AUTHOR'S NOTE / DISCLAIMER
This series involves cuckolding, and contains both gay and hetero sex. If this does not interest you, you will not enjoy this story.
This chapter picks up right where Chapter 1 left off. Chapter 1 is in the "Loving Wives" section.
***
We all relaxed there for quite a while. Eventually, Chris stood up and walked down the hall to take a shower. While he was gone, Riley finally broke the silence with a simple, "Wow..."
I looked over at her from my spot on the floor and smiled sheepishly. "Yeah..."
"So, uh, you're, like, gay now?" she asked.
I hesitated, trying to figure out how to respond. "I mean, I've never done anything like that before," I said. "I think a lot of it was just a heat of the moment kind of a thing? I don't think I want to take it any further than what just happened."
"Hm," she said thoughtfully, nodding.
"But I definitely think you're still the hottest girl I've ever seen," I added quickly. She smiled, and reached her hand out toward me. I grabbed it lightly, and we held each other's hands like that for a minute. "So you aren't, like, dumping me for him?" I asked finally.
"Um, no..." she said. "I don't really think he's the relationship type. I'm definitely not interested in that with him."
"Good," I said.
"But that was definitely, like, some of the hottest sex I've ever had," she said. "I don't really think I'll be able to resist him going forward. Is that gonna be okay?"
"Yeah," I said. "I guess we'll just have to see how things go..."
Riley got off the couch and said she was going to go lie down in my bed for a little while. As she walked down the hallway, I followed. Chris emerged from the shower at the same time, dripping wet and in just a towel. Riley and I were still both naked, carrying our clothes.
"Hey, babe," he said to Riley, wrapping an arm around her waist and pulling her toward him.
She laid her hands on his muscled chest. "Hey, sexy, I was just gonna go lie down for a little bit."
"Sounds good," Chris said easily. She moved past him and walked into my room and he walked toward his. As I passed him, he slapped my bare ass firmly. I was a little stunned, but when I turned around, he just said, "Oops," with a cute little smile on his face, and I couldn't help but smile back. I knew I had just told Riley that I didn't want any of that gay stuff to escalate, but feeling him slap my ass like I was a piece of meat was definitely making me doubt that.
I threw my clothes into my room as Riley laid down on my bed. I told her I was gonna get in the shower and she just murmured something, clearly falling asleep.
As I showered, I decided that sure, I'm definitely attracted to Chris, there's no sense in denying that any more. But I wasn't going to let him fuck me, like I had said to him before. I wasn't into that, and it would just be taking things way too far.
When I got out of the shower, Riley went in to take one herself. I put on a tight-fitting pair of boxer briefs and a white t-shirt and went into the living room. Chris was sitting on the couch, wearing a fresh pair of boxers and a blue tanktop from his college, and grinding more weed. I laughed to myself at feeling a little disappointed that he was wearing a shirt, when I used to find his shirtlessness so obnoxious.
"Hey, man," he said to me as I came in and sat down on the other side of the couch. "What would you say if I ordered a pizza or two?"
I appreciated that he was acting normal despite the fact that not very long ago he had fucked my girlfriend in front of me and I had taken his 8-inch cock down my throat. "I would say that's a great idea. Riley likes mushrooms," I said.
"I remember," he said, smiling a little at me as he packed a bowl.
I couldn't help but laugh. "So...pretty weird, huh?" I said.
He shrugged casually. "You're not the first 'straight' guy to suck my dick. I was in a frat, and I definitely, uh, opened the eyes of a couple closet cases to new opportunities."
"Heh. Opened their throats, you mean?"
"You know it. Happy to do it for them as long as they don't get any ideas about fucking me," he said.
"Did you, uh, ever fuck any of them?" I asked.
"Nah, never got that far," he said. "You've got a tight little ass, though, so I could probably help you out there."
I rubbed my hand on the back of my neck nervously, watching as Chris took a hit from the bowl. "Yeah, well, I was actually telling Riley this earlier...I know I said that before, but I'm not really into that, I just kind of said it in the heat of the moment, ya know?"