Just in case an explanation is required, the house competition was the system of points awarded and deducted throughout the week by the teachers. The winning house was announced at Monday assembly, and they were awarded the school pennant in a formal ceremony. I can't for the life of me remember why this was important to us at the time, but strangely it was. Naturally, as house captains, we knew the weekly results prior to the weekend.
Anyway, back to the supper situation, and the circumstance of Betty providing our supper two weeks in a row provoked our own response. In keeping with the competitive nature of their arrangement, we decided that the losing captain of the boys' house competition would assist in making and serving the tea. This may not seem like much, but to put it in context, we were expecting one of our number to act like the butler - or a woman! Either way, we considered it a demeaning role.
Many weeks passed with one of the girls turning up each week with home-baked goodies, and one of the boys putting on a brave face and serving up the tea. We were getting to know each other very well, and like any group of high achievers, there was a fair amount of teasing and rivalry as we shared in the successes and failures of each individual and the houses they led. In addition to the supper duties, we also started to impose other penalties for various failures. At the start this took the nature of silly forfeits such as singing a song. However, over the course of the year, the stakes were gradually raised.
The nature of our get-togethers changed the week Bertie's house was punished because three of its third-formers had been caught cheating in a test. Naturally the rest of us teasingly maintained that the corruption went right to the top, and we demanded that Bertie be held personally accountable. There was much debate over his punishment until Vicky surprised us all by suggesting that Bertie should serve the supper shirtless "like a savage". There was a moment's stunned silence before the other girls started giggling and adding their approval of the punishment. While I had no particular interest in seeing Bertie topless, I was nonetheless excited by the situation, as this was the first hint we had that the girls weren't entirely pure and incorruptible. The girls won the point, and Bertie was blushing furiously as he removed his shirt and served the tea. The girls didn't stop giggling until after we parted to return to school.
There was an undercurrent of tension the following Sunday evening, but nothing untoward happened. I was the losing house captain, but there was no suggestion that I should lose my shirt. However, the following week I was the loser again following a dismal showing by my house, and it was Bea who looked to the others with a wicked smile and suggested I should serve them topless. While the idea was naturally embarrassing, I was again excited by the situation and I probably didn't put up nearly enough of a fight before giving in and taking off my shirt.
As I was serving the tea, I did wonder out loud why the losing girl (Vicky) wasn't being punished like I was. This was neatly deflected by the girls, who laughed and accused me of being a bad sport. However, the other boys seized on the opportunity and didn't let the subject die. It transpired that during the coming week St Hilda's was having its athletic sports day, which was one of the high points of the competition between the houses. We began arguing that extra importance should be attached to the results of this, with the losing girl facing a punishment consistent with the punishment I was serving.
The ensuing debate was fierce but good-natured and the outcome was a victory of sorts. Since the girls' uniform consisted of a dress with a buttoned bodice to the waist, there was much discussion about a fair punishment. In the end it was agreed that the losing girl would undo these buttons while still otherwise wearing the dress, while the losing boy would "continue to go shirtless as normal". This shifting of the goal posts didn't escape our attention, with the topless boy now being the norm rather than the exception, but we didn't dare quibble about the agreement. Catching a glimpse of a bra was far better than we had dreamed of.
The results of the St Hilda's sports day had not reached us by the time we went home for the weekend. As we walked to church on Sunday evening there was much whispered speculation as to who might have been the losing house captain, and whether or not they might follow through on the arrangement to serve supper with their uniform unbuttoned to the waist. As it happened, we learned the identity of the loser partway through the service. During the notices the vicar congratulated the winning house, with mentions for second and third. The fourth place-getter was obviously the house not mentioned - the house captained by Alexa. Out of the four girls, Alexa was the quietest and most reserved. As we four boys looked across at the senior girls' pew, Alexa stared straight ahead with an embarrassed look on her face. We remained nervous about whether or not our hopes would be crushed.
As we arrived at our meeting place, the girls huddled together in the corner conducting a lengthy whispered conference. Alexa was obviously requiring some encouragement, but the other girls had taken on themselves the responsibility for the honour of their sex to provide the encouragement. They finally stopped whispering and turned to face us, with Vicky, Betty and Bea providing a wall behind which Alexa was sheltering. They glared at us and reminded us that there was more than one losing house captain in the room. Of course, in our excitement we had forgotten. We turned on Peter, the loser among the boys, and demanded his shirt be removed pronto. Poor Peter was the shyest of the boys, the least equipped to remove his shirt in a room with four girls, but he was as conscious as the rest of us that nothing should get in the way of viewing Alexa's bra. His hands were shaking so much that undoing his buttons proved to be a considerable challenge.
Peter was soon topless, and to his credit he then went about preparing the cups and saucers for our supper, doing his part to create an atmosphere of normality. For Bertie, Harry & I there was no such attempt. We simply sat in our chairs and stared at Alexa as she too appeared to be fumbling with buttons as she stayed hidden behind the others. Then, as if by some prearranged signal, the three girls moved away and sat down, leaving Alexa revealed to our gaze.
At the risk of over-elaborating the context in which we found ourselves, if your knowledge of 1950s morality is derived solely from the degree of "scandal" you observed when it was thought Rizzo might be pregnant in the movie Grease, then you don't really have an idea of our situation attending private schools in provincial New Zealand. If word got out about any of our activities so far, it would have resulted in immediate expulsion for all concerned. The loss of reputation would have limited future career and relationship options, particularly for the girls. The only thing that we had going for us in this situation was that gentlemanly behaviour was still extremely important. To bring dishonour to the girls by failing to keep this secret would bring the worst possible damage to our reputations. The girls knew they were entitled to a level of trust that is unthinkable today.
Having attempted to raise the narrative tension with the last paragraph, I now have to admit that the notion of Alexa being "revealed to our gaze" was a distinct anti-climax. While the front of her dress was unbuttoned to the waist, its style meant that it barely gaped at all. The opening revealed only an inch or two of her white cotton bra. I am sure that beforehand we had all intended to avoid staring openly, but it was difficult to avert our eyes as we hoped for glimpses of more. Throughout the evening I was rewarded with only two brief glimpses of the full roundness of a bra cup.
As I walked back to school with the other boys, we each compared our experiences of what we had seen. These glimpses of a bra were the high point in all our sexual experiences of women. I had had an erection all evening. My theological knowledge of the sin of Onanism had provided some degree of restraint up to this time, but that evening I could not help but indulge, and this generally signaled the time in my life when I conceded that I was not cut out for such a high degree of piety.