"Would you really?" I asked with a shocked while trying to keep a calm demeaner - however thoughts of jealousy pumped in my veins. Sitting on the couch Sara, my girlfriend, and I came across a threesome scene in the TV show we happened to be watching. This got us talking to have her reveal she would participate in a two male threesome if the scenario ever presented itself.
"I mean yeah, Why not? You know I like to be the center of attention and having two guys paying all there attention on me, I don't know, that sounds intriguing to me," Sara, 19, explained. Sara is an attractive pale skinned slightly plump, though I wouldn't describe her that way to her face, natural dark haired redhead. The plumpness is very attractive as it also applies to her big C breast which aren't so much perky as hang off her chest.
"I'm just a little surprised that's all. I wouldn't have guessed is all" playing cool.
"Oh," she laughed, "I'm a slut if I want two dicks, but two vaginas for a guy is macho?"
I fake laughed, "I never said that," I said before trying to turn this conversation around, "You know... I think it's uh... I actually love how open you are with all this with me," pivoting to make me sound like the open minded heroic boyfriend.
"I have never told anyone that before," she confessed, "plus it's never going to happen."
"What if I made it happen?" I asked this before actually taking the time to determine my own feelings on this fantasy becoming reality.
"Oh, I could never do that with you," sternly admitting. Taken aback finding words to react to this rejection. Sara sensed this putting her arm on my shoulder, "It's not because you're not good in bed or anything Tim, you're the best sex I've ever had, You know you're the best sex Ive ever had, right?" I nodded in return - Sara is phenomenal in comforting me. She continued, "It's because I love you and a threesome would have to be loveless. I would look at you and feel like I'm cheating and feel bad, but two rando dicks, meh" she laughed, "Again, it's not going to happen. We are totally going to get married one day, my window passed for crazy college things like that."
Placing my hand on her leg I kissed her. This should have been the end of it, but that night as my cock was plunged in and out if her pale redhaired pussy my mind kept coming back to the thought of her fantasy which surprisingly made my toes curl, ass flex and cock exploid way earlier than I would have expected.
Laying on top of her, catching my breathe, with my cock shrinking and bathing in my cum filled condom I joked, "Sorry babe, I can't be the best sex every night!"
She found my humor amusing, "It's okay," pulling me in with her legs, though my cock was already placid, "You're the best boyfriend everyday." She always knew what to say before she got up to pee and head back to her own apartment.
Fast forward a 2 months and our relationship foundation wasn't nearly as strong as it once was. As easy as it was for two 19 year old's to fall in love we were quickly falling out of it - everything seemed to spark arguments, the idea of missing out on the college experience was brought up a few times, though deep down I believed that to be a cover up for our connection simply fading.
"Alright how hard are we going tonight?" I asked Sara as we walked into a Friday night party. Our relationship could use a win tonight or else I think the number of fights and "miss communications" might be the end for us.
"Um moderate to potentially a lot" Sara joked. Walking into the college frat house we were instantly asked if we wanted to take shots - which we obliged. "Oof," I let out though Sara handled her liquor better that I did not making a sound as the liquor cleared her throat.
I thought the night was starting off well until I reached my hand out to grab Sara's hand as we explored the house she denied me putting her hands into her coat pockets. Was this her proactively denying me or a case of miscommunication and she didn't notice my at attempt at affection.
"Hey you want to play us?" two gentlemen shouted to Sara inviting her to play beer pong.
"Sure!" Sara shrugged.
"You got a partner to play with you?" one of the guys asked.
Sara looked around before casually pointing to me, "want to play?"
"Yeah that would be fun," saying hoping this would build a team bond between us though she was still feeling a bit cold and distant.
"Was hoping for another hot girl type, but he'll do I guess," one of the laughed. These two guys were Jason and Darius. Jason was a shaved head kind of skinny guy with a bmx shirt while Darius was a darker mixed skin guy who wore the schools soccer logo on his shirt.
The game was a competitive one with Sara pulling our team. Both kept flirty with Sara throughout the game. As the game got down to the wite Sara removed her jacket, "Oh my god dude!" Darius holding a fist to his mouth to shouting to Jason not being shy about observing Sara's cleavage. Sara rolled her eyes, buy her flush face told me a different story of her response.
The game came to a finish when Sara threw the ball into the last cup taking the win to our team. A small crowd that had begun to watch cheered - Sara's smile was remarkable, but before I could get to her Darius hugged and lifted her up her skirt rising a bit when he did so - which I saw Jason not shy away from admiring.
Jason came in for a hug next, "Good game!"
"Hey, alright that's enough" Darius laughed breaking up the hug, "You know I already called dibs."
"Darius here is a bit delusional on his accounts of history sometimes because I called dibs," Jason shot back.
"Boys," Sara laughed rolling her eyes. It was then I realized they didn't know we were dating - I guess from the outside we didn't appear as a couple.
"Why don't you both take her home," I inserted arrogantly.
There was silence. Everyone looked at each other.
Sara squinted her eyes and shook her head dumbfounded at me.
"Jason, I'm not hearing a no?" Darius said.
"I didn't hear a no either," Jason responded looking towards Sara.
"You guys are insane," Sara laughed.
"That maybe true - That's still not a no," Darius fired back, "Jay would you?"
"The three of us? For her I think I would," Jason responded.
"You all are ridiculous. No. Happy now?" Sara said.
"Why not?" I asked - actually upset as she wasn't putting any effort into our relationship.
"Tim! Can we talk?" Sara said seriously grabbing my arm and walking off.
"Put in a good word Tim!" Darius shouted.
Off in a little corner of the backyard, "What? What is going on?"
"Nothing, I just thought you wanted to try two guys."
"When did I say that?"
