(Author's note: This is going to be a multi-part story. This first chapter is relatively light on sex, but there will be a lot more action in subsequent installments. Everyone in this story is at least eighteen years old)
(And a quick shout-out to ErikaKane for her editing assistance with this story. Couldn't have hoped for better.)
*
I turned eighteen a month into my senior year of high school. Skinny, shy, good at math; I was last pick for the basketball team and last pick for the opposite sex. But by Christmas, I had gone from being terrified of girls to living the cliché as the official "sexually non-threatening platonic guy friend" of the five hottest chicks in school.
As nice as it was to have popular friends and beautiful women to look at all day long, I was also anguishing in a special circle of Hell, where my penis and I were at a constant state of war with each other. The argument went something like this:
MY PENIS: "Fuck her! She's hot!"
THE REST OF ME: "No, we're friends, it'd be weird..."
PENIS: "But...
tits
!"
Needless to say, it was a confusing time for me.
It all started with Corrine -- a bodacious blonde who was clearly destined for the Playboy centerfold. For a late-blooming nerd like me, she was also the most intimidating person on the planet. Every detail about her seemed specifically designed to twist my tongue into knots. First off, she was the tallest girl in school. I was 5'11" and she had maybe half an inch on me (Corrine liked to joke that this was due to her "Viking ancestry"). She also had a dazzling smile that belied an impish, teasing spirit, and a natural hourglass figure. But what really made my head spin were her tits. Her absolutely gigantic tits. The day those things had grown in, every guy in school promptly forgot his name. Seriously, her tits could stop traffic.
She and I became friends when I sheepishly asked her to be in an amateur horror movie I was directing with some buddies. Asking had not been an easy task for a guy like me—Corrine had always been a merciless tease. But nonetheless, as soon as the class bell rang, I stumbled over to her desk, feeling mortified but knowing that all the other AV club guys were counting on me to succeed for the sake of our film. I tried to play it cool, but my cheeks went crimson and my voice sounded like it was coming from inside a box:
"Hey Corrine, I'm making this horror movie and we kind of need someone to play the, like, buxom bombshell in distress. I was just wondering if you might think that was fun... or something."
She raised an eyebrow and grinned wickedly, leaning so far forward it took all my willpower to keep my eyes away from her pendulous breasts. "Sure, Ian," she said simply, "What do you want me to wear?"
It turned out my nervousness had been completely unfounded. While Corrine was definitely a tease, she was also really easy to get along with. She and I hit it off the first day of filming. We made each other laugh, hit an easy rhythm of conversation, and she even made fun of her own intoxicating hotness—happily donning the increasingly skimpy outfits I asked her to wear. She totally got the movie's trashy sense of humor, too, and would throw an extra bounce into each step as she fled from a lifeguard-turned-werewolf (Yeah, the movie was crap).
Even after we finished the film, Corrine still called me every day after school, just to chat. We had almost nothing in common besides our sense of humor, but that made our talks all the more interesting. I would keep her on the phone as long as I could, inwardly glowing at the thought of such a gorgeous creature enjoying my company.
Knowing Corrine even got me invited to some real parties for a change. I wasn't deluding myself that it was love—I certainly wasn't in "love" with her—but a part of me hoped that against all odds she had started finding the scrawny nerd kid mysteriously attractive. That was all dashed to pieces four weeks into our friendship, when I finally got up the guts to ask her out.
It was at a party Corrine had invited me to. I threw down a couple beers and headed through the dim lights, finally finding my girl in a dark corner, speaking quietly with her equally hot friend, Talia. They didn't see me in the dark, and I was just about to speak up when I overheard Talia say: "You and Ian seem to be getting pretty tight, would you ever think of going out with him?"
The timing was ridiculous, but what can I say? That's how it happened. I froze, not wanting to eavesdrop but too close to avoid it. Corrine thought for a second and then answered, "You know, I don't think so. It's nice having a guy I can talk to who doesn't treat me like I'm just a pair of boobs, but he's not really that attractive. I bet he will be one day, maybe when he's thirty or whatever. But he's a GREAT guy." Soon as she said it, Corrine realized I was standing there and she reflexively apologized. I assured her it was no big deal. We were just friends, anyway. I gave her a quick hug, inwardly groaning at the feel of her tits squashed against my chest, and headed outside to get some air.
Thirty?!
I thought,
Some consolation prize that is. I'll be fuckable by the time I'm ready to settle down.
I needed another beer. It wasn't that I was devastated to be rejected by Corrine -- hell, I'd been expecting that. It was how her words had confirmed my worst fears: I was doomed to be "just friends" for the rest of my life.
An hour later, I was reclining on the hammock in the front yard, wallowing in self-pity over my bad luck with women, when a body dropped on me and snapped me out of it, a stray elbow clocking me in the face. "Oh, I'm sorry!" Talia laughed, clearly blazed out of her mind, "I totally didn't see you there!"