She Sure Showed Us!

Welcome to another one of my stories! My ex-girlfriend said I should share some of these crazy stories with the world. At the time, I never bothered but now with the pandemic I have a lot more time on my hands, so...enjoy! I have changed the names to protect everyones privacy, but the rest of the story is 90% true and 10% filling in the blanks of minor details that I don't remember.

I had almost completely forgotten all about this one, and then I read a similar story on here and remembered this fun weekend from long ago. This one comes to us from way back in the day, about 2010 or so. That was one of the last years before everyone had a smart phone and I'm pretty sure that this story never would have happened otherwise!

So, that Summer was a fun one. I was just a couple of years out of college and like a lot of people that age, I rented a house in the suburbs with two friends. We found a great house that had three bedrooms and a fenced in back yard that had a big BBQ grill AND a hot tub! And even better, it was located in a neighborhood that had a number of households just like ours and as luck would have it there was a house with three young ladies about our age on the block right behind ours. Of course we ended up hanging out a ton.

There were times that all six of us hung out, but mostly it was a group of four. One of my roommates had a pretty serious girlfriend and the two of them never really hung out with the rest of us much. And, one of the girls never seemed to be around. But, that still left four of us who hung out a ton and had some fun adventures. My roommate was Brian and the two girls next door were Sara and Kirstin. We did hook up a bunch of times that Summer (me with Sara, Brian with Kirstin) but at first we just kinda all hung out together. One of our goals for that Summer was to get the girls to join us for a skinny dip in our hot tub. This story originates on one of those nights, but first a little about us. Brian and I were pretty average looking dudes. Sara was blonde, average height (probably 5'5'' or so) and a nice figure with a great pair of C cups. Kirstin was a little shorter (probably 5'2'' or so) , dark hair and slightly larger boobs but overall Sara had a slightly better figure. Both of them were totally hot, with gorgeous smiles and sexy personalities.

This story is about the first time we saw Sara and Kirstin naked, and the first time I hooked up with Sara. We had a BBQ that day in our yard with a bunch of friends, and by early evening most of our guests had departed and it was just Brian, Sara, Kirstin and myself hanging out. It was perfect weather and we decided to get in the hot tub for a few drinks.

I thought I had talked Sara into a skinny dip that night but Kirstin wasn't having it. We took our drinks into the hot tub (with suits on) and ended up in a game of "Never have I ever...", which of course ended up being 100% racy/sexy questions and Kirstin got some good-natured teasing for being the prude who insisted we wear suits. Predictably, Sara ended up doing some of the best teasing and Kirstin ended up trying to convince us she wasn't a prude at all. I thought maybe if we were lucky we would end up with Kirstin flashing us her boobs. Boy was I in for a surprise! Just like the title of the story...eventually Kirstin sure showed us that she wasn't a prude! Literally, and figuratively. But, we'll get to that part later.

I wanted to raise the stakes of our "Never have I ever..." game a little and I remembered a fun story that Sara had told me from college where she had lost a game of strip billiards and was the only naked person in a room with a bunch of her friends. I wasn't there but from her telling of the story it sounded like she had made an ill-advised billiards bet, lost all of her clothes, and been the lone naked person in a room with 8-10 friends for awhile. I was able to coax out of her that it was a "fun night" and I figured out that she didn't mind the attention all that much, and thought the whole thing was pretty sexy. So, I figured that story was fair game for a "never have I ever..." prompt.

"Never have I ever...lost a game of strip pool and been the only naked person at a party." I said.

Everyone laughed, and of course Sara was the only person who drank. Kirstin totally took the bait and teased Sara for it.

"Sara!" she exclaimed.

"Oh whatever...it was fun. Besides, at least I didn't chicken out!" Sara said.

"I wouldn't chicken out!" Kirstin said back.

"That's right, you wouldn't even play!" Sara teased, with a grin.

"I smell a challenge!" I said, and almost managed a straight face for a couple of seconds.

This went back and fourth a few times, and Kirstin admitted that she had never played any sort of stripping game but said that she thought it sounded like fun. I was about to cut in and volunteer to run grab a deck of cards when Sara cut the chase and challenged Kirstin.

