Author's Note:
This is a stand-alone story that is part of a larger series about the titular character, Nellie. Each story that follows can be read on its own or together, in any particular order, though they will be posted in chronological order. The stories may fall under different categories, but all will tell tales of Nellie's various adventures.
In this adventure, Nellie and her friends play a game of Truth or Dare that reveals secrets, fulfills fantasies, and gets riskier as the night goes on. This story takes place after the events of Nellie & The Officers.
Special thank you to OneAuthor and norafares for editing.
**
"Truth."
"What's the craziest thing you've ever done sexually?"
Veronica's face went bright red, unable to stop herself from glancing across the circle at me.
"Never mind. Dare."
A wave of disappointed shouts and raucous laughter filled the room as Veronica refused to answer the question. I was one of the laughers, as was Sydney, who most certainly knew what Veronica would have said. Jake didn't laugh, but he did smile as he held Veronica's hand comfortingly.
"Now I just want to know what it is even more," complained Alison.
"Yeah, you can't switch after picking," added Brandon.
Poor Veronica. Her mouth opened and closed silently as she met my eyes again.
I didn't care for one second if she told everyone about the threesome she, Jake, and I had in the locker room. But Veronica was a bit more tightly wound than I was, and wasn't quite ready for people to know about her sex life. I doubt she had expected the game to get so sexually focused, naive as she was.
At first, we had all pretended that playing Truth or Dare was far beneath us. Far too mature for that, we had said. But that was a bold-faced lie. Slowly, people admitted that they'd like to play, and there we were.
It was far more fun to play as adults, I had decided. The addition of alcohol made people a lot less inhibited with their answers and dares. The few times I'd played in high school, the Truth questions were all about who liked who, and the Dares were fairly tame. This game had started off strong. Since we were at Sydney and Reid's, they had flipped a coin for who would go first, and Reid won. He spun the bottle and landed on Calvin.
"Truth," Calvin had picked.
"What's your weirdest fetish?"
Calvin had looked surprised, glancing around the room.
"It's cool, man, we're all friends here," Jake said kindly.
He had still stuttered a bit before answering. "Well, I mean, it's not that I've ever done it before, but I always kind of wanted... I mean, it would be... you know that like, rope... tying... rope bondage stuff?"
So, that's how we found out Calvin was into what he finally said was kinbaku, an intricate type of rope binding. I immediately decided that if he picked Dare, we were daring him to try tying someone up.
We'd also found out that Alison lost her virginity in a clubhouse her friend had built above the bar her mom owned, watched Jake take a body shot off Brandon, and witnessed Kara leaning against the couch in just her bra after being dared to take her shirt off.
It was Kara who had asked for Veronica's craziest sexual story, and who was insisting that she couldn't switch to Dare. I took pity on Veronica as she looked around for help.
"I think you can switch after picking, but only once," I interjected.
"When we used to play it back home, you could refuse to do the Truth or Dare, but you had to do Seven Minutes in Heaven with someone of the asker's choosing," Alison added.
"Fine, do we agree to that?" Kara asked, to which everyone nodded. "Okay, Veronica. Seven Minutes in Heaven with Reid."
Alison tried not to look offended that Kara had picked her date, but we all caught the look she gave Reid as he got up and led Veronica to the small storage room beside the bathroom that fit just the washer and dryer and a cabinet of various items. Giggling like maniacs, we crowded into the hallway and listened at the door as Sydney started up a timer.
To be honest, it was boring. Reid and Veronica were chatting quietly, awkward laughs occasionally floating through the closed door. When seven minutes was up and Sydney flung the door open, they were standing on opposite ends of the small room, Veronica's arms crossed as Reid leaned against the washing machine.
Alison looked relieved, and Jake smiled encouragingly at Veronica, but the rest of us groaned at the lack of result.
"Seven minutes wasted." Brandon shook his head sadly.
"Oh whatever, we could barely hear what they were saying anyways," Calvin muttered.
"You said your fetish was rope bondage, not voyeurism," I teased.
Calvin scoffed. "Brandon's the voyeur, not me."
"Oh sure, regular Peeping Tom over here," Brandon replied sarcastically as we made our way back to Sydney and Reid's living room.
Once everyone was seated, Veronica took her turn and spun the bottle. When the bottle landed on me for the first time of the game, I raised my eyebrows as I met Veronica's eyes.
"Be nice to me. Remember I said you could switch," I told her as everyone laughed. "I pick Dare."
"Dare her to take her shirt off," Calvin suggested.
"Nah, dare her to give someone a lap dance," said Sydney.
