I recommend reading part 1 first, to give context. Thank you so much for reading!
I was titillated by Erica's confession. She came across as such a "good" girl. Hearing about her boyfriend the summer before we met, and what they did really surprised me. I had worked several weeks just to feel her up over her clothes, and Tim, her boyfriend, had done that in just a couple.
Anyway, we were now well into our spring semester of our junior year. We had gotten engaged over the Christmas break. I guess a girl allowing you to rim her got me to pop the question. In all seriousness, I had planned this beforehand, obviously. Being able to rim Erica was just icing on the cake. We continued our make out sessions, involving oral sex, fingers and tongues. We had progressed to removing a lot of clothing too. It was not unusual for us to make out in just our underwear, with Erica usually being topless. However, I was worried about getting her pregnant because I had heard that even semen on the outside of the vulva could get her pregnant. So, I was content to "hover", our term for dry-humping, with our underwear on.
Soon, the final exams were done and the semester was over. Erica returned to Ohio and I went home in Florida. I did fly up to visit her over the summer and we had a great time of dry-humping, fingering and sucking.
It was now our senior year. We were going to get married after we graduated, but had not set a date. I now had an apartment all to myself...previously I had two roommates although I did have my own bedroom. This of course allowed us unequaled privacy, which we took advantage of.
One evening, we were in my small living room watching SNL, or something like that. It did not take long and soon we were making out on the living room floor. Clothes began to come off and soon we were in our underwear. Erica was on top of me, grinding her panty clad pussy against my hard cock. Then she surprised me by taking my shirt and blind folding me. I could not see her, but I could certainly feel her. She reached down and pulled my underwear off. My hard dick sprung up, pre-cum leaking from the tip. She then got back on top of me and ground her panty clad pussy against my exposed cock. It felt marvelous...simply marvelous. I was dripping pre-cum like mad. I thought "this might be it...she might put me inside her". She continued to ride me until she climaxed with a loud moan.
She lay on top of me for several moments then I felt her move down. She took my hard cock in her hand and used her other hand to smear pre-cum all over the glans and shaft. Then I felt her tongue on my tip. She took me into her mouth and moved her mouth up and down while stroking my shaft. The eroticism of the entire night was too much...her rubbing her pussy against me exposed cock, with only her thin cotton panties between us...and I erupted in her mouth. She stopped moving her mouth but continued to stroke my shaft as I released. Like a good girl, she did not let a drop escape and swallowed it all.
Later on, she was at my apartment in the afternoon and we started fooling around. I don't know what got into me (I can rarely control myself once I get really horny), but I started playing with her exposed tits. I licked and sucked them, then rolled them between my fingers, gently pinching them. Then she did something amazing...her breathing became more labored and she said "I'm coming!". This was amazing. I had not even touched her pussy. She came from me playing with her tits alone.
The capstone of our senior year happened in the spring semester. We were at my apartment and again, fooling around. I was naked, laying under her and she was again riding me with only her panties on. Her knees were pulled up around my stomach in the classic "cowgirl" fashion, but she leaned onto my chest. She then whispered in my ear "I can't stand not to have you" and she pulled her panties to the side and grabbed my dick and put it at her entrance. She then moved her hips down and took me inside her pussy.