Author's note: I didn't plan on writing this sequel but the kudos and excellent ideas you wrote in the comments for part 1 were AMAZING, so I apologize for the delay--I'm excited to announce that here is PART 2! I tried to fold in everybody's contributions since I'm still learning about this kink. Please feel free to send more and maybe it will become a series--he goes to college? Haha. I think #sphfansonly will get a kick out of the romp continuing. Poor, small Jake; in his exquisite embarrassment--why does the whole world need to learn about his secret problem? Note: set in high school, but everybody is 18+!
--
It had been a few weeks since I examined Jake at Bergen Harris High but there was something about seeing him and his tiny dicklette that I couldn't shake out of my head. I'd find myself eating lunch alone on those long cafeteria tables they have in the staff room, or even away from the high school out shopping in town--since I had recommitted myself to the town and the job I was trying to decorate my place and really settle in--and all I could see popping into my head was a picture of his athletic figure, so embarrassed, hunched over in a slouch with my finger up his ass, with his tiny stiff cock hard as nails and sticking out as far as the precious little thing could go, trembling, and not even reaching the exam table.
I giggled at that memory. Other men I'd examined--real men, I mean--would bend over the edge to let me stick my finger up their ass and when I peeked around their torsos I'd be impressed by a meaty cock laying flat on that crinkly white paper we roll over the exam tables or it would be a long "show-er" cock hanging down along their upper thigh. That always turned me on. Jake's little penis could not even be called a cock; even fully erect it was just a bitty stub like a tiny thumb barely peeking out of his pubic hair and overshadowed by his enormous balls. It was such a ridiculous sight that I always laughed thinking about it.
I examined a number of the other guys at the school later that week after seeing Jake. Normal guys, I mean. Seniors at the high school. The wrestling team was a whole bunch of muscles and big cocks; Jesus, that was an afternoon. My panties were soaked after running all of those guys through the wringer. I think the earlier ones had it easier because I didn't hit my stride until later in the day when I got comfortable whipping off their boxers and wrapping my hands around their equipment.
None of them complained and I even got appreciative looks the more hands-on I went in the penis and testicular exam. They were all normal, horny high school guys with hefty, raw dicks and I was a fresh young lady doctor so it was a simple equation. I bet if I had wanted to bend some medical ethics I could have had a few of the more choice, bigger-cocked guys give me a fucking right there at the high school doctor office.
Bigger is definitely better. I need to feel the deep pressure on every thrust and be forced to bend my hips in order to take it all; God, I love that. I want a man to take control of me, fuck me hard and give me what I deserve. Jake's a nice guy and all, sure; and I wouldn't mind having coffee with him like I would with one of my girlfriends, but having sex would be an exercise in trying not to laugh the whole time. I'm not even sure if I would feel his cock if he missed my hole entirely and rubbed one out on my thigh. It'd be like when one of those little barky dogs comes up at the park and grinds on your ankle with its tiny doggy dick.
I'd try to be nice though, like, "Good, Jake! Good little boy. Did you cum? I didn't notice. You sure tried, didn't you?" And then I'd pat his head and tousle his hair and give him a peck on the cheek and send him on the way; then as he was getting into his car and I was waving goodbye, with the other hand I'd already be dialing up one of the wrestling studs to get my brains fucked out properly by a dick I could actually see and grab hold of.
The phone rang, startling me out of my thoughts. It was a Saturday night and I had just finished a killer workout, sitting in sweat-soaked clothes on my ass at the dinner table trying to figure out what to make myself to eat, or if I should order something. And then where to go for the evening. Was there a suitable bar? Fantasies of supple young high school jocks aside, I hadn't actually gotten fucked yet in this town, or for months before that. That was one of the items on my agenda, to remedy that problem. At some point.
The phone rang again and I reluctantly answered.
"Doctor?" The voice was urgent. A young woman's voice. I thought I recognized it.
"Yes, this is Dr. Netten."
"This is Mary Sue. You know, from Bergen Harris. Jake's girlfriend." Ah, that's who it was. I met her the week after I saw Jake. She came to seek counsel about their relationship, and from that I learned more about the small penis humiliation kink than I ever learned in med school. It was educational.
She was excited, speaking fast. Out of breath, even.
"Jake's on the floor. He hit his fucking head or something."
"Jake? Where are you? At your house?"
"Yes."
"Mary Sue. Listen. You need to phone 911."
There was silence. "I can't."
"What? Why not?"
"My parents are gone. They'll kill me."
Fuck, I thought.
"Mary Sue! He's breathing, right? You've checked that? If he's not breathing you gotta phone 911 right now!"
"Hang on." I heard her yelling to someone. I waited. I heard other sounds. Music and lots of voices, although they were subdued. Seemed like this accident happened at a party.
"Yeah, he's breathing. He might be unconscious, though... wait--" More muffled conversation with somebody there. "No, he's moving. He put his hand to his head."
I sighed to myself. Teenagers don't have enough perspective of the trade-offs in life. Don't wait! Just fucking phone 911. If it was a party, which given a Saturday night it had to be, alcohol or even more was probably involved.
"You can't just call an ambulance? If he's hurt... Mary Sue, I'm sure your parents--"
"Can you come here?" She interrupted.
"What?"
"Can you come to look at him?"
"Mary Sue. I'm not trained in emergency medicine. I work at a high school."
"But you would know what to do, right? To make sure he's okay?"
"Well, sure. I know the basics."
"You've got to come over then. 1240 Evanmeer. The street behind the school. It's close, right?"
"Well, yes, I know where that is. It's just 10 minutes. But--"
"Please come, Dr. Netten. You gotta make sure he's okay."
I thought for a minute, shaking my head. It was against every part of my better judgment but for some reason with her pleading and my fond memory of Jake I found myself agreeing. I didn't want to think of the liability. That was sort of a black hole of worry for any medical professional and it's best not to even start your brain getting into all the ways it could go wrong and fuck you over. I saw the headlines: Not even one month into job do-gooder doctor causes death in town... Oh my God.