoyed it."
Not knowing what to say, I kept my mouth shut.
"What did it feel like taking an 18-year-old's tight virgin cunt? Bet it felt fucking amazing, that virgin fuckhole getting opened for the first time, the miking grip, and the first christening with a load of hot sperm. No doubt my horny hubby exploded and squirted wildly, pent up as he was from denying his needs until he got home. I'm so angry that I waited too long."
Confused, I asked, "Waited too long for what?"
"I waited too long to seduce our very sexy babysitter. You beat me to it, did you save any virgin territory for me?"
Jayne replied shyly, "Yes, I am still an ass virgin."
Caroline growled, "Then I want to claim your last cherry, right now! Is there room in the bed for one more?"
At my amazed nod, she turned the adjustable light up, until the room was filled with a dim glow, and she was ready. Her lust-filled smile looked down at us, she had her 7-inch strap-on dildo around her and ready for use, her nipples were hard, stiff nubs, and her face was flushed. I pulled back the covers, and she jumped in, Jayne and I welcomed her home, as our hands, mouths, lips, and tongues covered her body, bringing moans and cries of pleasure from her.
"Now Jayne, on your hands and knees baby, I'm going to pluck that asshole cherry of yours!" Caroline growled, as Jayne quickly took the position, Caroline cooed at me, "Okay sweetheart, lick that sweet asshole, finger her, get her all good and ready for her first ass fuck!"
Seeing Caroline as she squeezed lube onto her dildo, getting it well lubed up for Jayne's tight pucker, I was happy to do so, and the room was quickly filled with Jayne's cries of pleasure, as I licked her sweet asshole, fuck, rimming her tight virgin ass was making my iron-hard cock throb almost painfully. I ran my fingers along the tight hole, worming a finger in, feeling the tight walls of her virgin hole clenching at my finger.
"Relax baby, just relax, I'll deflower you as gently as possible," Caroline whispered to her, and I worked on trying to make Jayne relax the tight clamp. I felt her loosen up, and I whispered to Caroline, "Okay sweetheart, I think Jayne's ready."
Caroline took her position, and I could see the well-lubed head being notched against her tight hole. Caroline leaned forward, applying a slow, steady pressure and I watched, my cock throbbing, as Jayne felt her ass walls being parted, the rose-shaped pucker of her virgin asshole opening up around Caroline's dildo.
Jayne let out a whimper, and then she uttered a yelp, and said, "Hold it there, let me adjust, ohhhh, feels so big."
Caroline stopped pushing, holding steady with what looked like 2 inches inside Jayne, she reached out, stroking Jayne's back, encouraging her to relax, relax, and soon, Jayne was ready for more.
"Okay, start going, slow, go slow."