My Girlfriend And Her Ex Pt 03

Thank you all so much for the good feedback and criticisms. Please leave more in the comments below!

Text conversations are marked with the characters' first initial in parentheses.

**********************************************************************************************************

I looked out the window, Hailey got in Justin's car. It sped off, my beautiful girlfriend in the passenger seat. My cock was semi-hard thinking about her getting dressed up just to have dinner with him.

I walked into the bathroom; it was a mess. It would take me most of the evening to fully clean. I gathered all the dirty laundry off the floor, most of which were Hailey's. I picked up her red Calvin Klein thong she wore on her coffee outing. I took a big whiff, the arousal wired through me instantly, my cock started throbbing. After a few moments of enjoying my girlfriend's scent, I removed the underwear from my nose. It had a substantial amount of dried pussy juices encrusting it. She must have been so wet when she was with Justin. I shook the thought out of my head. I felt a little sick. I threw them in the laundry basket and proceeded with my task.

I got to cleaning. First the sink, then the toilet, and finally the shower. I scrubbed hard and used most of the cleaning supplies we had. I finished off with hand-scrubbing the floor. I looked at the time, 8:16pm. The bathroom was spotless, Hailey will be pleased.

I stripped off my clothes and took a shower. I got changed into some sweatpants and a sleeping tee. I laid on the couch and ate the rest of the leftover pizza from Monday. I then watched some Netflix to pass the time. 8:50pm, I got a text from Hailey.

(H) Hey babe, could you get some comfy sleepwear set out for me. Also, please make a cup of chamomile tea. I'll be home in 15 loves :)

(N) of course cutie!

I grabbed a pair of her grey sweats and one of her oversized sleeping shirts. I got her pair of black bikini brief panties; she didn't like sleeping in a thong. I hurried over to the kitchen and put the pot on to boil and set out her favorite mug. A few minutes later the water came to a boil. I made up the cup of tea and set it on the counter. I stood by the entry way in anticipation for her to get home. A few minutes later Hailey opened the door and walked in.

"Hey beautiful!" I said enthusiastically.

"Hi." Hailey said with a smile.

"Could you put these away for me?"

She held out her purse and a takeout box.

I quickly took them from her. She walked over to the couch and sat down, her heels clicking along the way. I put the leftovers in the fridge and her purse on the coat hook.

"I'd like my tea, sweety."

"Sure thing baby."

I took the mug in hand and sat beside her on the couch, giving it to her.

"So.... how was it?" I asked, hesitantly.

Hailey took a long sip from her tea. She looked over to me, I've never seen her in such a good mood before.

"I had a really fun time. Thank you so much for being understanding baby."

"Could you go into details? What'd you have to eat?'

"Not right now baby, give me a moment, I'm tired from walking on my heels all evening."

Hailey looked at me expectantly. I didn't know if she wanted me to say something, I just looked at her with a dumb expression.

"Well?"

"Well, what?" I replied. I honestly had no clue what she wanted. I felt dumb but all I could produce was a puzzled look.

"Are you going to at least take my heels off for me?" Hailey cocked an eyebrow.

"Oh, uh...right." I hastily pulled her legs up to my lap and removed her shoes.

"And..."

I took that cue. I started rubbing her worn feet while she watched TV. We sat in silence for about ten minutes, she occasionally sipped on her tea while I attended to her feet. She finally took her feet off my lap and got up.

"I'm going to get changed and ready for bed." She said cheerfully. She handed me her empty mug.

"Could you take this honey?"

"Yea, sure."

I grabbed the mug and went to the kitchen. Hailey grabbed the clothes I set out for her and went into the bathroom. There were a few dishes in the sink, so I washed them. I turned the light off and got into bed. Hailey soon after followed and snuggled under the covers with me. She turned the lamp off and laid beside me, her ass pressing into my junk while she used her phone. I cuddled with her, smelling her hair, and wrapping my arm around her chest. I was dying to know how dinner went.

"So...what'd you eat?"

Hailey put her phone down and wiggled her ass a little more into me.

"Chicken Parm."

"Was it good?"

"Yea, I think you would really like the place."

Wasting no time with what I really wanted to hear.

"How's Justin?"

"He's good. He said I looked very pretty."

Great, now he's calling my girlfriend pretty.

"Babe, do you think I looked pretty?" Hailey said before I could respond.

