1.
"So, if you don't mind me asking, what do you like to do sexually?"
For the last few minutes, Susan had been studiously moving the last few pieces of tiramisu around her plate in an attempt to avoid answering a question about her taste in movies. Carl was great, but she was well aware that she was making a complete mess of this date. She'd been struggling badly enough with the small talk and then suddenly he dropped this bomb of a question like it was nothing.
"Oh, umm, well, I mean, normal stuff, you know, I mean, just, like, women tend to..." she trailed off.
Unfortunately, this did even make the top three of least coherent sentence she'd uttered this evening. What the hell was wrong with her? Well, that was an easy question. She was three weeks away from her thirtieth birthday and still a virgin. That birthday was a firm deadline in her mind. She simply could not reach her thirties and still have life passing her by. This date should have been an easy fix; they'd planned it like a military operation. Why was it all going wrong? Ok, so most military operations in history hadn't been planned at 2am over two bottles of Chardonnay and a shared tub of Haagen Dazs with Ms Mindy from grade 1, but props to Mindy, Napoleon himself couldn't have come up with a better battle plan.
They'd written it down and broken it into stages with pros and cons and strategies, contingencies, and (because drunken primary school teachers are still primary school teachers) glitter and pipe-cleaners. After they'd finished they'd pinned it to Susan's fridge and Mindy had even rearranged the magnet letter above it to read 'The Time is Now'. Except this 'now' was rapidly becoming not the time. It was unlikely that she'd another now before life forced her to start unwrapping presents.
Carl leaned forward, and there was a pause as if he was about to say something important, but still also weighing it up in his mind. He was still the perfect deflorist. Not perfect overall, of course; good enough was what made him perfect for this one specific job. It had been a central plank of Mindy's rambling and somewhat slurred argument that they didn't want anyone she was going to fall head-over-heels in love with. No pining away. Nobody could pine quite like Susan, so that had been rule number one on their chart. They needed someone to do the deed with enough class and grace to make it a positive experience, but not wonderful enough to start melting hearts ("Talking of melting is there still any of that ice-cream. Yeah, right there you see, that what we don't want happening to your heart.")
The dating apps had spat out Carl as one of the first choices. He was also a psychologist, which Mindy, for some reason found hilarious, and which prompted her to make an immediate swipe of approval on Susan's behalf. He also, crucially, been up late that night as well, which meant the deal had been sealed with remarkable speed.
He has ten-years older than her, divorced, and just starting to play the field again. He wasn't looking for anything too serious, but also wasn't too cavalier about dating. He wasn't ten out of ten in terms of appearance, but he'd looked after himself and presented himself well. In the planning stages, after some strenuous debate, Mindy and Susan had split the difference and agreed his picture was a seven, and, to Susan's great surprise, he'd remained a seven even after she'd sobered up the next morning. With a clearer head, she found she didn't hate the plan. She even took it back of the fridge to corrected some of the spelling.
He'd been a total gentleman all the way through the date; at least until that last question, which had started to show just a touch of frustration with her.
"Here's what I'm thinking," Carl said. He paused again. This sounded ominous.
"I'm a little confused, to be honest. I got the impression from the messages we'd exchanged, that you'd be a real party girl. I thought by this point in the date, you'd have downed a couple of shandies and be dancing on the tables. I was really expecting a simple, fun time. Look, don't get me wrong, you're an attractive lady. It's not that I don't like you. It just that tonight has been a lot of work and I'm not really ready yet for relationships that need work, not so soon."
She realized he was describing Mindy (except for the shandies which she was pretty sure she didn't drink anymore). She shouldn't be surprised really. Mindy had done most of the initial messaging with Susan looking over her shoulder and desperately trying to tone down some of the more colourful sentences. They'd fought over the keyboard at several stages. Mindy had usually won and so it was her personality that had shone through during the setup phase for the date. It might have been a little too much too soon. She had some very highly advanced ideas about what was appropriate flirty behaviour for the modern woman and what was not. The phrases 'gagging for it' and 'Mr Right Now' apparently were perfectly fine for courtship though she was coyer about talking what her version of Susan might actually want to do in bed, when prompted. It was all about 'mystique' apparently.
Maybe that was the issue: she wasn't drunk enough. She'd taken a couple of sips when the wine arrived, but alcohol had never made her relax, especially around men; it had always made her incredibly self-conscious that she was going to say or do something stupid. Luckily, she'd avoided that trap tonight, as always, by hardly saying anything at all.
"Um, sorry," she ventured.
Obviously, she'd need to say more to save this sinking ship, but that was all she had for the moment. She was expending most of her energy on not bursting into tears. She was on the verge of being turned down for casual sex. That surely was the ultimately slap in the face for a woman, to offer oneself freely and still be turned down. Counterpoint, she thought, you haven't actually offered much of anything all evening, not even good company.
Mindy had written, "If all else fails, tell the waiter the ladies is blocked, then jump him in the stall," on the back of the plan. At the time they'd have a good laugh about it. She hadn't considered it might actually become her last, best hope.
"No, look, it's okay," Carl said kindly.
She was pretty sure there were no actual tears on her face. She'd become pretty good at sucking up disappointment over the years, but, obviously, a gentleman would be treading carefully on his way out of the door.
To her surprise though, he suddenly went in a different direction.