"There is NO way you would ever get naked like that. You wouldn't even go for a skinny dip tonight!" Sara teased again. It was kind of funny...had Brian or I teased her like that, we would have been total jackasses and she probably wouldn't have even listened. But because it came from her female roommate, she was apparently not wanting to back down from the challenge!

"Ok, fine, we can get naked!" Kirstin said, relenting to the pressure from her roommate.

"Getting naked here with just us is no big deal. Doing it in front of a group of people and not being able to hide under the water takes guts!" Sara shot back. Of course, Brian and I would have gladly settled for that but Sara apparently wanted to up the ante.

At this point, it was just fun to watch them mess with each other. First, Kirstin tried to argue that being naked in our hot tub was no less daring than Sara's strip billiards story. Then, Sara argued that Kirstin was too chicken to do either one.

"So, Kirstin...are you saying that if Sara gets naked here, you will get naked the next time we have people over?" I asked. Again, I almost managed to keep a straight face. I'm not sure what Sara getting naked had to do with the challenge, but I didn't want to let this one pass without at least getting a decent glimpse of Sara and I really didn't think it would be hard to talk her into. It wasn't.

"Oh whatever, you just want to see us naked!" Kirstin said, as both girls rolled their eyes.

"...and?" I asked, grinning wide.

"Whatever....I'm game!" Sara said, quickly shutting everyone up.

"You're what?!?" Kirstin said, somewhat in disbelief.

"I said I'm game. I will take off my suit right now. Then tomorrow night, we will have people over and you have to get naked." Sara said. We had loose plans to have some kind of gathering the following night, and suddenly it became an interesting event!

"What? No way!" Kirstin said.

"See! I told you that you'd chicken out!" Sara said, with a laugh.

"I didn't say I chickened out!" Kirstin said.

Sara didn't say anything back. She simply stood up, and reached behind her back, and untied her top. We were all in disbelief as her top fell off, exposing her boobs. Before anyone could say anything, she bent over, pulling her bottoms down and stepping out of them. She tossed her top and her bottoms onto a chair near the hot tub, and stood up in front of us without even trying to cover up. It was dark out but thanks to the moonlight and the porch light we could very clearly see that her nipples were rock hard, and her pussy was cleanly shaved.

"Now...that is what I call putting your bathing suit where your mouth is!" Brian joked.

For a minute we all stared at Sara, and she didn't seem to mind in the least. She stood there for at least a minute or two and we were all staring at her. Brian and I staring at her hot body we were seeing for the first time, and Kirstin staring at her like she had completely lost her mind. While we were all staring at Sara, Sara was staring at Kirstin. I hadn't really picked up a competitive vibe between them before, but something had clearly gotten into them tonight! Plus, I'm sure it didn't hurt that we had been drinking all day.

"Ok, I held up my end of this. Kirstin, what do you say?" Sara said, with a great deal of confidence.

"Ok...so I have to take off my suit too?" Kirstin asked. She didn't seem upset about it, and had a grin on her face. It definitely broke some tension that she was being a good sport about it.

"Well, you can if you want to. But tomorrow night, we are having the same number of people over from my strip pool game that you teased me for earlier and you have to get naked then!" Sara said.

"How many people was that, exactly?" I cut in, with a grin.

Both girls gave me a funny look.

"What? If we are making plans here..." I said, and everyone laughed.

"I don't know, I think the four of us and five or six more will do it." Sara said. I had been pretty close with my guess!

"So I have to play strip pool...?" Kirstin asked, somewhat confused.

"Whatever. We can play a game or you can just strip down but my point is you have to be naked just like I was in my story when you said it sounded like fun and that you wouldn't chicken out of!" Sara said, laughing as she said it.

"Well, we have a foosball table..." I said, trying to act casual and conceal my excitement. Also, by volunteering our house I was making 100% sure that Brian and I would be invited. And of course, I was trying to be a good wingman for Brian since I knew he wanted to hook up with Kirstin but didn't want to appear too eager himself.

"Fine, strip foosball then. But she has to lose. She has to be the naked one!" Sara said. We were all cracking up at this point, and Sara was still standing up, totally visible to us.

"Ok, fine! But you have to stay naked the rest of tonight, and you have to do it with me tomorrow! And I'm not doing it if there is a bunch of total strangers or randoms there!" Kirstin said, as if Sara wasn't already planning on staying naked.

