A few days after being paired up with his sister-in-law, Katie, on an anonymous mutual masturbation session, Neal decides he needed to try something else to get his mind off the stress of not knowing how Katie was reacting -- and whether she would come clean about it to her sister, Neal's wife, Hayden.
Their towns local public pool sat down by the harbor and had a basketball court there where you could also join up in a pickup game. Neal hadn't played much since his high school days but enjoyed shooting around whenever he could. He decided to try his luck on joining in a game and then hopping over to unwind at the local public pool afterwards.
As he finished up and felt the sweat cooling on his skin, the idea of relaxing in the pool felt like the perfect way to clear his mind. Walking up the small hill, he left the couple of guys who were up to no good, still shootin' some b-balls, and he approached the pool entrance.
The pool attendant -- a woman that looked to be in her early twenties, probably on summer break from college, wearing tight white shorts that showed off her stunning legs and a polo shirt that was unbuttoned just enough to showcase her ample cleavage.
As Neal approached, she gave him a bright smile and stopped him. "Sorry, the men's locker room is already full for the day, but you can use the dual-gender locker room. Don't worry, there are private changing rooms inside," she said with a wink.
Neal nodded, thanking her, though his eyes lingered a bit longer than they probably should have on her shapely figure. Shaking the thoughts from his mind, he stepped into the locker room.
Immediately, he was greeted by the sound of crying toddlers and a flustered mother struggling to pack up their things. He sidestepped them, making his way further in, where his eyes landed on two teenage girls whispering and giggling to each other. Both were 18-year-old seniors in high school, as he recognized them from the town's paper for some recent awards they'd won for good deeds in the community.
The blonde was tall and lean, her neon-pink bikini barely covering her full, perky breasts. Her hips swayed as she stood, her long, tanned legs showing off her fit, toned physique. Next to her was a shorter petite redhead in an emerald, green bikini that left little to the imagination. The strings of her top barely held her perky breasts in place, while the bottoms hugged her tight, round ass.
Their eyes briefly met his, the blonde biting her lip while the redhead whispered something that made them both giggle again; Neal thought he heard the word "hot" though.
Neal could feel his body react almost instantly. His cock twitched in his shorts, rapidly hardening as he stole another glance at the two girls. Their youthful, toned bodies made him forget about the nearly 10 year age difference and forced an adjustment to his stance; his growing bulge in his shorts was impossible to hide, and Neal quickly looked for an escape.
Spying a private changing room with the door slightly ajar, he hurried toward it, desperate for cover. As he pushed the door open, he shot the teens one last smile, trying to play it cool. But as he stepped inside, his tented shorts hit something soft yet firm--something warm.
Startled, he whipped his head forward and froze.
"Oh my god! I'm so sorry!" he blurted out, eyes wide. His cock had just poked into someone. He hadn't even noticed there was a girl bent over in front of him. "The door was ajar, and I-- I wasn't paying attention, I thought it was empty..."
The girl tried to straighten up quickly, but she stumbled backward onto the bench from being knocked off-balance. Her pale breasts spilled out of her top, which wasn't tied up yet and she had no bottoms on, leaving her pussy exposed. Flustered as she landed, she tried to cover herself, her hands brushing her dark hair away from her face.
"Jesus, get out! What the fuck?" she snapped, clearly shocked.
Neal's heart skipped a beat as he recognized her voice and her face as it became clear.
It was Katie. His sister-in-law.
Time seemed to slow down as Neal took in the sight before him. Seeing his sister-in-law get herself off on webcam was one thing, standing in front of her completely exposed was a whole different level.
Katie's pale skin stood out, contrasted again her very dark brown hair, as his eyes were drawn to her tattooed arms flailing about. The deep colors of the skull and flowers on her shoulders and forearms sandwiching a vibrant stag deer just above her elbow were memorizing.
Trying to regain herself Katie quickly crossed her arms in an instinctive attempt to cover herself up, but her tattooed arms only acted to highlight the curve of her ample perky breasts; her floral tattoos that ran from her collarbone to just above her chest helped to further frame the amazing milky white tits she rarely would show off in her outfits. Her nipples, already hard from being exposed to the cool locker room air, peeked through the space her arms couldn't quite protect. Neal's gaze continued downward, unable to stop himself. Katie's thick thighs framed her completely shaved pussy, which was now mere feet away.
Katie, still reeling from being walked in on by a stranger, glances up. Her eyes work upwards and see gym shorts, which are full tented by a large, hard shaft.
"Katie, oh god! I... I'm so sorry," Neal stammers, his face flushing red, knowing how obvious his erection is.
