Editor's note: this story contains scenes of incest or incest content.
*****
Christmas Eve finds twin sisters Stacey and Suzie huddled around a roaring open fire with their partners, Josh and Anna. Outside soft snow continues to fall, the worse of the storm has past, the wind has died down. Looking through the windows with the way the porch lights highlights the drifts of snow, it looks like a perfect Christmas scene.
Six months has past since that heady night at the beach, neither Stacey or Suzie have spoken openly to each other about what happened. They had agreed the very next morning that it was a game that crossed a boundary too far and they wouldn't mention it again. But secretly both girls had played the night over and over in their heads often wondered how the other felt about it all.
There had been moments Suzie had been sure Anna knew the truth and so many times she had wanted to confess but how do you even begin to do that. Every time Anna had mentioned the night Suzie had tried to change the subject, she was too worried Anna would see right through her and worse, she couldn't stop thinking about Josh.
Late at night she would replay the events of that night, the feel of Josh's body on hers, the firmness and strength compared to Anna. She did try to stop comparing them, but her mind would just wander back to the way it felt to kiss him and the way he touched her. Making out with him had been every opposite to being with Anna, let alone actually fucking and not just because of the obvious reasons.
Every time she replayed the way he talked, the feel that he had full control, she became more and more turned on. She would remember the feel of his cock in her hand, the hardness, yet softness too and so warm to the touch. The way her hand had slid up and down his shaft and his moans in her ear as he became harder and harder. His own exploration of Suzie's body had been clumsy and hurried, he hadn't teased her first, just shoved his fingers deep in her cunt and started to roughly finger fuck her, but she had loved it, the complete difference. By the time he finally pushed his cock in her pussy she was so turned on and wet that there was nothing more she wanted than to be fucked hard. Josh had surprised her, his fingering had seemed unsure, but the way he had fucked her was confident, she couldn't help but buck her hips and she had came so hard.
Meanwhile Stacey was having a similar problem, only for her it was the panic in her that she had felt no jealous watching Josh with someone else. She knew she loved him, was still very attracted to him in all ways but was he really the one and then there was Anna, sweet, soft and like Suzie with Josh, she couldn't stop thinking of her.
"Grabbing a beer, anyone want one?"
All three girls replied at the same time that they did and so Josh headed off to the kitchen to get the drinks.
"You know, he's alright for a guy really," says Anna.
"Anna!" exclaimed Stacey.
"What?"
"You sound such a lesbian when you talk like that."
"Well duh Stace!"
Suzie lightly punches her girlfriend's arm, "behave you!"
Exaggerating the strength of Suzie's punch and faking pain Anna topples over and rolls around on the rug. Both Suzie and Stacey burst out laughing.
"Wimp!"
"OMG! That's domestic abuse..."
"In your dreams girlie," laughs Suzie.
"A girl can dream, right!"
Stacey fakes a shocked look and raises her hand to her mouth, "OMG! Please no details, keep your kinky love life to yourselves."
"Kinky love life?" Giggles Suzie.
"She means sex, our kinky sex life baby!"
"I know what she means, I'm wondering where she gets an idea like that about us?"
All three girls look at each other, Stacey blushes bright red and Suzie and Anna both burst into hysterical laughter. They don't mention it but all are referring to time Stacey walked in them in the shower, not that there was anything even slightly kinky about it. But both girls now looked at Anna and thought to themselves, if only Anna knew the half of it, where that innocent act had escalated to and the events that had unfolded partly because of it.
"What did I miss now, what's so funny?" Josh asks as he walks back into the room to see all three girls rolling around laughing.
"Nothing!" All three reply at the same time, taking the beers handed to them.
"You know its not easy being the only guy around here sometimes."
"Aww... Is poor Joshie feeling left out?" Giggles Anna.
Pouting his lips Josh sighs deeply, "ye...ssss!" He sniffs and stutters his words to emphasize he is upset.
Anna crawls over to him on her hands and knees, reaches up taking his hand in hers and pulls him to the floor. Wrapping her arms around him, she gives him a big bear hug.
"There, there Joshie, it's OK," she says sarcastically as she ruffles his hair. "You'll always be one of the girls to us!"
"Jeez Anna, thanks."
"Anytime sweetie," she replies and plants a kiss on the top of his head.
"OMG! You two get a room already," giggles Stacey.
"Hmm..."
"Josh!" Both Stacey and Suzie cried at the same time.
"What! We'd let you watch, wouldn't we Anna?"
Anna laughs and hugs Josh tighter, looking across at Suzie she winks, "Sure I'm game."
Suzie in return shakes her head and moves across to Stacey, laying down and resting her head on her lap. Stacey runs her fingers through her sisters hair and smiles down at her.
The next couple of hours are filled by more drinking, lots of chatter and laughter. At one point the girls send Josh outside to get more wood for the fire, so he can prove he's a big strong man. He in return scooped up snow, making snowballs and bombarded the girls as they giggled from the porch, making them scream and run back inside. Now once again they were all settled in front of the fire.
The beer was swapped for spirits, shots and basically any weird mixture of drink they can come up with between themselves.
"What time are your parents due back?" Asks Josh.
"Duhhhh..." Replies Stacey, "They aren't, they are staying over at our Aunt and Uncles, we are joining them tomorrow, remember!"
"Oh, it that the famous Aunt Maud?" Asks Anna.
"Famous Aunt Maud?"
"Yeah, has Stace never told you, how these two used to make her life hell by pretending to be each other?"
"Seriously, you two used to do that?"
Stacey and Suzie look at each other and raise their eyebrows in a knowing way.