"Yes, you always do!"

"Good. He really liked my top; he said my boobs looked really good." She giggled.

"Your boobs are perfect baby, of course he would say that." I added a sarcastic undertone on the latter part.

Hailey just moaned a little in approval.

"So...are you friends with him now?"

A few moments went by before she replied.

"Yes. I really like hanging out with him. Justin has shown a side I never seen in him. He paid for coffee and dinner, he was really kind, and complimented me. He never did those things when we dated."

Uhg...Why'd she have to say that. All I could manage was to say,

"Well, that's good."

I could feel her cock a smile.

"I also had a bit of an outfit malfunction..."

"Uh...Like what?"

"My skirt was a bit short and when I got out of his car...part of it was caught in my pantyhose so he got a full view of my ass." Hailey said with a trailing laugh.

"Wow. No wonder he paid for dinner!" I tried to make a joke of it.

I thought about it my head. Seeing her get out of his car as Justin held the door open for her. Seeing her plump tight ass cheeks practically absorbing her thong. I started getting hard.

She laughed.

"Yea, the only way I noticed was when he slapped it before I walked in the restaurant."

"Slapped what?"

"My butt, silly. What else?"

Fuck. I felt my cock getting harder. Hailey must have noticed because she wiggled her ass deeper into my crotch.

I had nothing to say.

"Nick...I have to tell you something."

Uh oh. Here it comes. She fucked him. She's been cheating on me this entire time. She's breaking up with me. I felt my body go numb with anticipation.

"When I went to coffee with Justin..."

My heart stopped.

"He kissed me."

Whew. But I also felt my face go hot. My cock was fully hard now. I was mad, but not angry. I sighed and didn't say anything. Hailey continued.

"When he dropped me off...I was about to get out of his car, then he grabbed my arm. I looked at him and he leaned over and bam. Just like that, he kissed me."

"Are you mad babe?" Hailey asked with the sweetest voice I ever heard.

My dick betrayed me. I couldn't help but feel incredibly heart broken, but my sexual desire held precedent.

"No."

"Really?" She raised the pitch of her voice.

"Yes. I'm not mad."

Hailey wiggled her ass against me again.

"Why are you hard, Nicky?"

Fuck. I had to try and reclaim my masculinity. I released her from my hold and turned her over. I was on top now, looking straight into her eyes. I kissed her, deeply. I didn't know what else to do. She met my kiss back and grabbed the back of my head. We made out for a few minutes. I felt her grab my dick from the outside of my sweatpants. She started stroking it. I was diamond hard at this point. My cock twitched, I felt mindlessly horny. Hailey broke from my kiss and stared into my eyes. She started rubbing me faster.

"Do you like hearing about Justin kissing me and slapping my ass?" She asked with a mischievous smile.

Fuck. I could barely respond.

"Y-es..."

I came in my pants immediately. I had never came so hard before. Hailey stopped rubbing. She knew.

"Babe...did you...cream yourself?"

I got off top of her and out of bed. I blushed and felt embarrassed.

"Yea."

Hailey smiled and began giggling. She had a grin on her face. I took off my pants and boxers. Before I changed into new ones, she spoke up.

"Turn around babe. Let me see your dick."

I did, hesitantly. My dick was at half mast, about two inches.

"Aww...Its so cute!"

I feigned a smile and finished changing. I got back into bed and Hailey took me into her hold, her face a few inches from mine.

"You have the perfect boyfriend dick baby."

"Uh...Thank you...I guess."

"I love you, Nick."

"I love you too, Hailey."

"You're the best boyfriend I could ever have. You make me feel so good about myself. I've never felt this way before."

My heart melted. I leaned in and kissed her. She kissed back. She broke off.

"I know that when I'm happy, you're happy. I wanted to confess something to you baby."

"Yes, anything. Please Hailey if I ever hurt your feelings or did something wrong...please tell me."

"Its not that...I just haven't been able to orgasm with you. I don't feel good when we have sex. I mean...I always feel safe with you...but when we have sex, I just don't enjoy it."

Shit. I had to hold my ground here. Its time to man up.

"You could teach me to be better!" I raised my voice a little.

"Baby...We had this talk."

"What if I ate you out better?"

"Baby-"

"Or we could use toys!"

"Nick!" Hailey raised her voice over mine, sounding stern. I fell silent.

