Part 3 Recap:
Before leaving for Nick's beach house, Heather seems to be putting a great deal of effort into her appearance. I suspect it's because she is secretly attracted to Nick. After we arrive, Nick begins flirting with Heather relentlessly, right in front of me, and there's nothing I can do to stop it. Nick manages to get her alone with him in the hot tub, where they almost kiss. Heather returns to me feeling conflicted because of her desire for Nick.
We spent the next couple of minutes observing the view, not saying much to each other, as the sun dropped toward the horizon. Then, I felt a jolt of fright as Nick returned. He was still in nothing but his swim trunks, intimidatingly bare from the waist up, his ripped upper body on full display. I once again caught Heather eyeballing him up and down the very first opportunity she had to do so undetected by him, and once again, I saw her bite her lip. It was like she couldn't help it, and it was like she was oblivious to how obvious it would be to me, or else she just couldn't resist the temptation.
Nick took his place right next to Heather, who was standing across from me several feet away against the railing. I was very uncomfortable with how close they were to each other, especially considering the fact that Heather was just standing there in nothing but her damp cover-up which was clinging tightly to the enticing curves of her precious body. I felt compelled to move closer to Heather, but I didn't think Nick would like that, so I just stayed where I was.
Nick was smiling mischievously. "Brad just told me something
very
interesting," he said, with obvious amusement.
"What's that?" Heather asked excitedly, hanging on his every word as always, and I was saddened once again to see her playing with her hair.
"It seems he's developed quite a crush ..." Nick began, pausing dramatically, "... on your husband."
My eyes bulged in horror. I saw Heather look at me with an expression of playful suspiciousness, as if suggesting something had happened between us while they were in the hot tub. "
Really
," she said accusingly, with her eyebrows lifted and a wide smile on her face.
Nick nodded, grinning. "I had a feeling these two were going to hit it off."
And then it was like Heather simply couldn't resist the urge to pile on and join him in his teasing at my expense. "I
thought
they were getting along," she added playfully.
I was mortified. My face must have turned bright red as I could feel the blood flooding my cheeks. It was like I was being implicated in something - as if I was seeking that attention out from Brad. I was terribly embarrassed, which I knew must have been Nick's intention. Heather had always been the kind of woman who was attracted to classic masculinity, and nothing would be more contrary to that than the notion of her husband getting along like that with another guy.
"You better stay close to your husband this weekend," Nick then said to Heather, feigning concern.
"Why is that?" she asked.
"Well, let's just say that Brad has a preference for heterosexual men," Nick explained. "There's nothing he loves more than sexually dominating straight guys." A wave of revulsion swept through me. "I'm just saying, it might not be safe to leave these two alone together, unless you don't mind sharing your husband with him."
"He can have him," Heather said jokingly, flashing me a smile, as if this was all just innocent teasing.
Joking or not, I was incredibly stung by Heather's comment, and I was horrified by this entire conversation. Here they were, talking about this huge muscular guy who could easily overpower me without breaking a sweat, and apparently he had a crush on me. And they were implying that he might try and force himself on me if given the opportunity, and it was like this was no big deal to them - as if it was some kind of game. I was dreading Brad's return from the kitchen. I was also painfully aware of how destructive this kind of talk could be for Heather's attraction toward me. But as bad as this had been, it was about to get much, much worse.
"Tell me something," Nick said, turning toward me. "Have you ever fooled around with a guy before?"
My eyes bulged once again, even more mortified than I had been a moment ago. It took me a moment to register the question. How could he be asking me that? "No!" I said defensively.
"Have you ever wanted to?" Nick asked. And then: "Be honest."
I couldn't believe he was questioning me like this with Heather right there. I knew his intention must have been to embarrass me even more in front of her, and I had no choice but to respond as best as I could.
"No," I said decisively. "That's disgusting."
"Too bad," Nick replied. "If that wasn't the case, we could consider altering the sleeping arrangements - you could bunk with Brad, and I could bunk with Heather."
I was utterly stunned - too stunned for words - and then positively seething. Here was this man, making such a blatant remark about sleeping with my wife, with her standing right there next to him, and there was nothing I could do to stop this. And as for Heather, she should have been
outraged
by this comment. But all I heard from her was a nervous laugh which instantly escaped her, as if this was just a harmless joke.
What I
didn't
know was that the nervousness in her laughter had been to mask the fact that the thought of this happening didn't bother her at all (at least the bunking-with-Nick part), and she was afraid of letting that on. She had also assumed I would take offense to his comment, innocent though it was, and she was pleasantly surprised when I seemed to take it in stride.
It was surreal, finding myself in this situation, with such a thing being said right in front of my wife, all as if it wasn't a big deal, and I was helpless to put a stop to it. Unfortunately for me, Nick wasn't done.
"You say you've never fooled around with a guy before, but how do you know you wouldn't like it, if you've never tried it?" Nick asked me. The tone of his voice was as if this was just a normal line of questioning, just an innocent conversation, and I could do nothing but glare at him as he went on. "See, I believe sexuality is a spectrum, and that everyone falls somewhere on this spectrum. Very few people fall all the way to one side or the other, like I do."
"Me, too," Heather felt the need to add. At that point, I should have clarified that