I made a mistake. I am a man, but thats no excuse. I cheated. It wasn't right of me, and I regretted it... when I got caught. I'm not perfect, never said I was. I thought that it was it, I thought she was going to dump me right on the spot if I ever got caught; I was wrong.
For a little background, my girlfriend Sara and I have been together for about a year and a half, and we've been happy. I have to admit though, I can get a little bored in the bedroom, which is where this whole story starts.
Turns out that the beautiful blonde I had in my bed last week was one of my girlfriends pledge sister. When she was talking with her sorority sisters about the Wrestler she had fucked on the fourth floor of my building, it didn't take long for my girl to realize who had cheated.
Well one day after practice, I head over to my girl's room like I do after every practice. I climb the stairs and head down the hall, all excited about the cock that is about to be in my girl's pussy, visualizing myself about to fuck her. Her short 5'3 frame with her 120 pound body sprawled on her body, her 34 C tits, tight ass and long brown hair. I knock on the door and she opens the door but she doesn't look too happy to see me.
"Hey baby" I say, a little confused, a little nervous "Something wrong?"
"I'd say so. Come in" I walk in and get a little more confused to see a guy John who I'd met once or twice, he was in Sara's women studies class. "That girl you fucked last wednesday night? She is my pledge sister. We figured it out earlier tonight."
I began to panic "Baby, I..." I struggled to find the words but decided I'd just be honest "I fucked up. It's not you, I just get bored with the sex after a while" she just looked at me with her hard eyes.
"I always thought I'd dump any boy that ever cheated on me" I winced. "However, I decided to do something else. I am going to fuck John. You're going to watch."
"I'm... what?"
"You heard me; You have two options; 1) Watch your girlfriends pussy get slammed by another guy. 2) We break up, you leave, and I fuck him anyways" I was shocked. Speechless. But I nodded my head.
"Option number 1".
"Good" Sara walked over to John who was sitting in a chair and straddled him, his side facing me so I could see everything. She grabbed his hair and started kissing his mouth and his neck, rubbing her chest against his, her crotch against his. I felt a twang when I saw him reach back and squeeze her ass nice and hard. She smiled and pulled her sweater off, revealing a black lacy bra that I've never seen. I am starting to feel a little sick, watching my girlfriend go at it with another guy. John grinned and buried his face between Sara's C breast. He reaches up and unsnaps her bra with one had, she slides it off and throws it at me.