"I want to ask you something. If you object than I won't do it, but I will feel shitty. So please, listen to me."

We looked into each other's eyes. She looked serious.

"I love you. No matter what. I feel safe with you. I feel like the prettiest girl in the world when I'm with you. You support me in all my endeavors, and I never have to worry about you cheating on me. I just haven't felt like our sex is good. It doesn't make me feel good."

I was silent, listening attentively. She continued.

"So...I was thinking. Justin really has changed, and I feel comfortable around him again. I want to have sex with him. Just sex. Nothing more. Just one time. I don't feel any love for him, it's all for you."

Hailey looked at me dead in the eyes, I've never seen her this serious.

"When I was with him this evening, I never felt that aroused before. It made me feel so good. Nick, almost all boyfriends would never agree with this. I hope you're not like those other guys. If you're not okay with this then I won't, but just know, I am not happy with our sex life."

My cock instantly got hard again. I felt nauseous, my face hot, my eyes watered, yet a sexual provocation coursed through my body. My girlfriend just asked if I would be okay with her having sex with another man. I arrived at a crossroads. My mind raced. I loved Hailey. She was hot, funny, and a great companion. I rationalized my two choices. Choice A) No she cannot, and we'd go along as couple, but how long would that last? Probably not long. There are way more dating opportunities for her than me. Choice B) Yes, she would remain my girlfriend and I'd still get sex, but she would fuck her ex-boyfriend, albeit only one time. I contemplated this for a few minutes. We laid together in silence.

I arrived at a conclusion.

"I mean...If it is just a one-time thing...and it'll make you happy...Then okay."

Hailey's face went from solemn to joyful. She cuddled up to me and kissed my face all over.

"Thank you, thank you, thank you!" She said with glee.

I endured her assault of kisses. I couldn't help but smile and kiss her back. After a few minutes of this we reserved ourselves. I had to ask the obvious.

"So...When was this going to happen?"

"I was thinking Friday night. During dinner he invited me over to watch a movie."

Two days from now. She's fast.

"Yea sure."

"Great! Thank you for being so understanding Nick, really. You're the best boyfriend ever!"

And with that she kissed me. She took her pants off, just in her panties and shirt and turned over, facing away from me. My cock was still hard. She backed her butt into me, I peeked under the covers to see her black panties highlighting her perfect ass. I wrapped my arm around her. All I could think about was Friday night. She fell asleep in my arms, shortly after, so did I.

The next day I awoke. Hailey was gone, she had early morning classes on Thursday. I reflected on last night. What had I just agreed to? My masculinity felt like a fraction of what it was. I shook it off, time to get through classes and homework today. It lingered in the back of my mind throughout the day.

My last class finally ended at 4pm. I walked back to our apartment. Hailey was already there, eating some yogurt and doing homework at our modest kitchen table. She didn't put much effort into dressing up today, just wearing some black sweatpants and our university's signature hoodie.

"Hey cutie!" I said enthusiastically.

"Hi babe."

I threw my backpack on the couch and laid on the bed. I browsed social media to relax a bit after a hectic day of classes. Hailey got up and laid down beside me.

"So, I was thinking...I would really like it if you could help me get ready for tomorrow night."

That caught me a bit off guard. What did she mean?

"What do you mean baby?"

"Well...You know. Help me get ready. Like pick out what I'm going to wear and help me with my makeup and stuff."

"I mean...If you'd like me to, I'm more than happy to help."

"Good. And by the way, I want to wear something special. Something new. So, I was thinking you could go to the store and buy me some lingerie for tomorrow night..."

I felt my penis getting hard. Control. Control. I liked the idea though.

"Yea of course babe!"

"Sweet! The student bus leaves for the mall in half an hour."

Shit, I'd better leg it over to the stop if I'm going to make it on time. Hailey sat there like a goddess.

"No worries my love."

I grabbed my wallet and rushed out the door. I arrived at the bus stop just in time. It was a 20-minute trip to the mall.

The bus finally arrived. It was evening now; the mall was packed. I navigated my way through the crowds of people. Victoria Secret was really the only store that would have what I was looking for. I walked in, the only guy there. Uhg, how embarrassing.

