This chapter is a continuation of a story about two girls with whom I got reacquainted several years after high school. While this could stand alone, it is best read after reading "Debbie and Sara" Chapter 1
"Debbie?" Sara called out, then did a double take when she saw me, "What are you doing here, where is Debbie?"
"In the shower, getting ready for class." I replied, feeling a little odd and not having a firm grasp on my story, everything happened so quickly that I didn't have time to invent an alibi.
"How have you been Rob?" Sara asked as she bounced into the living room to join me. Suddenly she froze, staring at something on the floor. I followed her gaze and realized that we had been busted! Debbie's red, come soaked panties were on the floor! They must have dropped when we went to take our shower, and neither of us noticed. Sara reached down, picked them up, held them at arm's length and exclaimed, "Eww, these are all gooey, what were you two doing? These are Debbie's new panties that she bought yesterday when we were at the mall!"
She dropped them to the floor and yelled down the hallway, "Debbie, what were you doing, corrupting the morals of our nice neighbor? I leave you alone for a few hours and what happens? You're fucking Rob on the couch!"
Just then, the phone started ringing and Sara ran to the kitchen to answer it. (Remember those days of wall mounted phones?) It was her mother saying that they were going to stay at her aunt's house for the night. I heard Sara say that she had just returned home from work and that Debbie was getting ready for her class that night. No mention of me, so she wasn't going to rat me and Debbie out!
I heard the shower still running and wasn't sure what to do, Debbie and I had scurried to the bathroom, Debbie accidentally dropping her soggy panties, Sara had walked in, found them, and let Debbie know this. We were busted but the phone had interrupted the conversation.
Sara waltzed back into the living room, her beautiful red dress floating about her long legs, and plopped down next to me. I remember wondering about all this red clothing. Red must have been the "it" color for the season. Saras dress looked brand new, and I began wondering if she was also wearing red underwear. Then I wondered if she was also wearing a red slip under her red dress.........
Sara jolted me back to reality, "So, Debbie wins," she exclaimed, paused, and then sheepishly admitted, "we had a bet on who would sleep with you first, but until now, you hadn't cooperated.
"You two had a bet?" I asked "about who would be first to sleep with me? For all these years, I always thought that you two were too good for me. I was afraid to make a move from fear of rejection. I had just stopped in to visit, Deb was all alone shaving her legs, and well, you can imagine the rest!"
"Scaredy cat", Sara teased, "Too good for you? I told Debbie that one of us should make a move after we heard that you had moved back from Maine, and now it looks like Debbie beat me to the punch!"
Sara laughingly yelled towards the bathroom, "Debbie, you little slut! Was he as good as you fantasized that he would be?"
Debbie had stepped out of the bathroom wrapped in a towel and was headed upstairs. Over her shoulder, she hollered to Sara, "That is for me to know, and for you to find out! Be careful, he really loves panties!"
"Really?" Sara asked, "Do we have someone who appreciates our lingerie as much as we do? Does someone have a panty fetish? Most guys just want to rip them off and get down to business. Is it just panties, or is it all lingerie?"
"Guilty on all counts," I admitted, all the while sitting there, kind of dumbfounded. What the fuck was happening here? Was this real? Was I dreaming? I had just stumbled into the most incredible fuck of my life with a gorgeous girl who I had fantasized about for years. Not only that, but she had also indulged my most private sexual fetish and now she had just told her equally hot sister about it. To add icing to that cake, Sara did not seem at all put off by this and I wondered why Debbie had warned her that I loved panties. Then I considered Saras comment about the bet over who would sleep with me first. This whole thing was surreal, I wasn't the most popular guy in town, and I had always been afraid of rejection by girls like Debbie and Sara. In addition, I had been very self-conscious about my panty fetish, usually removing my girlfriends' panties when, in reality, I had wanted them to continue wearing them during sex. As I had grown into my 20s, I had learned to be less self-conscious about this, and that afternoon with Debbie, I had cast all caution aside and let my desires unfold, resulting in mind blowing sex. Suddenly, my fetish didn't seem to be an issue, not just with Debbie, but with Sara as well.
"Yeah," I confided, "I find lingerie incredibly fascinating, not to mention a turn-on. You women spend lots of time and money buying all these beautiful silky garments and they are always covered up. No one gets to see them but yourselves, then in a fit of passion, they are yanked off and tossed aside like Christmas wrapping paper. For myself, I love for you to keep it on for a while, I love the way it looks, and I love the way that it feels on you."
"Well," Sara began, "I love lingerie too, its more than underwear, its special and I feel special when I wear it. I wish that more men would appreciate it as it sounds like you do." Then she whispered, "I've got more lingerie than Debbie does!"
As if on cue, Debbie skipped down the stairs, now wearing a pair of jeans and a skintight, white, French cut, t-shirt. Her long blonde hair was pulled back in a simple ponytail, no fuss, no muss, but I could also see the outline of her delicate white bra straps through the tight cotton of her t-shirt. Her firm, round breasts swelled out the front. This caused a stir in my loins; I also loved the subtle glimpse of hidden underwear.