At the end of chapter two of this story our couple, Sam and Melinda Anderson, are returning from a dinner invitation at the home of Lars and Astrid, Gustafson. They had gone to the dinner uncertain as to whether the intention of the Gustafsons was simply to have dinner or to seduce them into an evening's sexual swap of spouses. As it turned out Sam had spent the evening watching an NFL game with Lars while Melinda had her first experience with girl-on-girl sex with the bi-sexual Astrid. As this chapter opens Sam is driving home while a naked Melinda occasionally strokes his cock. In this chapter, Sam is the narrator.
As I pulled into the garage and closed the big door behind us, Melinda, silent until now, spoke up. "Sam I'm sure you realize that while you and Lars were watching the football game Astrid and I were making love. Well, not quite. We were just fucking; no love involved. I hope that meets your definition of 'play it by ear,' because I think that is what we agreed to do tonight."
"I remember," I said. I also remembered that we hadn't quite reached any agreement on what was meant by, 'play it by ear.' I kept that thought to myself as I looked at Melinda in silence in the dim light remaining from the garage door opener. "Was it good?" I asked. "The sex I mean?"
The light faded as it timed out and we sat in dark silence for a long moment.
"Yes, it was good. Just fucking unbelievable. Really beyond anything I've ever experienced."
"Okay. Are you going to tell me about it?" I asked. "I want to hear all the details." It was a line each of us often used when asking the other to tell lewd sales of fictional sexual misconduct with others as a precursor to lovemaking. But tonight was different because prior to this our ten-year marriage had been totally monogamous. Now it wasn't.
"Sam," she said. "I will tell you. I'll tell you all the things she did to me . . . or maybe they were for me. Anyway, I'll share all of it with you. But not right now. Right now I want to make love with you. What Astrid and I did was just fucking, but what I want now is for you to love me. Can you do that Sam?"
"Yes."
"Thank you. I will tell you all the details in the morning. And then we can do some fucking of our own. We have a whole weekend ahead of us."
"When I'm with you it's never just fucking," I said.
Within minutes we were naked in bed spooning with Melinda's warm round ass pushed against me and my cock deeply imbedded in her cunt. We weren't fucking aggressively; just lying beneath the covers, our bodies pressed together and peacefully coupled.
"Oh god, Sam that feels so good. I can't put into words how good it feels to be lying here with your arms around me, your hands cupping my tits and your wonderful cock filling me."
"Yes," I agreed, unable to put my own emotion into words.
We lay like that for a long time until I began to slowly stroke my cock in and out of her.
"Oh yes, Sam. Keep that up. It feels so good."
I had spent whole evening nominally watching a football game while my mind drifted about in lewd speculation about what the women were doing. Half erect the entire evening; I wasn't sure how long I could delay reaching a climax. "I'm not going to last long babe," I said.
"That's okay. Just go ahead and fill me up with that hot cum of yours." Her cunt felt warm, snug, slippery, and soft all at the same time. My prick was in heaven. "I want to feel your cock squirting into my cunt. Filling it me with your love juice," she whispered.
She was quiet again as I kept slowly pumping my cock in and out of her. I could feel a climax approaching. "It's okay Sam, go ahead and cum. Don't wait for me. I'm not sure I can cum again. Too much already tonight."
I picked up the pace planning to just let myself go. But contrary to what she had said I could hear her making the little whining noises she makes shortly before she climaxes some nights. "Come on babe. You can do it. Sam it's me you're fucking. Let yourself go."
Just as I felt the cum start to rush up my shaft l heard her groan and felt her cunt squeeze my cock. It wasn't a big climax for her. Just a little one but our timing was perfect as I shot stream after stream into her.
When we were done she rolled over and put her face against my chest. She was sobbing. I could feel her tears running down my chest. "I love you Sam."
"I love you too," I said. And I meant it, even if she had been fucking another woman tonight.
When I awoke it was nearing 10:00 a.m. and the sun was streaming in the windows of our bedroom. I slid from beneath the blankets, taking care not to awake Melinda. A few minutes later I was standing in our big walk-in shower with warm water streaming over me when I heard the door to the shower open. Turning, I saw my naked wife joining me.
"Good morning."
"Is it?" she asked.
"Sure. Why not?" I responded.
"You're not upset about what happened last night?"
"No. I told you I wasn't last night. We said we would 'play it by ear,' and you did."
"Oh thank you," she said as she pressed her body against me, her face against my chest. We stood in silence for a long time, my arms holding her tight against me with the warm water pouring over us.
Finally I pushed her back, just a bit so I was holding her face in my hands and looking down at her. "Listen to me Melinda. We said we would play it by ear and you need to understand if our roles had been reversed and Astrid had set out to seduce me, I would have done the same as you. And then I would have come home and made love to just as we did last night . . . even if you had been screwing Lars all evening. But now I want you to share the details with me, just as I would you. That's part of our deal now. We each can have our fling with others but it won't be a secret. Agreed?"
"Yes."
Later I would look back at the brief foregoing conversation as a landmark change in our relationship. Monogamy was no longer a part of it.
"Now soap me up Sam I need to get clean. I will tell you all the details over breakfast in the kitchen."
We lathered each other up and as often happens when you do that in a shower we wound up having sex. Melinda was leaning against a tiled wall with her butt sticking out at me and her legs spread just right so she was at the perfect height for me. I stepped in behind her and after stroking my dick between her pussy lips I slowly slid it into her cunt. She moaned as I entered her and once I was fully seated she began wiggling twisting her hips to drag my prick around inside her cunt.
I slapped her hard on one side and then the other side of her ass. "Why you nasty little slut. So this morning you want to fuck don't you?"
"Yes," she growled. "Last night was for making love. This morning is for fucking. So put that nice stiff prick of yours to work Sam and fuck me with it. Fuck me good and hard."
I grabbed both her hips and began stroking my cock in and out of her cunt. Good strong measured strokes to begin with soon followed by faster and harder thrusts. Melinda matched each thrust with a thrust of her own hips causing me to bottom out in her each time.
"Oh fuck Sam. Fuck, fuck, fuck. That's so good so fucking good." Then she retreated to just grunting as I drove each stroke home: "ugh, ugh, ugh, ugh, ugh . . ."