I walked through the aisles, wondering what I should buy. I can't believe this. I'm literally deciding what lingerie I should buy for my girlfriend just for her to fuck another dude. I got hard, again, thinking about it. I arrived at the intimate section. My eyes were drawn to a mannequin modeling a pair. A dark blue plain G-string, garter, and bra. My cock got instantly hard. I looked at the price. $65. Fuck, that's pricey. I was lost in thought when I felt a tap on my shoulder.

"Hey, you need help finding anything?" A sweet voice broke my train of thought.

I looked over. She looked familiar.

"Oh! Aren't you Hailey's boyfriend?" She asked.

"Oh...Uh, ya."

"I'm Jen, one of Hailey's friends." She piped up.

I remember now. Jen was a close friend of Hailey. A bit shorter than her, natural blonde. She had smaller tits than Hailey, but her ass was much more well-formed. She was in her year. Hailey didn't hang out with her too often but any time she went clubbing it was with Jen. I also knew they talked a lot. Hailey would often be on facetime with her, and Jen would be talking about the latest guy she fucked or Hailey would be talking about me.

"Oh ya..." I smiled. I reached my hand out to shake hers.

"I'm Nick." We never formally met, but I heard a lot of stories from Hailey about how slutty Jen was when she was drunk, which is to say most girls in college are like that.

"Nice to finally meet Hailey's boyfriend! I'm really happy she finally met a guy who treats her like the goddess she is." She shook my hand back with a big smile.

I'm glad Hailey tells her friends about me, especially all the good things I do for her, after all, I'm the best boyfriend she has ever had.

"I'm guessing you're here to get something for Hailey?"

"Yea, I think I'd like this."

"Good choice, I'm sure Hailey would look really good in this. The mannequin is a size large, but I'll get a small from the back. Meet me at the register." Jen said smiling. She hurried away to the back, her ass bouncing around in her leggings. I could faintly make out a thong line. Fuck she's hot. I walked over to the register and waited for her to return.

She came back with a small box in hand and scanned the barcode.

"Okay, that'll be $68.90."

I got my debit card out and paid. Jen looked at me.

"So, is this for you or Justin." She asked innocently.

What the fuck. How did she know. I looked at her blankly. All I got in return was her smiling face. I felt myself blush.

"Its...for Justin."

Jen giggled.

"I kind of figured. You know...you're a pretty good boyfriend to let Hailey see him."

"Uh...Thanks."

She giggled again and placed the box in a bag.

"I hope they like it!" Jen said cheerfully.

I felt my cock pressing against my jeans. Great, now her friend knows about this. I quickly grabbed the bag without a word and sped out of the mall. I held the Victoria Secret bag close to me as I rode the bus home. It was dark outside. I checked my phone, 8:41pm.

When I finally got home it was 9pm. I walked in the apartment. The TV was on playing yet another boring Netflix movie.

"Hey babe, I'm home!" I hollered.

"In here baby." Hailey's sweet voice radiated though the room.

I set the shopping bag on her dresser. I looked into the bathroom. Hailey was on her phone wearing her white Calvin Klein bra and bikini brief set. Her hair was still wet, looks like she just showered.

"Mmmhh...I like what I'm seeing."

Hailey, not looking up from her phone and laughing.

"Stop it."

I stripped down nude to take a shower. I got behind her, my crotch pressing in between her ass cheeks. She held her phone out so I could see. She was on snapchat typing some text over the image. It was a picture of her ass. I gulped.

"Are you going to send that to Justin?"

She turned her phone off and spun around smiling.

"Maybe. But its none of your business."

With that she skipped out of the bathroom, leaving me standing there naked. I showered and edged myself, maybe I'd get lucky, and we could have sex tonight.

I threw on boxers and slipped into bed; Hailey was sitting up, texting on her phone. I cuddled next to her, feeling her smooth skin against mine gave me goosebumps.

"Whatcha ya doing babe?"

"Just texting Justin."

"About..."

Hailey just giggled.

"About tomorrow night."

I pressed my body closer to hers, not saying anything. She eventually put her phone down and cuddled next to me.

"I'm so excited for tomorrow baby." She whispered into my ear.

"I am too."

In reality I was incredibly nervous, horny, and sick to my stomach. I couldn't let Hailey know that though.

She planted a kiss on my lips and wrapped herself around me. I tried to get something sexual started, but she just shrugged it off. Dammit. She fell asleep in my arms, as did I.