Katie, who's gaze shoots up to see Neal's face after hearing his voice is further shocked and embarrassment. The sight of her brothers-in-law's very hard cock, clearly outlined against his gym shorts, right in front of her as she lay basically naked sends confusing messages through her. Her mind races back to their encounter online, and she feels a strange mix of anger, embarrassment, but also an undeniable attraction.
"Neal, what the fuck are you doing here?!" Katie finally manages to say, still trying to cover herself but unable to fully hide her naked body.
"I didn't know you were in here," Neal explains, still trying to process the situation. "I thought the room was empty."
Katie takes a deep breath, her chest rising and falling with the effort to calm herself. "Well, clearly it's not! Jesus, get out!"
Yeah, of course," Neal says, "I'm so sorry Katie," backing up towards the door. He turns away but can't shake the image seeing some of Katie's body completely bare, now in person and his dick is now fully sticking out in his loose gym shorts.
Frantically, he scanned the line of change rooms, desperate to get out of sight where he could regain control of himself. His cock was throbbing, begging for release, once again because of his sister-in-law's sexy tattooed body.
As he hurried past, the two 18-year-old seniors by their lockers caught sight of his obvious predicament. They exchanged glances, their eyes darting to Neal's tented shorts, biting their lips in excitement and giggling to themselves as they watched him intently.
Finally, Neal found an unoccupied room a few doors down from where the teens were and rushed inside and flung the door shut behind him. So overcome with arousal he rushed to slide out of his gym shorts and boxers, falling to the floor. The cool locker room air now hit his exposed skin, sending shivers through him as his cock stands fully erect, pulsing and aching for release.
"Fuck Katie, you're incredible," he mumbles to himself as he trembles with overflowing arousal trying to picture her body, gripping his shaft tightly at the base and beginning to pump his hand up and down.
The two seniors still worked up over seeing Neal run by with his obvious boner hear a creak. Looking towards Neal's change room the door has cracked open, clearly not fully shut or locked, and they can see a small amount, but enough, of what is going on inside.
"Oh my god! He's...look," the blonde whispered as she nudged her friend. Seeing for herself the redhead whispered back "Holy crap...I've never seen a guy do that...," as they both crept closer to the change room. "This is so hot," the redhead continued as she tugged her bikini top aside, her hand moving across her freckled skin to her small hard nipples as her other hand ran down her tight young abdomen as her fingers slid just underneath her bottoms.
As they inched closer the door creaked open another inch, giving the high schoolers an even better view of Neal veiny thick cock as he continues stroking himself rapidly. "God, I hope he cums," the blonde whispers, her hands fully inside of bikini bottoms, as she fingers slide in and out of her bare, smooth pussy lips.
Neal, now panting intensely, leans his free hand against the side wall bracing himself as his hips begin to buck and thrust with his strokes, trying to will his cock to explode. "Fuck,' he mutters, his voice thick with frustration.
Throwing his head around, needing to cum, his eyes open and his heart stops -- he sees he's made the same mistake Katie did in not full closing or locking the change room door.
He is now tightly gripping the base of his grossly engorged throbbing cock while locking eyes through a couple inch crack with two 18-year-old high school seniors. He scans their bodies, the redheads freckled perky, almost pointy, tits with the cutest small nipples starring back at him as they both were clearly fingering themselves underneath their bikini bottoms. Heart pounding, Neal doesn't move to shut the door, but with a free hand opens the door further to allow them all better looks at each other; his hand begins to slowly stroke his shaft again, as he peers down at it for a moment before looking back up into the teen's eyes.
The seniors didn't shy away. If anything, their arousal seemed to grow, their movements becoming more frenzied. Their eyes widened in anticipation, their breaths shallow as they watched him expose himself more to them, his hard cock glistening in his hand. Neal's strokes picked up again, a little faster this time, his eyes never leaving their bodies.
The blonde bit her lip, her eyes locked on Neal's shaft as her hand moved faster beneath her shorts. The redhead's hand worked over her nipple, her cheeks flushed, and her tiny hands moving rapidly inside her emerald, green bottoms; both the girls wetness and slapping of their fingers moving in and out of their tight pussies made its way to Neal's ears.
Fueled by the sight of them pleasuring themselves, Neal's strokes became faster again, as he tugged down on his balls, he could feel it coming -- his frustration over not being able to fuck his sister-in-law now spilling over onto these two barely legal high schoolers. The teens quiet moans were all that he could handle.
Neal let out a low groan, his hand tightening around his cock Neal came hard, thick spurts of cum shot out through the crack in the door a good few feet -- landing just a few feet short of the teens. The girls gasped softly, their own hands moving faster as they watched him finish, completely captivated by the sight of him, as they both rode themselves into intense orgasms of their own.
As they all began to come down from their peaks, none of them spoke; Neal just mouthed to them "So. Fucking. Hot.," as he reached out and shut his change room door with the girls moving to cover up and grab their bags.
