I told her my favorite fantasy was where she was on her stomach with her legs open and sucking a guy while I did her bottom with my tongue. It was one night when she was particularly accessible and willing to talk sex, telling me about guys she had done, what she liked, and who she had done it with. She was unbelievably candid. When I told her about my fantasy, she actually said it sounded fun and she might be willing to do it.
"You really would?" I asked.
"Maybe," she said with a laugh in her voice. I went on to describe it in more detail, and she seemed to enjoy hearing it. She asked if I would rather do her bottom, or would I do her pussy and I said 'maybe both.'
I asked her about her favorite fantasies and she talked about some. One involved her with two guys, one in her mouth and one in her pussy. I told her I liked that image, saying I could see her being fucked while sucking off another guy. I even said I would like to see it. She told me she had thought about that fairly often.
"Once a week?" I asked.
"Maybe that often," she said. "Sometimes more." I said I liked that she had fantasies, and asked if she ever masturbated to any of them. "Some," she replied with a grin, slightly embarrassed to admit it.
"It's good that you do," I said. "I like it. That means you enjoy sex. Think you'd ever do it with someone else?"
"Maybe," she said with a chuckle. "If it was right. Right time, right situation." I went on to tell her some of my other fantasies. Then she said sometimes she thought of things she'd done with other guys.
"Like what?" I asked.
"Like my bus trip," she said. I asked her to tell me about it and she went on to described a trip she had taken in high school when she made out with a guy on the bus that she had just met. "I let him finger me under my panties," she confessed. "Then I sucked him under the blanket."
"That's hot," I said. "Tell me more."
"Well, I think a man on the bus saw us and watched. I liked that he saw us, and it made it even sexier. I think he knew I was sucking that guy and I liked that he knew. I liked showing off for him."
"You're a little exhibitionist," I said, teasing her about liking to give a blow job when someone was watching. "You ever fuck for someone to watch?" I asked. She blushed and said she never had. "Ever want to?" I asked.
"Maybe," she said. "If things were right." We went on to talk about fucking, and fantasies, and what we may someday do, and then we fucked again and it was especially intense. When she came it was with a shout and a prolonged shriek that could have frightened the neighbors.
"That was fun," I said when our breathing returned to normal. In was probably a few days later, after we'd had sex, that I brought up my favorite fantasy of her blowing a guy while I did her bottom with my tongue. Again she said she liked it and the wheels began turning. I decided right then to try to make it happen. I began to think of guys I thought she might be attracted to, then started looking for ways to bring it about.
I settled on a couple of my friends and thought I would bring it up to her and see how she reacted. If she seemed open to it I would go ahead and put things in motion. The thought of this fantasy becoming reality energized me to an amazing degree. The next time we engaged in pillow talk about our sexual fantasies I brought it up again and asked directly who she would rather fuck, Jake, Paul, or Matt?
Without hesitation she said Matt and smiled. "So you've thought of him before?" I asked with a kiss. She simply nodded, as if saying it aloud was more public, more shameless. I said I could understand, and I could. Matt was tall and handsome, with an athlete's build and a wide, winning smile. I suspected he was very sexy to women, and I knew Claire liked looking. It was simply obvious when you saw how she looked at certain men. Not only could I understand, I could also see him being attracted to Claire, and in fact, I had fantasized seeing them together many times.
I had pictured the two of them fucking, seeing in my mind him pushing his erect cock into her pussy repeatedly. I had even featured him in my favorite with him sitting on the bed with his legs open and my wife on her stomach with his cock in her hand and her mouth around the tip with me behind her, watching her suck him, my tongue licking her tiny hole from behind.
It was actually my go-to fantasy most often enjoyed when I was masturbating. I loved the thought of her sucking him while I watched, giving her pleasure with my tongue as I viewed them. The first time I had this fantasy was while we were at a swingers convention as a bookseller, not a participant, but I fantasized about us having a threesome and my doing her anus as she sucked off one of the men there.