After the spontaneous fuck Vanessa laid down beside me, spent, and put her head on my chest. We were quiet for quite a while, both thinking of the memory she had shared about fucking her work colleague in public.
"You really are ok with all this, right?" she asked sweetly and earnestly.
I nodded and quietly told her truthfully, "I am."
She giggled softly and ran her hand in my chest hair, "I'm a lucky girl." she smiled. I looked at her beautiful face as she stared up at the ceiling.
"You'll always be my puppy." she said with a little sigh. Then, with a mischievous lilt, "my little cuck puppy."
For some reason hearing her say that made my limp cock twitch a little. I wasn't sure if she noticed, but after a moment she continued, "You like that, right? Being my little cuck puppy? Knowing what a naughty slut I am? Wondering who I might be fucking when I'm not with you?"
My cock twitched again, involuntarily responding to her even though we'd just fucked. "Mmmmm...I bet you jack off when you're alone, imagining me with other guys?"
Vanessa's head jerked up a little like she had been struck by a thought. "Wait...am I the first girl who has cucked you?" she asked.
I was quiet, remembering my first girlfriend. "Ohhhhh...I'm not am I?" she laughed. "You tell me. Tell me who made you her cuckold first!" I mumbled and tried to deflect but she was not letting me off the hook.
"Well...I mean I was just 18...a kid......it's embarrassing...Do I...?"
Vanessa, grabbed my chin with her hand and made me look into her beautiful, penetrating eyes. "Yes. You do. Tell me. From the start"
We both knew I was going to obey. I took a deep breath. "Well...I was a shy kid...and she was my first girlfriend. Her name was Luna and she was short with an average face but big tits and was quite popular. I had seen her in school and thought she was sexy, but she was dating one football player, then a lacrosse player. We were in a summer science class together, and we were assigned to a joint project. I knew I didn't have a shot with her so I was...more relaxed you know? We were at her place working on it one night and her mom worked afternoon shifts so we were alone. I was doing all the work, but I think she got bored and...she started to kiss me. She had more experience, I guess a lot more. Of course I got super excited and before I knew it she on top of me and we were fucking. I came really quickly but she seemed to enjoy taking my virginity. I started going there every day after her mom left for work. I'd help her with hour homework, then we'd fuck. She was going out of state at the end of summer, but I had fallen for her completely."
"Ooohhh", Vanessa cooed, "my puppy must have been so so excited. Did Luna teach you a lot?"
I blushed and she wrapped her little fingers around my cock, giving it a squeeze. "Yes...I mean of course, I was thinking about her all the time...and I tried to remember what she taught me to make her feel good but...I could never last long..."
"Mmmm...is that why she made you her cuck?"
I felt myself harden, and I swallowed, "Yes," I answered a little hoarsely, "I guess...I mean it just kinda happened."
"I love it," Vanessa giggled, "tell me every detail."
"Well, one day I went to her place at the regular time. Her mom's car was gone, but she didn't answer the door. I was, you know, really excited to fuck her so I tried the door and when I opened I hear music coming from her room upstairs. I went up and..."
"Oh no!" Vanessa said, clearly into the story.
"Yeah...she was in bed, naked, on all fours, getting fucked hard from behind by a jock. She turned and saw me but didn't say anything."
I took a deep breath and continued, "I stood there, really shocked. The guy realized I was at the door but he didn't stop fucking her, he just kind of slowed down a little."
"Ouch," Vanessa lamented, "that must have hurt."
"Yeah," I answered. I felt vulnerable telling her all this, but I trusted Vanessa and she was sweetly stroking my hardening cock as I talked. "When I realized she wasn't going to apologize, was just going to...to keep fucking him, I ran out, tears forming in my eyes.
Luna called me later that night but I didn't answer. I skipped class with her the next day and she called again a few times that night. Finally I picked up. She was more relaxed than I expected but she apologized...'sorry about what happened last night...' She told me she had met up with her ex and they had a few drinks and she let him take her. Then she really surprised me by casually adding, 'He'll be back again tomorrow, you can come to my house and watch us fuck if you want to.'"
"Wow," Vanessa expressed, stopping her stroking for a moment.