I steeled myself and knocked on the door. For the past hour and a half I had been debating whether or not I should go over to his place, but what broke me is that every time I peeked out my windows he was seemingly just lounging on the couch watching TV, but after maybe my hundredth glance our eyes caught each other. My heart skipped and we quickly looked away, but now I knew he was waiting for me, hopeful for our night to continue. I took a quick shower and threw on a simple black dress that hugged my waist and showed ample cleavage. After psyching myself up for the millionth time I grabbed my purse and left the apartment, wondering if my neighbor across the way had watched me leave and imagining him getting hard at the thought of me at his door.
When he opened the door to apartment 12B I was delighted to notice he was even more attractive up close. His deep dark brown eyes and five o'clock shadow were all I needed to already feel the warmth gathering between my thighs. I was horribly nervous, but luckily he spoke first.
"I guess you saw my note?" He said with a coy smile as he relaxed in the doorframe, standing in nothing but a pair of sweatpants.
"I saw a lot more than that." I said and he laughed, and I could finally breathe again.
"Please come in." He gestured through the doorway and I stepped inside his apartment. It was a clean and simple studio, which was the best you could hope for from a New York bachelor. "Feel free to sit down." He said as he pointed to the couch and walked over to the kitchenette. I instead went right over to the windows and looked across the way. It was true that even with all the lights off in my apartment you could still make out the furniture inside the place. I had been exposing myself to all of 57th and 3rd without even realizing it.
I was pulled out of my thoughts when he asked "Anything to drink? I got whiskey and beer, and maybe a bottle of red that I can't promise is any good."
"I'll take a whiskey" was my reply while also realizing that I still didn't know his name. "I'm Sara by the way".
"Andrew. Pleasure to meet ya" He walked over and handed me a well-poured whiskey. I sipped as we looked out the window and he said "Ya know, I think I have one of the best views in all of New York."
I almost choked on my sip of whiskey. God I was so nervous! Keep it together.
"Oh, really?" Was my genius reply.
He responded by moving the hair off of my neck. I was frozen in place, but my heart was beating a mile a minute. He leaned in and began placing light kisses all along the side of my collarbone and I arched my neck to him, a small moan escaping my lips. We moved in clumsy unison over to the couch and plopped down unceremoniously. I broke away to set my whiskey on the coffee table and turned back to him, taking his face in my hands and pulling him in for a kiss. Our tongues danced together as we responded to each other's movements with a series of approving groans. I was deliciously aware of the giant windows framing the entire scene and secretly hoped some nosy neighbors were stealing glances this way.
"This is not how I thought my Tuesday night was gonna go." I said breathlessly.
"Do you wanna stop?"
"Hell no." And I pushed him onto his back, climbing on top of him and straddling his waist. Whatever nerves I had were replaced by my growing desire. I lifted off my dress and threw it on the ground revealing that I had chosen not to wear a bra. Andrew's hands immediately went to my breasts. Holding one in each palm and giving them a squeeze. I moaned as his thumbs moved over my nipples bringing them to full attention. I threw my head back, thrusting my chest forward and gasped when I felt his mouth close around my right nipple as he sat up for better access. My hand went to the back of his head, my fingers entwining in his hair as I enjoyed the sensations of his tongue on my body. I reached down in between us and found his hard cock with my free hand and pulled it out of his sweatpants. Andrew groaned as my hand began to stroke, my thumb swirling the tip and spreading his precum.
A squeal escaped me as Andrew picked me up and took me the few steps over to the bed.