"Alright, I'll do it too, but you're getting naked first. Just like my story, you have to be the only one, at least for awhile! And if I am staying naked tonight, you have to do it tonight too!" Sara said. Brian and I couldn't believe our luck.

Kirstin giggled, blushed and finally relented. She leaned forward and reached behind her back sheepishly to untie her top. With a grin, she let it fall off and then reached her hands under the water and slipped her bottoms off without getting up. And just like that, we had two gorgeous naked girls in our hot tub!

"I told you I wouldn't chicken out! It's really not THAT big of a deal" Kristin said, giggling, and I almost believed her. I was still thinking there was no way she would actually follow through the following night but in the meantime I was enjoying my view of naked Sara and naked Kirstin. We hadn't seen Kirstin below the waist yet but her boobs were just barely above the water line. Sara was still standing.

At this point, Kirstin had risen to the challenge and Sara was still standing up but a minute or so later, Sara started to get back down into the water and Kirstin was not having it. I'm not sure if she was trying to get Sara to back down or if she was just enjoying teasing her but either way, Brian and I appreciated it!

"Oh no you don't! No hiding under the water! If I am getting naked at a party tomorrow night you at least have to be above the water tonight!" Kirstin said. Of course, Sara didn't seem to mind. She also seemed to forget that she had agreed to get naked at the party too, but I don't think she minded. The whole reason Sara had ended up in the billiard game was that she loved the attention. The funny thing at that point is that Brian and I would have totally joined them in the nude but neither girl brought it up at first and we didn't want to seem too eager.

"Ok!" Sara said, and she sat up on the side of the hot tub, completely visible. At this point, Brian and I grinned a little bit, unsure how we got this lucky to end up in the middle of this series of events. She challenged Kirstin to join her but Kirstin seemed ok letting Sara win this one. However, realizing that Sara was enjoying the exposure, I decided to push my luck just a little bit.

"Actually, we could use some more drinks." I said, mostly just to see how Sara would react.

Sara smirked, and walked off toward our kitchen with a wink. Totally naked. After Sara was gone, Kirstin got up and turned on some more lights, and giggled as she realized that she had given Brian and I quite the show in the process. We already had a good view of her boobs but now we could see that her pussy was shaved just like Sara's. She was not as bold as Sara about standing up to give us all a better look but she was a good sport and paused for a few seconds or so to let us have a peek. She even halfway smiled, halfway grinned and totally blushed at us while we looked.

"I guess go ahead and get a good look, but it's not like you wont see me naked tomorrow too!" she said, with a giggle. That was the first time she actually admitted she was going to go through with it. She ended her pause pretty quickly, maybe ten seconds or so, and got into the hot tub again.

"So, you're going through with it tomorrow night then?" Brian asked.

"I guess so. I mean, it's not that big of a deal and who cares, you guys have all seen me naked now. And it's not like I have any chance of winning strip foosball anyways, you guys know how bad I am at that game. Seriously though, nobody weird or random! I'll totally do it but not if there is anyone creepy there" she said. She didn't seem upset at all at this point and Brian was clearly pleased having a good time.

"Don't worry, it'll just be us and a few other people. Any ideas?" Brian said, reassuringly.

We chatted for a minute about who was cool enough to not be weird around the fact that we were planning a party where at least one guest had to get naked by the end of the night. Kirstin asked us to keep the whole thing a secret, and I guess she had a point that it would all feel very weird if we didn't at least act like it was a coincidence. Eventually, we settled on five or six people to invite and decided at random we would play foosball around 10pm and suggest strip foosball after a match or two. I was thinking that we would be lucky if we had even half of them come. Of course, we greatly underestimated the attendance but more on that later!

"So, did you like what you saw earlier?" Kirstin asked me teasingly, trying to shift the conversation topic. I suppose she could have been asking about me seeing her naked for the first time but somehow I knew she was asking about Sara, and that she apparently had figured out that I had a bit of a crush on Sara.

"Yeah, that was pretty awesome." I said with a big grin. We all giggled and laughed, and I knew that tonight was my night to make a move. With Sara making such a bold display I figured I should make a move and Kirstin asking me about it told me everything I needed to know.

