After both girls and I had rested for a short while. We were all still laying on Cynthia's bed, the two of them recovering from their oral orgasms.
"Roy, I want you to fuck me now." Cynthia informed me. "Only I want to be on top so I can control how fast we go and the depth too. Cheryl and I have both been getting birth control shots for months and since all three of us are virgins we can let you cum inside our pussies without risk of disease or pregnancy.
Cynthia climbed on top of me and rocked her pussy back and forth on my jutting erection coating it with her female liquid. Man that was a feeling I really enjoyed but when she finally reached down and inserted my organ. Her pussy walls had to stretch quite a bit sideways to engulf all my width and it took several times of her raising and lowering her lower torso before she had got it all inside. Her pussy was so tight and wet I nearly came instantly. If it hadn't been for the earlier blow job, I would have cum right then. Fortunately for both of us I was able to hold off.
Cheryl crawled over and squatted down facing Cynthia with her pussy right on my mouth. While the girls massaged and caressed each others boobs and nipples. I got to lick and suck on Cheryl's pussy, while Cynthia rode my stiffness. After Cynthia orgasmed the two girls switched places. Now I was licking Cynthia's sweet nectar from her pussy while Cheryl was riding my prick and moaning and groaning while she raised herself up and down.
It felt like several seconds but was probably about ten or eleven minutes until my prick shot off a salvo of shots into Cheryl's gripping, pumping, pleasure center.
She collapsed on top of Cynthia which caused her to fall back onto me with Cynthia's butt now where her pussy had been. Since we all had showered before leaving school, her butt was clean and smelled of soap. I licked both cheeks and caressed them, squeezing and fondling, enjoying the spongy feeling of her very firm butt cheeks.
"Um girls, while this has been a wonderful time, I need for you both to get off me now so I can breathe again." I gasped.
The girls rolled off and were giggling and smiling, telling me how much better a real man felt, than the fake dildoes they usually played with, when it was just the two of them.
When we heard a car pull into the garage we hastily put on our clothes and went into the living room, we were sitting on the couch when an attractive mid 30s lady walked in and smiled at us.
"Hi mom!" Cynthia and Cheryl both greeted the new arrival.
"Roy, this is my mom, Sarah. Mom this is our friend Roy, I think I told you about him being our schools star tennis player." Cynthia introduced us. "He brought us home since we missed the bus when Mrs. Striange kept us after school today."
"Hello Roy, thank you for bringing Cynthia home you are welcome to stay and have dinner with us if you'd like. Cheryl eats here more often than she does her own home." Sarah told me.
"That sounds great to me, I just need to call my own mom to let her know I have been kidnapped by three of the cutest girls I have ever seen and they won't let me leave until I partake of a meal with them." I joked.
Sarah laughed out loud while the two girls giggled and smiled knowingly.
"Besides being the star of the tennis team, Roy is also known for saying incredibly stupid shit to break up the teachers lectures if they get too boring. He only gets away with it at school because he is also a straight A, teachers pet, to all of them. Except Mrs. Striange who pretends he is her worst student in English. Cynthia explained to her mother.
"May I use your bathroom to call my mom?" I asked Sarah.
"Of course, it's right down the hall next to Cyndi's room. Tom and my room is through the kitchen and we have our own bathroom." Sarah explained.
I made a quick call to my mom, explaining I had been invited to dinner at a friends house. She told me to have a good time and she would see me when I got home.
While in the bathroom I took a quick piss and finding a wash cloth I used it to clean off my cum covered dick. There was a bottle of mouthwash on the sink and I used that to rinse my mouth.
Returning toward the living room I overheard Sarah say. "Roy is a very handsome guy and a quick wit, how long have you known him?"
"Just since last week when third semester started, he is Mrs. Striange's teachers assistant. I never had any classes with him as he takes all honors classes but somehow we all three have Mrs. Striange for English Lit." Cynthia told her mother.