As luck would have it, Amy wanted another session sooner than my wife had anticipated. After I finished cumming deep inside Karen's womb, she got a message on her phone. It was Amy and she was wondering if this evening was too soon for a session with the two of us. Karen asked me if I was up for that and, after she described Amy, there was no way I could say no. I have a thing for redheads and Karen's description of Amy and how she made her pussy quiver piqued my curiosity. Amy was going to come over at 7:00pm, so my wife and I quickly prepared and ate supper. Neither of us had bothered to clean up other than my wife licking my cock clean of her juices, my cum and Amy's foot sweat. Karen's pussy was still a sloppy, juice dripping mess. I took a Viagra right after we ate dinner and I'm glad I did.
Amy arrived wearing the same baggy oversized pink t-shirt, black pantyhose and cute pink flats. My cock responded the same way Karen's pussy did when I saw Amy. She was tall and cute and perfectly chubby. She still smelled of sex when she introduced herself to me with a hug and kiss. My cock started to harden immediately. My wife asked Amy what she had in mind and Amy responded by just saying "I want the two of you to make love to me and use my body. I want as many orgasms as you can give me." Holy shit, this 28 year old girl was horny and certainly not shy.
My wife asked me to make love to Amy like I was making love to her and hold nothing back. I didn't have to be told twice. Karen sat on one couch, while Amy and I sat on the other. Amy immediately straddled my lap and starting making out with me. She tasted wonderful and I kissed her back deeply. Our tongues danced together in and out of each others' mouths while Karen whispered encouragement to us. I pulled Amy's oversize t-shirt up over her head to reveal her youthful but large tits. I immediately inhaled one of her nipples as she leaned back and looked at my wife. If she thought she was making my wife jealous, she was in for a surprise. Karen hopped up off the couch and removed one of Amy's size 11 flats. She sat back down on the couch and put one of her legs up on the arm of the couch. Karen hiked up her dress and revealed her blown out, gaping wet pussy to Amy. Amy's nipples were as hard as pebbles and I took turns devouring them while running my hands down her side and hips.
My wife took Amy's size 11 flat and put the toe against the opening of her huge gape. She asked Amy if she wanted to see her fuck herself with the shoe. Amy moaned "yes, please" and kept her eyes locked on Karen. My wife was verbalizing what she was doing as she slowly slid Amy's flat inside her body and Amy responded with moans and her nipples grew even larger in my mouth. As Amy kept watching her shoe disappear inside Karen's pussy, I slipped my hand inside her black pantyhose and rubbed her clit hard. Amy managed to ask Karen if she could fit the whole shoe inside herself. Karen said she wanted to try. Amy asked her to wait for the final plunge until she was ready to cum from my fingering her. My wife obliged and fucked herself using about 3/4 of the slick pink flat. I could feel Amy's pussy contracting on my fingers when she ordered my wife to push her shoe in all the way. My wife moaned hard and pushed Amy's flat in until just the end of the heel was visible at the same Amy's orgasm ripped through her body.
Once Amy's orgasm subsided, she got off me and pulled my shorts off to reveal my pulsing, vein rippled cock pointing right at her. Amy ripped a hole in the crotch of her pantyhose and straddled me again. Her pussy was so slick and ready, my cock slid right inside her to the balls. She held me deep inside her and started ramming her tongue into my mouth as we made out passionately again. Karen joined us, with Amy's flat still lodged deep inside her pussy, and reached around Amy's hips to rub her clit as it jammed against my pubic bone. I felt another orgasm hit Amy when her pussy started contracting and tried to milk my cock deep inside her. Karen didn't relent and continued rubbing Amy's clit as she coached her to ride my cock hard.