The morning after the Halloween party, we woke up as usual. I felt a little different under the covers until I remembered what had happened after we made love the night before. We had showered and then I picked out two pair of sexy panties. One for Jeff and one for me. I looked over at him as he started waking up. Jeff had been at home from work for a while and we had no plans for the day. When he roused enough, I slipped over to him and cuddled. I had him turn on his side and I played the big spoon to his little spoon. It just sort of worked out that way. I was not making a statement, but afterwards I did grasp the significance.
The girls had initiated the costumes for the party, but the guys had gone along. After the party, I had led Jeff into our first 'lesbian' sexual encounter. I purposely did not let him penetrate my pussy with his cock instead bringing him off with my hand. Now I began rubbing his pantied cock until he was hard again.
I did not want to lose the theme from the party. Sonia had intrigued me with her stories of how Keith had taken to the start of their feminization fetish. I had the hots very badly for duplicating this with my own husband. The first step had been a success. I wanted to get with Sonia about what their after party had been like, but I was not ready to share any details about Jeff and me just yet. I would let her bring the subject up and not quiz her too closely. Otherwise, I would feel obligated to report our bedroom activities also.
I had thought this through. Since Jeff had gone along with the costume for the party, I was feeling a certain anticipation for the expansion of my plan. After the party and after making love, putting him into panties for bedtime was the sure sign that he was not averse to the idea. I did not necessarily expect him to embrace it to begin with. At that point my only goal was to re-enforce the new pleasure and hopefully get him comfortable with the idea.
When it was time to arise and have our coffee, I made sure to be the first one to speak.
"God, Honey, last night was fantastic. I don't know what came over me. I guess the anticipation and planning for the party got me going. When all you guys agreed, we thought it was so sweet of you to go along with our kinky idea. Seeing what a big hit you all were made us so pleased that Beth had thought of it. Although I must admit that Bart was not very believable. I thought you were the prettiest. Keith looked good, but you are shorter and the stilettos looked more natural on you. Did you enjoy it?"
He seemed to be looking for some kind of sign. After all, waking up in your wife's panties is not exactly what you would brag about to your buddies. I was hanging on his response...
"Yeah, it turned out okay. I expected some of the other guys to really get personal about it, but everyone seemed to enjoy the joke."
"It was sweet," I cooed. "I had not idea it would turn me on so much to see how good you all looked made up. I never made it with a girl before. Much less a gorgeous one."
I jabbed him and ran my fingers over his cock now tenting the front of the pink panties. Jeff was not big by any means, but his cock did get hard. Also, he was a heavy cummer. When I blasted him with my girl cum, I was hoping that it did not turn him off. I hugged him again and suggested that we get some coffee and go back to bed. He started going toward the bathroom. I had to act quickly.
"Oh, and Honey, would you leave the panties on? I want to re-live our wild sex night while we have our coffee. Go to the bathroom and I will get our coffee."
As I poured the coffee, I was excited to see if he would come out with my panties on. He did indeed leave the panties on per my request. I put our coffee on the night stands and again told him how sexy he looked wearing my panties. It must have been the 'manly morning after masculinity syndrome' because he said, "Sandra, the costume party is over". He said it but without firm conviction. I was determined to explore the fetish mainly because Sonia had been so enthusiastic about Keith being totally into it now.
"Oh, but Honey, I had such a good time last night. I mean the party was fun, but our lovemaking afterward was off the charts. And you look so sexy all cleaned up and smooth. I bet the guys who propositioned you last night in jest were a little turned on by the, uh, dark intrigue of anonymous prostitutes being so near to them."
Jeff was in a casual mood, but still showed some reluctance to engage in the conversation. I wanted to explore this a little further, but not press it enough to make him uncomfortable. If this was not something that appealed to him, we would drop the subject and I would have memories of the party and the wonderful sex we had afterward.
He did answer. "It was so different and you girls seemed to get a kick out of it. Bart looked sort of out of place. I mean he shaved his mustache and still looked like a bulky guy."
We laughed and began to compare the outfits and makeup of the other guys. I asked him about the razzing he got from the other men who were dressed more traditionally. Jeff thought that some of the guys' costumes looked ridiculous. He said that a couple of them were much less believable than the hookers except for Bart. I reminded him that even though it was a stretch for Bart to look feminine, he still was willing to go along with the theme because Beth really wanted to join in the fun with the rest of us.
"Yeah, Sandra, but that does not explain the 'after party' we had. Don't you think that was a little over the top?"
"Over the top? Is great sex over the top?"
"You know what I mean. Dressing for the party was one thing, but dressing for bed makes me feel uncomfortable."
"How so?"
"I don't want people to think of me in that way."
"What people, Jeff."
"If anyone knew about this, I would be humiliated."
I could see his concern.
"Jeff, the party was a costume party. You said yourself that some of the other guys looked terrible in their costumes. You guys were gorgeous. Bart did not ruin anyone else's costume. He complied with his wife's wishes. He gets an A+ for that just like the rest of you."
"Oh, I didn't mean it that way," he objected.