(FOREWORD: This is a long one, with a kind of slow build-up. Immediate gratification seekers might want to move on. This is a story with some tension, characters, and hopefully, a payoff. 25,000 words over two parts. Comments are welcome, but mutual respect is required. Thanks for reading).
Things began to heat up as we were kissing. The collision of our tongues became the expected instead of the surprise. Rory bit down on my lip and at the same time merged his hands with mine in a way that made me feel I had suddenly lost all control in our coupling. Before I knew what was happening, he had me on my back. The two of us almost fell off the couch, provoking a laugh from him; I was still too caught off guard. I couldn't stop him from the position where I lay.
I couldn't say for sure that I wanted to stop him.
Rory's hand snuck beneath my blouse and I pressed my fingers against it, trapping it on the edge of my ribcage. We were still locked in a long kiss. He breathed into my mouth when we parted as if dosing me with a mint-flavored gas.
"Why?"
"You know why," I said. I hadn't lost my trust in him, though, and I think I proved that when I didn't push him away, only leaned back and caught my breath. I continued to hold his hand in place, but made it feel more like an affectionate touch. We were breathing in each other's faces for several seconds. It made me laugh. I don't think that made him happy. "I guess you thought tonight would be our big night."
Although he didn't make it sound aggravated, he told me, "We've been going out for three weeks, Erica."
"Three
weekends
," I corrected, hoping I didn't sound like a bitch. He slipped his hand out from under my shirt and I sat up until he moved away to give me space. "I don't want to make it sound like it hasn't been a good time. I'm just saying... you know how they measure your hours in flight school? It's like you could say we've been dating for three weeks, but if that's only twenty hours of flight time, you know..."
"So you think I haven't been logging my hours?"
Me and my big mouth. I grinned away the insult and put a hand on the back of Rory's neck. "It's not all about you. I've been handling a full class load... even for someone who enjoys it, psych gets pretty thick at times. I've been practically working full-time at the bookstore since they fired all those students—"
"I know that. I know. I was hoping tonight would be our 'get to know each other' time," said Rory, sinking into the couch as if the night were already over for him.
"Seriously?" I leaned against him and started to put my head on his arm, but it slid into his lap and I didn't bother rising again. I smiled up at him. "I like you a lot, Rory. You have to know that. Especially after all I went through with that asshole Conner. Then my boyfriend before that—"
"You told me we wouldn't talk about them anymore..."
"Ugh, so damned hard not to," I said with a smile. "You get where I'm going with this. I told you on the second date I needed some time. If you thought it was
this
much time and instead it's
that
much... I don't blame you for being disappointed..."
The way his thumb stroked my hair told me he wouldn't stay mad at me. "I don't want to be the next asshole you tell the future boyfriend about..."
"You're not like Conner at all. I'm sorry you've got to deal with his bullshit. It's not fair. I feel like I wish I could tell you about it... but I already told you. My words don't make you feel what I felt about it. He made me feel cheap and... worthless. You know I don't have a problem with sex..."
"I know," said Rory. He looked me in the eye when he said it. I suspected he was lying, but not a hateful lie to protect himself or advance anything. I really believed he wanted to share my feelings; he just didn't.
My palm ran along his jaw and I thrilled at the scrape of his 5 o'clock—make that 1 a.m.—stubble. Rory had odd eyes, narrow sockets, but always seeming to face each other by their unusual shape and symmetry; it was the baby blues within that kept my attention, however. He had pouty cheeks and a nose with just a couple of ounces more weight to it than most people would have thought sexy. As short as he kept his golden blond hair, its curls wound around his ears but didn't get too wild. From the first day I met him at the Cabana's poetry slam I dreamed of what he would look like with that hair grown out to his shoulders. Robert Plant? Mmm. Sammy Hagar? Not so much.
I never wanted to believe that men and women were all that different. As young as I was, I could believe there were things I had yet to learn, and maybe I would find out that men did actually have to have sex and couldn't control themselves when it came to that biological imperative. I didn't want to believe it. I found it easier to believe that men just grew up in a culture where they expected to get everything they wanted, while women were expected to demonstrate greater self-control. Men could be sluts—women couldn't. I would have enjoyed being a slut, probably. But I couldn't let myself. Even if I wanted to be with Rory as much as I did.
I rose to rest on my elbows, leaned upward until he met me, and we kissed again. I wanted to feel safe with him. I wanted to overcome my fears of what he would do. Not the physical, which was almost an afterthought, but how he might bounce my heart around like that gorilla with a suitcase.
My lips left his and I knew I couldn't go any further. I thought about hearing all of those rumors about what I had done with Conner and his friends—things I hadn't done—and the looks people gave me. I smiled sadly and stared into his eyes. They were adorable eyes. I wished they weren't so disappointed.
"You know how much better it's going to be after all this build-up?" he asked me, squeezing me around the shoulders. It made me erupt in laughter, and he smiled back at me. What a prize I had stumbled on.
Rory and I went to the kitchen and we started reheating the Mexican take-out we had started out our evening with. Probably not a good idea, I reminded myself. I had lucked out that my burrito with extra hot sauce hadn't triggered a digestive meltdown the first time. Good thing our romance was on hiatus for the time. Rory slammed the microwave and hit the buttons, then crossed his arms as he half-turned to me and smiled.
His shirt was unbuttoned down to his belly. My handiwork, before I realized I wasn't prepared to follow him all the way. I had to look away. His waxed pectorals could make me appreciate why guys obsessed over cleavage.
"I saw him again, you know. Conner."
I could only nod. The fact my great new guy friend and my hideous ex-boyfriend knew each other had been a heartbreaking surprise, enough that I didn't think we would weather that initial bump in the road. But Rory did convince me he was different. While he admitted to thinking a lot of Conner before meeting me, he also said he could barely stand to share the same room with him later. They weren't close friends, Rory insisted, but Rory's freshman roommate, Jack, was pretty close with Conner, who was in the same fraternity, so they ended up hanging out more than a few times. Rory said he had to keep himself from knocking Conner out the first time he saw him after I told him about our history, and while I said I was glad he had shown restraint, a part of me wished he hadn't.
"What's the great genius up to?" I asked, against my better judgment. "Genius" wasn't much of a term of mockery. Conner was a hell of a programmer and had already made a small fortune designing websites around the campus. If we had gotten married, and I had dreamed of it a few times while we were together, I would have probably gone on to be a very rich woman, assuming his business plans for some of the games he was designing were as sound as the designs themselves. He had already made and sold a game before he graduated high school. "Most likely to succeed" was a title he hadn't won in his old hometown, but he would rewrite that after college; he would probably keep any "worst boyfriend ever" title.
Rory yawned before telling me, "He's, uh... he's doing a redesign on the Raincoating website. You would not believe the traffic that thing gets..."
"Yeah, who would have thought people would want to see naked dicks on the internet?" I laughed. I had to look away as I started to blush. I wanted to sound cool with Rory, but good god, talking about penises? After the way our evening had gone, I wasn't fooling anyone.
He gave me a nod as he opened the microwave and put on a ridiculous quilt-like oven mitt to handle the burrito plate. "Who knew? ...Yeah. The website only gets more traffic as we get closer to Hell Night. Jack has been having Conner re-doing the whole thing while—shit! Hot." He put his burnt thumb in his mouth before going on, rolling his eyes in embarrassment.
"Be careful with that. It's hot."
"Thanks. No, Jack has been... putting up all the recruiting material. He's even got the applications all online now."
"There's an application to be naked on the internet now? That's a long line."