Note to Readers: This is a standalone story; but if you enjoy it, you might want to read Night 3 of Spring Break, as well as earlier ones involving the same characters.
Our six college friends, who had remained on campus during Spring Break, had settled on a game to amuse themselves in the otherwise quiet evenings. It was a game of questions and challenges -- with an adult theme. It consisted of three stacks of cards. One set had questions to be answered. One had challenges to be performed. If the other players felt that there had been a failure to adequately answer a question or perform a challenge, the third set consisted of 'penalties' for the unfortunate player.
There were a few 'house' rules, devised by Brad (the ring leader) to keep things interesting: One couldn't select more than one Question card in a row; and the other players could substitute one Challenge and one Question of their creation in lieu of whatever was on the card a player selected.
The game started relatively tamely. Roger chose a Question, and had to admit when he first had sex (age 17, behind the football stadium bleachers.) Clarice chose a Challenge, and gave a back rub to one of the girls. Then it was Alice's turn. She chose a Question.
Q: What sex position or activity is the one you hate the most?
Alice gave a sardonic laugh. "Are you crazy? If I answer this, one of you jokers will make it a future challenge. I won't say."
"If you refuse to answer, you have to choose a penalty card."
"OK then, I'll answer the Question. I hate having my breasts rubbed."
"Wait, you used to love that," said her (former) boyfriend Roger, innocently.
"Shut up, stupid," Alice said, clearly caught in a fabrication.
"Wow, she lied. That has to be addressed, otherwise this game has no integrity," said Cliff.
(Really, integrity in a Truth or Dare-style board game? But it sounded good.)
"She needs to choose a Penalty card."
Alice, grumbling mostly at the betrayal by her 'friend' Roger, picked a card.
Penalty: "The player deserves a good spanking; 10 swats each administered by the other players."
Alice's eyes got wide, as she saw smiles and head nods by the boys.
"Grab her."
Two guys each got hold of an arm. Other hands undid the clasp and zipper of her pants and they were lowered to her knees. Alice was pulled to Brad's lap, bent over at the waist. As Brad held her there, her plump derriere, clad in silky blue panties, angled upward.
"It wouldn't be a true spanking unless it was against the flesh," Roger suggested.
That was all that was needed, and the panties were pulled down too, to join the pants at her knees. The soft white flesh of her behind rose up invitingly. Alice kept her legs tightly pressed together, knowing that she'd otherwise be displaying some more interesting flesh just inches away.
Brad rubbed his hand softly up and down the cheeks of her butt, then let one finger intrusively drag into the crack, causing Alice to jerk upward. "Hey," she cried.
"Oops, my apologizes," he said with a smirk. Then he pulled the hand away and struck one cheek. Then the other.
Alice yelped. Each person, including the women, took a turn striking the backside. It slowly grew a crimson color. Cliff noticed that Clarice was unusually flustered and breathing heavily as she administered the strikes on Alice's bare bottom. Something about the look in her eyes made him think something was going on. (He would shortly be proven right.)
When they were done, Alice drew her clothes back up. "Hope you guys had fun. Remember, I can devise a challenge too," she said ominously.
Joan drew a Question. "Name the most ticklish spots on your body."
This was not the worst question, to be sure, but she feared this would come back to haunt her.
"My feet, along the ribs, and the inner thighs."
As she feared, the guys' faces showed that they were entering that information into their memory banks. "Oh my," she thought.
It was Roger's turn. Challenge.
"If a man: Let the other players determine if you are circumcised, by feel only, into your shorts."
That was not good, Roger thought. He wouldn't mind the ladies doing a grope, but the other guys? That was a bridge too far.
"I'll take a Penalty," he said.
He drew a card.
Penalty: "Demonstrate your favorite masturbation techniques."
"Ugh." was his response. In front of everyone? Including the guys? This was worse than the Challenge.
"I'll do the Challenge," he finally said. The others, magnanimously, let him reverse his position.
Roger took off his pants and stood in his briefs. The others lined up, and felt down the briefs to the penis. The women grasped and rolled it around, feeling for the foreskin. The guys, mercifully, mostly made a show of inserting their hand into the briefs, but didn't in fact touch his private parts.
All the ladies correctly ascertained he was circumcised. The two guys didn't even bother to guess
Clarice was next. She chose a Question.
Before she could read the card, Roger interposed his own. "Tell us what you thought about spanking Amy's backside."
Clarice paused, thinking how to answer. "Well, she's got a great ass. If I were a guy, I'd look at those mounds all day."
"You didn't answer the question."
Clarice's throat tightened. She could always lie - but that had gotten Alice into trouble. And there was that thing about the integrity of the game.
"I thought it was very exciting," she admitted. "Seeing someone powerless and on display like that was a turn-on. I'm sure I'll have to explain my pleasure at witnessing that to a therapist one day."
Everyone laughed at the admission - and the seed of a later challenge was planted.
Brad was next. "Challenge."
Alice smiled. She was waiting. Before he could draw a card, she said, "Forget the card. I've got the challenge for you. I'm going to cover Cliff's guy parts with whipped cream. You need to clean him off, with your tongue and mouth."
There was dead silence in the room. Brad was not gay. This challenge would force him to do something far outside his comfort zone - or he'd have to forfeit and chose a penalty card.
"Hey, challenges have to be male/female, don't they?" he asked plaintively, hoping the others would rescue him.
"You set the house rules, remember? You didn't say anything about that," Alice said.
"I won't do it," Brad said. "Any penalty would have to be better."
He chose a penalty card: "Each player will remove one article of clothes from the penalized player."
Brad was wearing shoes, socks, a shirt, undershirt, pants and briefs.
It was agreed that shoes and socks each counted as one item. That meant five of his six pieces of clothes would get removed.
Cliff chose the shoes. Clarice took the shirt. Joan chose the pants. That left him in his undershirt, briefs and socks.