Here are a few words of introduction to help you set the stage. Real people inspired these stories the names are fictional. If it was a she and she told me how she felt or what she did I'll put it in her voice when possible.
I met Carri through her brother. We went out, it got sexual, and eventually it got a little kinky. During sex or after Carri would always talk about how big I was. At first it was flattering, but became very repetitive, and eventually became patronizing. I asked her about this, since I went to a "nude beach" an hour or so away, and knew I was not that big. Over the years I'd gotten to know some of the single guys who came out regularly, and even a few couples. I had the feeling that Carri was very experienced, and knew that there were much larger out there. I'm not a miniature, there's seven or eight in length and about five or so in circumference, but if you've ever been to a clothing optional beach, (most nude beaches are not completely nude-in fact most of the time there are equal amounts of people in bathing suits, or topless, and then of course some naked) then you know that a lot of the guys there a really well hung.
At any rate I told her I just knew she'd seen a lot bigger cocks, but of course she said no while reiterating what a turn on it was to have such a big well-proportioned cock. Carri was accustomed to nudity and often went naked around the house . . . curtains up or down, lights off or on, doors open or closed, and sometimes with or without company. It seemed a natural progression to ask her to go to the lake with me. At first she declined, but it didn't take much talking to persuade her. It was almost like a dare-come with me and admit there are bigger fish in the sea, or stop acting like this is such a big deal.
A little about the layout of the lake is helpful. It is a park with a large parking lot that gradually slopes to a wooded area. About a hundred yards on paths through the wooded area, and then another ten to twenty yards to the water. If the lake is high the water comes to or almost to the woods. There are trails worn in the woods that run parallel to the water. In later years they paved them, even put in a service road and began charging admission-but this was still the old days of dirt paths. There are park rangers who patrol on foot, and some of them are not tolerant of any sexual activity-but some surprisingly are. It is a lot more crowded on the weekend, but Thursday and Friday pick up too.
People usually park in the parking lot, hike down to the beach area, and remove however much they dare near the water's edge. Some more daring exhibitionist types would simple leave their clothes in the car and walk down nude, or perhaps wrapped in only a towel. Then occasionally the pretty wild ones would drive up nude. Unfortunately, the last two categories weren't usually ladies, but if so, they were usually pretty wild. Even so, most of them were with boyfriends or husbands. Sometimes they were swinger types and a single guy could get lucky. The rarest of the rare was a woman who would drive up alone naked, but thankfully there were a few.
The first time I talked Carri into going it was summer and there was a good crowd. The parking lot was full. I knew she was going to get her eyes full. After we parked, I kind of took her on a guided tour. I kept my clothes on and didn't ask her to take hers off either. As we got through the woods on the main path I took her to the right and down one of the well worn paths paralleling the lake front where the swimmers and sun bathers were. We were ten yards or more behind the sunbathers and still on the path in the woods when I caught a glimpse of one of the regulars, "Big Ray". He is not tall, but rather has about fourteen inches of dick. Yes, he's measured it.
Ray was crouched in the woods behind some of the trees and bushes and jacking off, while scoping out an attractive woman and her husband who were laid out nude maybe five to ten yards in front of him. Since he did not turn around Carri had no idea that he was masturbating-much less how large he was. We passed by him without his noticing and as we turned left toward the lake and the sunbathers I told Carri that she should go over to Ray and ask him the time. She looked at me like I was crazy, but went over anyway. As she got closer it started to hit her what was going on. Ray noticed her as she got closer, and never one to miss a chance to have his cock admired, turned and faced her full frontal. His prick almost touched her as he turned. Carri did everything she could to keep from looking down, but eventually I could see her head tilt, they carried on a brief conversation and she returned.
"Well I guess that settles that doesn't it." I said
"Oh, I don't know what you mean." Carri lied.