I stuck my tongue out at her. She knew what happened the last time I gave someone a lap dance.
Veronica cleared her throat. "I dare you to rub your boobs on Calvin's face for a full minute."
Calvin's eyes were wide and he couldn't stop himself from smiling. I laughed, too. Calvin was sitting between Veronica and Brandon, and I had a feeling it was more of a show for Veronica than anything.
"Sure. Bra on or off?" I asked, standing up as I removed my T-shirt.
I knew that Sydney, Veronica, and Jake wouldn't be surprised by seeing me half-naked. Kara and Reid didn't appear to care one way or another, and even Alison seemed to have loosened up a bit. Calvin appeared to be frozen in place, and Brandon was determined not to look at me, his cheerful demeanour suddenly much quieter than usual.
"Bra off," Veronica decided, shrugging nonchalantly.
Grinning at Calvin, I took my bra off and threw it back towards my shirt. His eyes were glued to me, and he barely moved as I straddled his lap and turned to Veronica.
"Start the timer!" I said cheerfully, then pressed my breasts against Calvin's face.
His breath was warm on my skin as I jiggled my tits against him. I knew Calvin was trying very hard not to react because the warm puffs that came through his slightly parted lips were frequent. Since I was straddling him, I could feel his cock starting to twitch beneath me. While it would have been incredibly fun to start grinding against him, I didn't know how much Calvin would appreciate that, so I pulled myself away from his crotch and pushed even harder against his face.
On one side, I knew Veronica was watching intently. Even though she and Jake were exclusive now, I had a feeling she'd realized she liked tits a bit more than she thought she had. I smiled at her discreetly, a knowing look in my eyes, before glancing towards Brandon.
Brandon's face was stoic, an unusual expression for him. He was a loud, boisterous guy with a thick beard and broad torso, usually smiling joyfully at all times. I thought perhaps he wasn't having fun, until I realized he was watching the show out of the corner of his eyes.
A little bit jealous, maybe.
I licked my lips. I had told Sydney I'd be interested in maybe hooking up with Brandon, but nothing had really come from it. That had been the same night I'd met Shaun and Darryl, and while I hadn't seen either of the officers again, the lewd fantasies we'd made up about Brandon had fallen somewhat by the wayside.
The thought of fucking him came roaring back, though. The thrill I'd gotten from feeling Calvin's cock twitch beneath me returned, only this time it was a full tingle of arousal at the thought of rubbing my tits across Brandon's face. I didn't know if anyone noticed my nipples harden even more. That is, aside from Calvin, who took in a sharp breath as I let one nipple trail across his lips.
Calvin's sudden inhale seemed to get Brandon's attention, and he noticed me looking at him. I bit my lip as we made eye contact and smiled as his eyes flicked down to my tits reflexively. When he looked back up at me, I knew right then and there that Brandon would be up for at least some of the little fantasies I'd thought up with Sydney.
"And that's time," Veronica said softly.
Calvin cleared his throat as I pulled away.
"Thanks!" I said to him brightly.
Laughter filled the room as I got off his lap. I pulled my T-shirt back on without bothering with my bra, settling back in place as Calvin tried to discreetly adjust himself.
"Your turn to spin," said Veronica.
I leaned to the center of the circle and spun it, watching as it flew past each person sitting there. When it finally slowed, it landed on Sydney.
She groaned and tilted her head back. "Goddamnit, of all the people..."
It wasn't without reason. Sydney and I were close, and I knew a lot about her. I knew exactly what kind of Truth questions would embarrass her, and exactly what kind of Dares would be the most difficult.
When she looked back at me, I could almost read her mind. 'Don't make me do anything with Reid,' her eyes seemed to beg.
Sydney had never admitted it to me, nor probably to anyone, but I knew she carried a torch for Reid. They had been friends since they were kids and were now roommates, though nothing remotely romantic had ever happened between them.
I wasn't a mean person. Whatever she asked, I didn't intend to cause any actual harm.
We stared at each other for a moment longer, trying to communicate only through eye contact, before she finally sighed. "Dare."
I thought for a moment. "I dare you to spin the bottle and make out with whoever it lands on for thirty seconds."
In comparison to the rest of the game, I thought it was a pretty tame request. Since everyone had just seen my tits, I figured it wouldn't be too big of a deal. Sydney looked relieved and spun the bottle right away.
My heart dropped as it slowed. I tried not to look panicked as it shifted past Jake and started to point at Reid. Even Sydney froze, her eyes wide, but luck was on our side. Both of us released a quiet breath as it moved past Reid and landed firmly on Alison.