"Yeah, you should probably make some kind of move tonight. Just sayin...I don't think she's doing this just to see me naked. She's seen me naked 100 times!" Kirstin said, confirming what I suspected. I winked at her.

Part of me wanted to ask about the "100 times" I knew they were roommates but it sounded like maybe there was more nudity in their house than I would have expected but just then Sara walked back, with a tray of drinks in her hands and her fabulous body fully on display with the entire back yard now lit up by the lights Kirstin had turned on.

"Gosh, it sure looks like someone turned on some more lights! Go ahead, get a good look!" Sara said, as she put the drinks down and motioned her hands up and down her body, jokingly hamming it up like she was a dancer or something. If Kirstin paused for ten seconds and stood still to give us a good view in the lights, Sara paused for at least a minute or two and was striking poses! Not only did we have a better view with the lights on but the neighbors probably did too! So of course I pointed this out.

"Well, I'm sure the neighbors are enjoying this one!" I joked. Both girls blushed and giggled.

Things didn't last too much longer in the hot tub but for the rest of the time we were out there, Sara sat up on the side of the hot tub in full view of everyone, and Kirstin sat in the water but made no effort to cover her boobs which were mostly above the water. It was pretty awesome, and clearly neither girl minded that we were sneaking plenty of looks at both of them. Their rock hard nipples told us that they didn't mind the attention at all.

The joke of this whole thing was totally on Kirstin. Sara was enjoying every minute of being naked, and Kirstin seemed calm and confident but at least a little bit nervous about the following evening. I don't think Kirstin cared at all about being naked in the hot tub nor was she really nervous about strip foosball but she seemed to be concerned with who would be invited. I figured that was a good sign but also thought the odds of her chickening out eventually were at least 50-50. Still, she was being a good sport and like most hot girls in their mid 20's she seemed more concerned with how she would look and who would be there than she was with actually doing it.

The night started to wind down, but Sara never got shy and actually did make another naked drink run for us. As soon as she was gone, I hatched my plan.

"Ok, how about when she gets back, you guys head inside and bring some towels out. That'll give me a good opportunity. Give me like five minutes. If you see her get out of the hot tub and put her suit on, I totally struck out so come on back outside. If we are making out, just leave us some towels on the deck." I said.

"I like your odds" Kirstin said, with a smile and a wink. I totally wanted to believe her, but I was a little bit drunk still and not totally sure if this was just her way of messing with Sara.

A minute later, Sara came back. It was after midnight now, and it had gotten a little bit cooler outside. She got back in the tub (although her boobs were still above the water line) and nobody said anything. We nursed our drinks for a minute, and Brian volunteered to run grab towels and he asked Kirstin for a hand. They headed off together, leaving Sara and I alone in the hot tub. We were finally alone but Sara didn't move. She sat next to me, totally naked still.

"What a night, eh?" I said, to break the tension.

"I know, right?" Sara said, and giggled.

"You having fun still?" I asked, and jokingly nodded toward her nipples. They were still rock hard, and we had all been teasing her for it all night.

"Obviously!" she said, with a grin and stuck out her chest a little bit.

I took that as my cue, and leaned in to kiss her. We shared a long kiss, leaning in to each other and made out for a couple of minutes. I started to pull her closer, and she resisted just a little bit.

"What if they come back?" Sara asked me.

"Don't worry, they won't" I said, noticing that they had apparently come and gone and left us towels on the porch.

She must have realized I had already told them not to come back out because she climbed right into my lap without any further prompting. Naked. Now things started to really get hot and heavy. I kissed her deeply, and ran my hands all over her body. She arched her back, and I ran my hands to her tits. As soon as I touched her nipples, she moaned loudly and I realized we needed to move from the backyard to the bedroom sooner than later.

"Shall we head inside?" I asked. She nodded in return, and we got out of the water.

She picked up her swimsuit, but didn't put it on. I handed her a towel, and she used it to dry off but didn't put it on. We went inside and she was still naked, with her swimsuit in one hand and the towel in the other and nothing covering her up. We passed Brian and Kirstin on the couch. Kirstin had a towel wrapped around her but had not put her suit back on. We all just kind of grinned at each other as Sara and I headed up to my room.